Big Market Shifts Could Result if Dollar Is Turning
When something goes in one general direction for 10 years--say, like the dollar’s fall in value against the Japanese yen--the safest assumption to make is that the trend will continue forever. Why fight it?
That at least partly explains why so many people have trouble believing that the dollar’s rebound, from its historic low of 80 yen in April to just over 90 yen now, is more than a temporary aberration.
But what if the dollar has turned for good? Many investors might have to rethink their expectations for global stock and bond markets. Japanese and European stocks, overshadowed by U.S. stocks’ surge this year, could begin to look much more appealing. And interest rates in Europe, well above U.S. rates, could come down if shifting currency values promote the flow of capital to Europe.
The dollar’s latest rally, a 3.3% rise against the yen on Wednesday, came on the heels of the Japanese government’s surprise announcement that it will change accounting rules and other guidelines to encourage more foreign investment by Japanese institutional investors.
Theories abounded as to what, exactly, the Japanese government is up to. The official line from Tokyo, of course, was that Japan wants a weaker yen to restore some of the competitive edge Japanese companies have lost as the strong yen has squeezed the country’s export machine.
If Japan begins investing overseas again in a big way--recycling its trade surplus wealth--the yen should fall because institutional investors will be selling yen to buy other currencies.
*
In the process, those investors will get capital moving once again within the calcifying, bad-loan-burdened Japanese banking system, says Bluford Putnam, chief markets strategist at Bankers Trust Co. in New York.
And that is by far the Japanese government’s more important objective, he argues. “There’s only one way to fix the Japanese banking system, and that’s to flood it with money,” Putnam says. Japan has capital, but it needs to be unfrozen. If now-skittish lenders begin extending new loans and making new investments, fresh profits will cover old losses from the crash in stock and real estate values. The system will be renewed.
Sound familiar? “That’s exactly parallel with what the Federal Reserve did” in the early ‘90s, Putnam notes, when the U.S. central bank slashed short-term interest rates and re-liquefied the troubled American banking system.
One big bull on Japan is Barton Biggs, the well-known investment strategist for Morgan Stanley & Co. in New York. For the last two months he has been telling clients that the mighty yen has peaked and that the Japanese stock market is a screaming buy. The recent talk of depression and financial collapse in Japan, Biggs insists, is a classic sign of a market bottom.
In Santa Monica, hedge-fund manager Mark Strome also is convinced that the yen will continue to weaken. Changes in government policy such as those announced in Japan this week, Strome says, “Always come after the fundamentals have already turned,” in this case against the yen.
While many analysts doubt that Japanese insurance companies and other investors will ramp-up foreign investment again--after being burned for years overseas as the strong yen devalued their foreign holdings--Strome thinks otherwise. “There is such a herd mentality there that when one investor makes money [overseas], and others see it, they’ll [buy] too,” he says.
Just in the move from 80 to 90 yen to the dollar, a Japanese investor’s U.S. securities have automatically appreciated 12.5%.
Yet some analysts believe the initial investment push by Japanese institutions will be into Europe rather than into America. Bonds of most European countries yield more than U.S. bonds, and the German mark--Europe’s key currency--is perceived as a safer store of value than the dollar.
If Japanese money does flow into Europe, interest rates there could fall, which would naturally be bullish for European stocks as well.
Indeed, it may not be a coincidence that many foreign stock markets have risen sharply since mid-May--when the yen began to slide--after treading water for much of winter and spring. And most other foreign currencies haven’t even weakened against the dollar so far.
Bill Wilby, manager of the Oppenheimer Global stock fund in New York, says a rebound in the dollar should mean that export-oriented European and Japanese stocks will do “quite well,” while export-oriented U.S. stocks--Wall Street’s leaders this year--could fade, at least temporarily.
Even allowing for the devaluation effect of a stronger dollar on U.S. investors’ foreign holdings, Wilby thinks the performance of European and Japanese stocks could be good enough over the next six months or so to make them better investments than U.S. stocks--or at least no worse.
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Getting Better
Foreign stock market returns for U.S. investors have mostly improved sharply since mid-May, when the dollar began to rebound against the Japanese yen.
Year-to-date change in dollars: *--*
Stock market As of May 9 As of Tues. Australia +3.6% +7.1% Britain +6.8% +14.0% Canada +5.8% +12.6% France +17.6% +16.8% Germany +9.7% +19.0% Hong Kong +2.6% +11.8% Japan +4.6% -3.5% Singapore +0.6% +0.4% Spain +15.5% +21.2% United States +14.3% +22.3%
*--*
Source: Morgan Stanley Capital Intl.
