Santa Ana Jury Awards 2 Lawyers 3% of Thriving Baseball Card Firm
- Share via
SANTA ANA — An Orange County Superior Court jury on Wednesday unanimously agreed with two local attorneys who have long insisted that they own a 3% share in Upper Deck Co., the fast-growing baseball-card company.
The 12-member Santa Ana jury deliberated for more than a day before determining that Upper Deck executives gave the 3% share to attorney Andrew Passante Jr. in 1988. Passante subsequently agreed to split the 3% stake with Andrew J. Prendiville, said Vincent J. Bartolotta Jr., who represented Passante and Prendiville.
A spokesman for Upper Deck would not comment on Wednesday’s verdict. Upper Deck President Richard P. McWilliam previously denied that Passante had been granted the 3% share.
Bartolotta said evidence presented during the trial proved that Passante received the 3% share in 1988, in large part for work he handled while serving as Upper Deck’s first corporate attorney. Passante “was there at a critical point in the company’s history,” Bartolotta said. “He arranged for a $100,000 loan that literally saved the company.”
Passante agreed to split the 3% share with Prendiville, another attorney who helped arrange the loan, Bartolotta said.
“Jurors determined that (Upper Deck) agreed to hold the 3% for Tony Passante,” Bartolotta said. “Now the only issue is what that 3% is worth.”
Jurors on Friday will begin deliberations on the value of that 3% stake, Bartolotta said.
Privately held Upper Deck, based in Carlsbad, does not release profit or revenue figures. However, the company redefined the $1-billion-plus collectible industry with its line of high-quality trading cards.
In 1991, Upper Deck moved from a cramped facility in Yorba Linda to a new, $12-million plant in Carlsbad. That same year, Upper Deck was named Inc. magazine’s manufacturing entrepreneur of the year in Orange County.
More to Read
Inside the business of entertainment
The Wide Shot brings you news, analysis and insights on everything from streaming wars to production — and what it all means for the future.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.