Bush Drive Could Hurt Churches’ Tax Breaks

From Associated Press

President Bush’s reelection campaign is trying to recruit backers from 1,600 religious congregations in Pennsylvania -- a push that critics said Wednesday could cost churches their tax breaks.

An e-mail from the campaign’s Pennsylvania office, obtained by Associated Press, urges churchgoers to help organize “Friendly Congregations” where backers can meet to sign up voters and spread the Bush word.

“I’d like to ask if you would like to serve as a coordinator in your place of worship,” says the e-mail, adorned with the Bush-Cheney logo, from Luke Bernstein, who runs the state campaign’s coalitions operation and is a former staffer to Sen. Rick Santorum, the president’s Pennsylvania chairman. “We plan to undertake activities such as distributing general information/updates or voter registration materials in a place accessible to the congregation.”


The Internal Revenue Service prohibits political campaign activity, for or against any candidate, from taking place at all organizations that receive tax-exempt status -- including most churches and religious groups. Violators could lose their tax breaks and face excise taxes.

Bernstein refused comment. Kevin Madden, a Bush-Cheney spokesman at the campaign’s headquarters, said the campaign did not mean to imply that religious supporters should actually congregate for the president at their places of worship. But he would not say whether the campaign was taking steps to make sure they didn’t.

“People of faith feel strongly about the president,” Madden said, adding that they “are people we want to be part of our campaign. This message is intended to be from individual to individual. This is organizing with individuals who may be members of a church who we hope to identify as supporters and be part of our efforts.”

Madden said the campaign also is targeting “Friendly Congregations” in other states, but he could not specify where. Pennsylvania is a key political swing state that offers 21 electoral votes. Bush lost the state in 2000 by about 204,000 votes.

The director of a nonpartisan watchdog group called the campaign’s church appeal “a breathtakingly sad example of mixing religion and politics.”

“I have never in my life seen such a direct campaign to politicize American churches -- from any political party or from any candidate for public office,” said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn of the Americans United for Separation of Church and State. “By enrolling churches in an election scheme like this, I think the Bush-Cheney campaign is actually endangering those churches’ tax exemptions without even the courtesy of telling them that they run a risk.”