Advertisement

COVER STORY : Strength in Diversity : Autry museum honors the West’s multicultural roots, unsaddling celluloid cowboys and cliches.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITER

It was an unexpected juxtaposition. A Japanese-American woman in the loveliest of kimonos poured tea according to an ancient ritual. Nearby, two men wearing string ties oohed and aahed at a larger-than-life bronze statue of singing cowboy Gene Autry, posed alongside his faithful horse, Champion.

If you came to the Gene Autry Western Heritage Museum expecting a curator of chaps or do-si-docents, forget it. Welcome to the surprisingly polycultural Autry, where diversity is an important part of the program.

Dedicated to explicating the American West, the Autry might have taken the low road and celebrated the predominantly white West of celluloid and cliche--the monosyllabic cowboy, his freckled skin turning to leather in the sun; the frontier wife, ready to defend to the death her clutch of towheads; the imperial explorers and terminally grizzled mountain men.

Advertisement

Those icons of the Old West are certainly represented at the Autry, whose treasures range from Albert Bierstadt paintings to chenille kiddie curtains bearing the hallowed name of Hopalong Cassidy. But the Griffith Park museum is devoting an increasing amount of money, time and space to showing visitors that the American West was created not just by Anglos but by people of diverse ethnic and cultural origins.

As Mexican-American staffer Mary Ann Ruelas says, with obvious relief, “I think people are beginning to understand we’re more than Gene’s closet or the Giddyup Museum.”

The Autry’s commitment to multiculturalism isn’t new. Since its founding in 1988, the Autry has surprised thousands of visitors with the fact that many cowboys were African American. The often heart-breaking history of Native Americans is an essential part of the Western tale the museum attempts to tell. A current exhibit documents the unique contribution of Japanese-American women to Western life, and past shows have chronicled the contributions of Russians and Italians. Only last year, the museum initiated an annual Juneteenth celebration to mark the end of slavery in the traditional style of the black communities of Texas.

But the Autry’s commitment to polyculturalism is being reaffirmed in a major way with a new permanent gallery, to open Memorial Day weekend. Called the Spirit of Community, the gallery will show how six different ethnic or cultural groups interacted with the dominant Anglo-American culture in and around the year 1890.

The new exhibit, which cost $500,000, was conceived by Michael Duchemin, the Autry’s curator of history. “It came about,” Duchemin says, “because the museum recognized that we weren’t diverse enough in our representation and interpretation of the history of the West.” To counter that deficiency, Duchemin proposed that the museum tell the interconnected stories of seven Western communities: Anglo American, Asian, Mexican, Native American, African American, Canadian and Mormon.

As Duchemin explains, each of these groups was a major player in the West of 1890. In that turbulent year, the year the Mormon church officially renounced polygamy, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints had 150,000 followers in the American West. Some were Mormons who had trekked to Utah after anti-Mormon violence farther east, only to find themselves hounded by evangelical Protestants who urged them to “Get right with God!” Others were recent European converts to Mormonism, many of whom sailed from the English port of Liverpool on their journey to what would soon become the 45th state. Only immigrants of German origin were more numerous than Mormons in the West in 1890, Duchemin says.

Advertisement

The Spirit of Community exhibit will consist of artifacts, maps, photographic enlargements and other objects, plus explanatory material. Each community’s material will be displayed behind Plexiglas in cases--one to a cultural group--that resemble buildings. The exterior architecture of each of these display areas relates to the group whose story is being told. Thus, the Mexican area appears to be made of stuccoed adobe (it’s actually made of fire-retardant materials, including fiberglass), with a tile roof and the distinctive canales , or rain gutters, typical of Spanish colonial architecture.

The Asian area--mostly devoted to the Chinese--takes a different architectural tack. By 1890, many Western Chinese were concentrated in urban Chinatowns that had formerly housed non-Asians. Given this history, the exhibit’s Asian space looks like one of the brick buildings, designed by Anglo-American architects, that filled the downtowns of San Francisco and other Western cities. But the building has been modified by its Asian occupants. Its window sills and doorway have been painted, and streamers have been hung, in the bright purples, yellows and greens that the Chinese believed brought prosperity and other things devoutly to be wished.

At the center of the exhibit is a fabulous artifact--a gleaming Silsby steam-operated fire engine, made about 1860, that was the pride of Carson City, Nev. You can look at the fire engine from two very different points of view. “From one perspective, it shows the power and dominance of the Anglo community,” Duchemin says. But a fire was one of the few occasions when the ethnically polarized towns of Western America might all work together for the common good so “it can also be seen as a unifying piece,” he says. Duchemin trusts that visitors will make up their own minds.

From the beginning, the project was conceived as a collaborative effort between the museum and the communities being featured. The Autry enlisted the help of a panel of museum consultants who are themselves members of the ethnic or cultural groups involved. The advisers each have a professional’s understanding of what makes an evocative exhibit and other museum expertise. But each is also an ethnic insider, who can bring his or her own experience and special sensitivity to bear on the project.

The consultants have been very much involved, Duchemin says. They have vetted the “scripts” that are the basis for the signage and other written materials in the exhibit. And they have been invaluable in ensuring that each ethnic story is told in its own voice, not that of the dominant culture. Eventually, the Autry hopes to have a community-based advisory board, with a revolving membership of 25 or 30 people.

As one example of the consultant’s insight, Duchemin points to Suellen Cheng’s insistence that the woman featured in the Asian section be a merchant’s wife, not a prostitute, as were many of the first Chinese women in the West. Cheng, a curator at El Pueblo de Los Angeles Historic Monument, objected to focusing too much attention on a woman who was essentially a slave, without influence. She argued persuasively that wives, while few in number, were more representative after the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 barred unmarried Chinese women from entering the country. Moreover, Cheng insisted, wives and mothers were more central to the creation of community than marginal members of the demimonde.

An embroidered silk wedding costume is included in the Asian section, Osage marriage garb in the Native-American section. Eventually, the museum would like a wedding dress for every community featured in the exhibit.

Advertisement

Ethnic interaction in 1890 wasn’t always pretty, and that, too, is reflected in the exhibit. One of the less attractive European-immigrant artifacts is a ballot for the San Francisco-based Workingmen’s Party. This largely Irish organization ran its candidates on a shamelessly anti-Chinese platform. Some of the interactions are quite unexpected. One striking artifact is evidence that, at some point in the late 19th Century, a Navajo weaver chose to decorate her blanket or rug with stylized images of African-American cowboys.

The new exhibit will occupy about 2,800 square feet, with each constituent community assigned about 125 square feet of display area. Between each ethnic display will be a recessed area (the staff calls them fiords) where docents will be able to gather a small group of school-age visitors out of the flow of traffic. Each ethnic display will include a hidden “education box” filled with replicas of relevant artifacts that the children can handle. A built-in camp stool opens into the fiord so the docent can sit down as she teaches her charges.

The exhibit’s multiculturalism extends to the docents themselves. The Autry’s education department tapped docents from each of the cultural communities represented and asked them if they would share their own family histories with visitors. As a result, volunteer Winnie Lu will tell how her grandfather practiced Chinese herbal medicine. And Jean Fernilius, a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, will show youngsters a replica of the autograph book her great-grandfather kept in prison where he was incarcerated for having more than one wife.

Turning to museum staffers for ethnic information has worked well for the museum in the past. When creating its Children’s Discovery Gallery in 1992, the museum decided to build the please-touch exhibit around the Mexican-American ranching family of Mary Ann Ruelas, assistant director of programs.

The treasures that filled the Tucson townhouse of Ruelas’ grandparents have been painstakingly reproduced, down to the traditional paper cutouts, called papel picado, that hung on the walls. By involving its own ethnic expert, the museum was able to get ongoing feedback about the accuracy of the exhibit. Ruelas objected, for instance, when the family ranch house was shown with sections of the adobe exposed, unprotected by stucco and, thus, at risk of melting away in a heavy rain.

“That’s like showing your house with the windows broken,” Ruelas protested. She also pointed out that her family had lived in Arizona, not California, and so the exhibit’s simulation of an afternoon sky was repainted minus the Southland pinks and mauves.

Advertisement

Ruelas was a learner in the course of the project as well as a teacher. While sharing information with other family members, she discovered that some of her ancestors may have been Conversos, Jews who had been pressured into converting to Catholicism by the Spanish Inquisition but secretly adhered to such Jewish practices as not mixing meat and dairy products at the same meal.

One result of the Autry’s drive for multiculturism is that it is attracting a more diverse audience. Last year’s Juneteenth celebration drew 3,000 people, most of them African American. As education associate Lori Givens points out, “It brought a lot of people here who didn’t think there was anything here for them.”

Givens thinks African Americans and other minority visitors are also heartened when they learn that the Autry has ongoing relationships with ethnic institutions such as the California African American Museum. “People feel a little safer that their story will be told responsibly,” says Givens, who recently planned children’s programs on the Buffalo soldiers and other African-American themes for Black History Month.

The Spirit of Community gallery will open May 28, but it won’t be finished, says Duchemin. As the curator explains, it is his hope that the visitors who come to see how their ancestors struggled in the American West will become actively involved with the exhibit, which will change over time. The curator hopes that these ad hoc ethnic experts will be quick to tell the staff what it got right and what it didn’t.

“A lot more dialogue is required,” he says. Duchemin also hopes that visitors will bring their own ethnic artifacts--also known as family treasures--to add to the evolving display.

WHERE AND WHEN

* What: Spirit of Community gallery at the Gene Autry Western Heritage Museum.

* Location: 4700 Western Heritage Way, Griffith Park, next to the Los Angeles Zoo.

* Hours: Opens May 28. Museum hours are 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., Tuesdays through Sundays.

* Admission: $7 general, $5 seniors and students with ID, $3 children ages 2 through 12.

* Call: (213) 667-2000.

Advertisement