Beethoven's 10th Symphony--or, at least, a movement of it--made its belated debut in London Tuesday night, and initial critical reaction was hardly an ode to joy. The piece--the result of five years' work by musicologist Barry Cooper--was generally agreed to be "Beethovenian," but the authenticity of the work was brought into question repeatedly. "(Cooper's) statement that 'about two-thirds of it is based directly on Beethoven's sketches' begs an awful lot of questions, especially when we are concerned with a composer of such notoriously untidy working habits," wrote Paul Griffiths in the Times of London. Countered the Guardian's Edward Greenfield: "Though even Dr. Cooper would never assert that it was what Beethoven would finally have delivered . . . I marvel that the long Andante sections which framed this unexpectedly structured movement are so genuinely Beethovenian." Walter Weller conducted the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra in the 162-year-old work's premiere at Royal Festival Hall. Added violinist/conductor Sir Yehudi Menuhin, who conducted the second half of the concert: "I think it is a valuable work. It is certainly Beethoven. I have huge admiration and respect for Dr. Cooper, who has done an extremely good job."
Arts and entertainment reports from The Times, national and international news services and the nation's press
Copyright © 2019, Los Angeles Times