Mick Mulvaney just scrapped all the experts on CFPB’s consumer advisory board


The head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau dissolved a group of outside experts that acted as an important sounding board for the watchdog agency on economic and financial issues as well as policy.

Bureau officials told the 25 members of the Consumer Advisory Board on Wednesday that they will be replaced and the board will be reconstituted, according to two board members who were on a morning conference call. An email to board members on behalf of CFPB Acting Director Mick Mulvaney confirmed the actions.

“Everyone on the board has been fired,” said Judith Fox, a professor of consumer law at Notre Dame Law School who sat on the board for three years.


The law that created the CFPB mandates that bureau officials meet with the advisory board at least twice a year. But the meetings repeatedly have been canceled under Mulvaney, who has steered the bureau in a more industry-friendly direction since taking charge late last year.

Under the Obama administration, the advisory board acted as a group of experts that bureau officials could talk with about economic issues, trends in the industry or the bureau’s proposed regulations. It is basically the only group of outside experts that the CFPB director is required to interact with by law.

The board will be reconstituted in the fall, Fox said. None of the current members of the board will be eligible to apply. Members of two other boards that also provide outside expertise would also be replaced.

Under Obama appointee Richard Cordray, the board would meet two to three times a year for at least a couple of days. The most Mulvaney ever committed to, according to board members, was a 20-minute phone call. A two-day meeting originally scheduled for Wednesday and Thursday of this week was canceled.

On the Wednesday morning conference call, Mulvaney political appointee Anthony Welcher told board members that the bureau was looking for more diversity among its members and looking for ways to save money. But now-former board members say those arguments are misleading. The board’s cost was several hundred thousand dollars, according to bureau officials, a small fraction of the bureau’s estimated 2018 budget of $630.4 million. Several members including Max Levchin, founder and chief executive of financial services company Affirm, offered to pay their own travel costs.

Along with consumer groups and academics, the board was made up of representatives from big financial companies such as Citigroup, Mastercard, and Pennsylvania bank PNC.


“Without this direct line to all stakeholders, CFPB’s job becomes much harder, perhaps nearly impossible,” said Levchin, who had been on the board since 2015.


Trump’s CFPB is shutting the office that focuses on student loan abuses

Mick Mulvaney must leave as CFPB chief soon, unless Trump nominates somebody — anybody — else for the job

Mick Mulvaney doesn’t want to show you complaints against banks that backed his campaigns, report says

Tougher payday loan rules issued by CFPB to remain in place ... for now


Column: Mick Mulvaney says a good consumer agency is a weak consumer agency


1:05 p.m.: This article was updated throughout with additional details and background information and with comment from Max Levchin.

11:20 a.m.: This article was updated with comment from Judith Fox.

This article was originally published at 10:50 a.m.