‘New Moon’ review: The movie misses Robert Pattinson ... and Catherine Hardwicke


This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.


It’s almost here, Twi-hards. Today, in our ongoing daily countdown to ‘The Twilight Saga: New Moon,’ we bring you the review of the film by Los Angeles Times film critic Kenneth Turan, who believes the film suffers from the absence of Robert Pattinson and the mad-love sensibilities of Catherine Hardwicke.


‘This is the last time you’ll ever see me,’ Edward Cullen says to Bella Swan. As if.

Spoken early on in ‘New Moon,’ that promise is one of the least likely to be kept in movie history. With most of that film still to unfold, and two more adaptations of Stephenie Meyer’s ‘Twilight’ series in the works, the next due out as soon as next summer, the world is going to see as much of Kristen Stewart’s melancholy Bella and Robert Pattinson’s undead Edward as it can take. Maybe more.

In the short term, however, Edward is as good as his word, and ‘New Moon’ suffers as a result. Constrained by the plot of the novel, the film keeps the two lovers apart for quite a spell, robbing the project of the crazy-in-love energy that made ‘Twilight,’ the first entry in the series, such a guilty pleasure.

‘New Moon,’ which has been grandly titled ‘The Twilight Saga: New Moon’ in honor of that first episode’s huge success, marks the franchise’s entrance into the self-protective, don’t-rock-the-boat phase of its existence, which is inevitable but a bit of a shame.

In place of ‘Twilight’ director Catherine Hardwicke, a filmmaker of intense, sometimes overwhelming and out-of-control emotionality who seemed to feel these teenage characters in her bones, ‘New Moon’ has gone with the more polished Chris Weitz.

A smooth professional whose credits include such adaptations as ‘The Golden Compass’ and ‘About a Boy,’ Weitz makes the vampire trains of Melissa Rosenberg’s capable script run on time, but he almost seems too rational a director for this kind of project. This lack of animating madness combined with the novel’s demands give much of ‘New Moon’ a marking time quality.

Yes, I know, ‘New Moon’s’ emotional energy is supposed to come through Bella’s putative attachment to newly buff best friend Jacob Black (Taylor Lautner). But though audiences gasp when Jacob uses his shirt to staunch Bella’s blood (don’t ask) and reveals a torso that would make Charles Atlas swoon, the connection between these two is so self-evidently non-romantic that it turns out not to be much of a diversion.

More interesting is Jacob’s discovery that as a member of the fierce Quileute tribe he is prone to turning into an exceptionally large wolf at a moment’s notice, a wolf whose main objective in life is to safeguard humans from vampires. In addition to pining for Edward, Bella suddenly finds herself in the middle of age-old and bitter enmities. This is one hard-luck young woman...



‘New Moon’ premiere shines in Westwood

‘Twilight’ producer: Lautner is going to blow people away with his acting

Robert Pattinson, object of obsession

‘New Moon’ and ‘Lawrence of Arabia’? Let Chris Weitz explain

‘Twilight’ screenwriter says second film is better

Stephenie Meyer breaks silence on ‘Oprah’

Stephenie Meyer and the future of ‘Midnight Sun’

Robert Pattinson talks about his career ‘backup plan’