Advertisement

Key Whitewater Figure to Come Forward : Probe: Susan McDougal, a partner in the land deal, is scheduled to appear at a press conference. She is remembered as colorful, free-spending.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITERS

She is the mystery woman of the Whitewater saga--the one key witness who has as yet said nothing publicly about President Clinton’s Ozark Mountain land investment.

Susan McDougal, 38-year-old former wife of failed savings and loan owner James B. McDougal and former partner with the Clintons in the Whitewater Development Corp., is in a position to know about many unexplained aspects of the controversy now engulfing the White House.

Among other things, she could shed light on the central question in the case: Did Clinton and First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton personally benefit from savings and loan money funneled illegally into the Whitewater real estate venture?

Advertisement

In addition, McDougal’s version of the Whitewater story is likely to be every bit as colorful as it is informative.

A feisty, fun-loving woman, she is remembered vividly here because she appeared in hot pants and riding a white horse in a television commercial for one of her then-husband’s real estate developments and because her free-spending habits helped to bankrupt his savings and loan, costing U.S. taxpayers at least $47 million.

On Monday, McDougal, who has eluded reporters since the Whitewater controversy began, is promising to break her silence. Her lawyer, Bobby McDaniel, has scheduled a press conference for his client, who is preparing to tell her story to Whitewater special counsel Robert B. Fiske Jr.

Because McDougal has been implicated in many of the misdeeds involving her ex-husband’s Madison Guaranty Savings & Loan and Whitewater Development Corp., she is expected to seek immunity in exchange for her testimony. McDaniel acknowledged that he already has talked with the special counsel.

According to those who have talked with her recently, McDougal realizes that she is in a position to stir up trouble for the President and she is anxious to defend herself.

But it is not yet clear whether Clinton should fear her testimony.

While McDougal possesses inside knowledge of the Whitewater project that could substantially assist Fiske with his investigation, her friends and lawyers say she remains fiercely loyal to the Clintons and insistent that she is not guilty of any wrongdoing.

Advertisement

“Susan McDougal did not knowingly do anything wrong, and no one has shown that she did anything wrong,” McDaniel said.

An acquaintance added: “I don’t think she feels that she has any real smoking-gun evidence, but they are going to have to give her immunity to get her side.”

McDougal not only denies any fault in the Whitewater matter, she also insists that she is not guilty of more recent charges pending against her in Los Angeles that she stole $200,000 from famed conductor Zubin Mehta while working as his personal bookkeeper after she left Arkansas.

Leonard Levine, her Los Angeles attorney, said McDougal is confident she will be proven innocent of charges of embezzling from Mehta.

Clearly, McDougal’s story is one of rags to riches and back to rags.

From humble beginnings in Camden, Ark.--one of seven children born to a soldier father and Belgium-born immigrant mother--she became a highly visible Little Rock businesswoman with a flashy Jaguar and a reputation for what one of her friends described as “a shop-till-you-drop philosophy.”

Between 1984 and 1986, according to a bank examiner’s report on Madison Guaranty, she collected more than $1.5 million from the thrift, acting as the owner of a subsidiary advertising agency, known as Madison Marketing, that drained millions of dollars from the savings and loan.

Advertisement

She collected 15% commissions for doing the thrift’s advertising and public relations work, but she actually hired other firms to carry out the work, according to the government’s assessment of her role.

In her high-roller days, McDougal is said to have spent $1 million renovating and decorating a $200,000 house that she and her former husband bought in West Little Rock.

Her expensive tastes also dictated the expenditure of $600,000 to convert a former dry-cleaning establishment in a historic section of the city into an Art Deco headquarters for Madison Guaranty.

“Everything was paper hats and horns--a party all the time,” said an acquaintance familiar with McDougal’s business practices. “She thought her subdivisions were making money even when they were losing money.”

Now, McDougal is back on hard times--unemployed and living with her boyfriend, Eugene (Pat) Harris, a former Madison Guaranty real estate agent, in Nashville. By all accounts, she spends her days searching for work, talking with her lawyers and avoiding the reporters who frequently stalk her.

“Every day is not a party now,” commented one friend.

McDougal got to know the Clintons through her then-husband, whom she met in 1974 when she was a young drama student and he was a teacher at Ouachita Baptist University in Arkadelphia, Ark. She encountered him one day when she was trying to get into a locked office at the school and he kicked in the door for her.

Advertisement

James McDougal and Clinton were acquainted from their days working in the office of Sen. J. William Fulbright (D-Ark.).

Beginning in 1978, when the Clintons and the McDougals decided to develop vacation homes together in the Ozarks, Susan McDougal was privy to the many internal financial transactions of Whitewater Development for which there apparently no longer are complete records.

As a primary stockholder in Madison Guaranty and the owner of Madison Marketing, she may also know about thrift funds funneled through her company into the Whitewater venture.

McDougal could be able to explain the circumstances surrounding one transaction that has provoked particular suspicion. That is a November, 1985, check for $7,500 from Madison Marketing to Whitewater Development that was used to make a payment on a personal loan that the Clintons had taken out to build a model home on one of the Whitewater lots.

The check has been characterized by Clinton’s critics as evidence that, as governor of Arkansas, he may have benefited personally from payments from a state-regulated thrift.

In addition, investigators hope that McDougal can explain what happened to $300,000 she got from a small Arkansas investment firm also enmeshed in the Whitewater matter.

Advertisement

The firm’s owner claims that Clinton and James McDougal asked him to loan money to Susan McDougal, apparently to help prop up Madison Guaranty as it was staggering under the burden of bad loans.

She is known to have spent $110,000 to acquire an additional parcel of land for Whitewater Development, but it is not known where the remainder of the money went. The loan was backed by federal Small Business Administration funds.

Even though they were business partners, McDougal’s former husband seems to have no idea how she will answer these questions. He claims that she always operated independently of him.

“I didn’t see it as an adjunct to my activities,” he said in an interview. “I saw her as an individual with a right to her own ambitions and undertakings.”

Throughout their marriage, he said, his former wife kept her finances separate from his. “She did not have to ask me when she wanted to buy something,” he said.

Susan McDougal, however, tells a different story, saying in her rare comments that he handled the family’s money.

Advertisement

The McDougals separated in May, 1984. In 1986, when they were ousted from the management of Madison Guaranty by federal regulators, James McDougal--his health deteriorating--is said to have accepted the move with quiet resignation, but thrift executives remember that Susan McDougal, who remained a stockholder, fought to keep her management ties.

Even now, with the legal system putting pressure on her, she is described by friends and acquaintances as “very strong, very loyal, very bright . . , a survivor . . , very anxious to have her side of this come out.”

As she points out in conversations with friends, she was never charged with any crime when James McDougal was tried and acquitted for bank fraud.

And even though the McDougals have been separated for nearly a decade, the financial web they wove together has kept them “inextricably intertwined,” as James McDougal put it. They divide the small returns that the land development still produces and will share in the proceeds of a defense fund their lawyers are establishing.

In addition, although their divorce became final in 1990 while Susan McDougal was living in California, the McDougals still seem to have a fond sentimental attachment. “We go to the same funerals,” her former husband said.

Advertisement