Two Californians who crossed their parties on immigration fight

Migrants crossing the border into the U.S. from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico.
Migrants crossing the border into the U.S. from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, on Tuesday.
( Anadolu via Getty Images)

It was a wild week in Washington, D.C., that included decisions by two California politicians to buck their parties, unusual moves in the nation’s highly partisan fight over immigration.

First California Sen. Alex Padilla split with President Biden in announcing his opposition to a bipartisan immigration proposal to tie foreign aid for U.S. allies with new restrictions on the flow of migrants across the southern border. Biden had asked the Senate to come up with the plan but Padilla said the $118-billion bill “misses the mark.” It was heavy on conservative priorities to restrict asylum and expedite deportations, and did not address progressive goals to create citizenship opportunities for millions of people in the country illegally.

In a case of odd political bedfellows, former President Trump also opposed the bill and it was dead within days of introduction. Trump sees immigration as a major issue in the 2024 presidential race, one he can use again Biden. Its demise was due largely to Republicans kowtowing to Trump and turning against the bill they had previously fought for. But Padilla’s bit part in the saga was intriguing to me because it put the Democratic senator in the unusual position of opposing a priority of the Democratic president — as Biden campaigns for reelection, no less.


Meanwhile in the other chamber, a California Republican helped tank a GOP priority to impeach Biden’s secretary of homeland security — something House Republicans have been trying to do since they nabbed the majority in 2022. Rep. Tom McClintock said he bucked his party to vote against impeaching Secretary Alejandro N. Mayorkas because it would cheapen the use of Congress’ most powerful punishment.

“It dumbs down the standard of impeachment to a point where it will become a constant fixture in our national life every time the White House is held by one party and the Congress by another,” McClintock told my colleague Sarah D. Wire. “That’s exactly what the American Founders feared, and that’s why they were very careful to specify narrow limits to its use.”

McClintock was one of four Republicans who voted against the impeachment, enough to torpedo it given the GOP’s very narrow majority.

Read more about these partisan defections in these articles:

I’m Laurel Rosenhall, Sacramento bureau chief for The Times, delivering your guide to the week in California politics.

An energetic new leader in Sacramento

California Senate leader Mike McGuire speaks with firefighters while visiting the Healdsburg fire station.
(Josh Edelson/For The Times)

“The Energizer Bunny of California politics.”

That’s how political science professor David McCuan described Mike McGuire, new leader of the California Senate, who was a student of his more than 20 years ago at Sonoma State.

My colleague Mackenzie Mays spent time with McGuire in his north coast district as he led elementary school students in the “wheelbarrow” dance, chatted with firefighters in a region ravaged by wildfires, and prepped for an evening of auctioneering.


Now McGuire, who was sworn in on Monday, must harness that energy as he takes on his biggest challenge yet — guiding the Legislature’s upper house as the state grapples with an estimated $38-billion budget deficit. The Senate leader plays a powerful role negotiating the state budget with the governor and the Assembly speaker, making it one of the most influential positions in state government.

At a swearing-in ceremony at the Capitol on Monday, McGuire vowed to “buckle down” and right the budget in the same way that Californians struggling financially are forced to “live within their means” and make sacrifices in their personal spending, Mays writes.

“We know that tough decisions lie ahead,” McGuire said in an emotional speech on the Senate floor that at times drove him to tears. “We are going to protect our progress.”

Super weird Super Bowl politics

A red MAGA hat with a SF Niners logo patched on it. Sunglasses under the hat show Taylor Swift mirrored in the lenses.
San Francisco has long been a conservative punching bag, but some far-right commentators now say they plan to cheer for the city in the Super Bowl
(Los Angeles Times photo illustration; photos by Associated Press, Unsplash)

As America’s two favorite pastimes — football and intricate political conspiracy theories — collide in the runup to Super Bowl LVIII, a strange thing has happened, writes my colleague Julia Wick.

Several conservative commentators announced that they plan to root for San Francisco, the liberal city they more typically vilify.


The nascent 49ers fans declaring their unlikely allegiance are sticking it to Taylor Swift, the pop star dating Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce, who will be facing off against the 49ers on Sunday.

Swift has been at the center of a series of sprawling but unfounded right-wing conspiracies that allege she is somehow in cahoots with the NFL to hurt Donald Trump’s chances in the 2024 election and help reelect President Biden by, among other things, endorsing him during the Super Bowl. Swift endorsed Biden in 2020 but there is no evidence that she plans to make any political announcements at the big game this weekend.

Nonetheless the conspiracies led one conservative pundit to declare on Fox News that he’s “proudly supporting the San Francisco 49ers, America’s team.”

Democratic San Francisco Assemblymember Matt Haney told Wick that it was “a little strange to see people who usually hate San Francisco now cheering for San Francisco.”

“They hate Taylor Swift even more, I guess,” he said.

Gov. Gavin Newsom — former mayor of San Francisco and longtime 49ers fan — called the GOP criticism of Taylor Swift “sad and pathetic.”

He’s been traveling the country to stump for Biden. And no, he is not rooting for the Chiefs.

Enjoying this newsletter? Consider subscribing to the Los Angeles Times

Your support helps us deliver the news that matters most. Become a subscriber.


Keeping up with California politics

How Katie Porter harnesses her blunt style and single-mom experience in her Senate campaign
Porter’s three terms as an outspoken Democratic member of Congress holding down a competitive Orange County district have been defined by her blunt demeanor, professorial intellect and sometimes polarizing behavior. Those traits tend to stir things up inside both the U.S. Capitol and her four-bedroom home in Irvine, where she is raising three children. Her decision to run for the U.S. Senate has put all of it on full display.

California lawmakers blast state’s workplace safety agency over ‘dangerous’ farmworker conditions
California Democrats lambasted the state’s workplace safety agency on Wednesday after hearing testimony from farmworkers who said they have been exposed to extreme heat and pesticides on the job and have faced wage theft and other labor law violations.

Column: Why Wendy Carrillo says her DUI was a ‘blessing in disguise’
In an interview with Times columnist Gustavo Arellano, Assemblymember Wendy Carrillo (D-Los Angeles) said that after crashing her car in November, she realized she was an alcoholic. She described “looking at a shiny silver toilet in jail” as “an incredibly sobering moment.”

With a nudge from Newsom, a new bill aims to legalize psychedelic-assisted therapy in California
After a failed attempt to decriminalize a short list of psychedelics last year, state Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) is reintroducing legislation to make California the third state to legalize psychedelic-assisted therapy for adults.

Column: California finally has a reparations plan. Why is it half-baked and disorganized?
California doesn’t really have a legislative strategy for reparations, writes Times columnist Erika D. Smith. Instead, she says, what we have so far is a confusing and growing collection of bills — some of them half-baked and all of them introduced by lawmakers who, despite their assertions to the contrary, don’t seem to be on the same page about what to prioritize or how to move forward.

Column: Is Adam Schiff playing dirty in California’s U.S. Senate race? No, he’s not
The calculus is plain with Adam B. Schiff’s (D-Burbank) new ad in his bid for U.S. Senate, writes Times columnist Mark Z. Barabak. Schiff is hoping to clinch the Senate seat in the March 5 primary by lifting his weakest possible opponent, Garvey, into a November runoff.


President Biden expected back in California for more reelection fundraising this month
President Biden is planning a swing through Los Angeles and the San Francisco Bay Area later this month to raise money for what is almost assured to be a rematch against former President Trump in the November election.

Stay in touch

Did someone forward you this? Sign up here to get California Politics in your inbox.

Until next time, send your comments, suggestions and news tips to