Uber and 2 of its executives are convicted and fined in France
A French court has convicted and fined Uber and two of its executives for deceptive commercial practices and illegal business activity over its lowest-cost ride service.
It’s the latest legal tangle for the app-based business, which has faced protests from taxi unions and regulators around the world, reflecting larger tensions between long-regulated industries and the borderless, online economy.
The court fined the San Francisco-based company about $900,000, regional Uber executive Pierre-Dimitry Gore-Coty about $34,000, and Uber’s France general manager Thibaud Simphal $23,000. Half of all the fines were suspended.
The court did not order prison terms, and it rejected a prosecutor’s request that the two executives be barred from running any company for five years.
And the fines were much lower than the more than $100 million in damages that traditional taxi services had sought.
Traditional taxi services accused the low-cost UberPop service of unfair competition because it uses nonprofessional drivers. UberPop is now banned in France, but Uber still operates a service with professional drivers.
Jean-Paul Levy, lawyer for a taxi union, said the conviction is a “founding decision,” showing that Uber “is a company which placed itself outside the law.”
Jonathan Bellaiche, lawyer for three taxi unions and one individual taxi driver, said he is “rather disappointed.”
“The important point is that in the end UberPop activity was profitable,” he said, given that the amounts of the fines are far lower than UberPop’s gain, which he estimated at about $50 million.
Uber’s lawyers did not comment on the court’s decision.
Thierry Guicherd, the taxi driver who sued UberPop, has been recognized by the court as a victim.
“It’s a satisfaction to know that they [Uber] are convicted and not a satisfaction at all when we know the amounts of the fines. Because of course the damages that myself and my colleagues are facing are much more important that what the court decided to order,” he said.
The court ordered Uber to pay Guicherd about $1,800 for the damages.
Frederic Bergaud, a 35-year-old taxi driver in Paris, called the conviction of Uber “good news.”
“It’s a first step,” he said. “Are we going to win the war? We don’t know. But it’s better than nothing.”
It was the first trial for Uber managers in France. During the trial, lawyers for Uber argued that Simphal and Gore-Coty are not the legal representatives for Uber in France, have no such mandate from the shareholders and are only salaried managers dealing mostly with marketing and advertising.
Yet the court ruled Thursday that they were de facto managing Uber in France.
More than 200 UberPop drivers have been fined under fast-track procedures in France, and the company has already been convicted of deceptive commercial practices and fined some $170,000 over UberPop by a Paris court.
The French Parliament voted to outlaw UberPop and other similar services in 2014, and Uber suspended its UberPop service in France last July. But its standard app-based service still prompts occasional strikes and clashes with taxi drivers.
Also on Thursday, a court in Frankfurt upheld a ban on the UberPop ride service in Germany.
Judges threw out an appeal by Uber against a March 2015 ruling by a lower court that banned UberPop from offering rides with drivers who don’t have taxi permits. That ruling stemmed from a suit brought by a German taxi association. It was heard in Frankfurt because that was one of several cities where Uber had launched operations.
The latest verdict can be appealed to a federal court.
In Spain and Italy, Uber is outlawed entirely.