The chaos surrounding the Grand Avenue redevelopment may turn out to be a good thing — at least for
Los Angeles County Supervisor
What is much more likely when the authority, which Molina chairs, meets late this afternoon is that Related will be granted an extension of its agreement through January.
That delay, in turn, will present an opportunity for the design to be significantly reassessed — and an opportunity perhaps for Frank Gehry, who was heading up the design effort before Related's California office started consulting with other firms, to return to a lead role.
The plans that Molina objected to were produced by Gensler, the large architecture firm that also designed a proposed pro football stadium next to L.A. Live. The Gensler plan, for a site on the east side of Grand known as Parcel Q, directly across from Gehry's Walt Disney Concert Hall, were meant to be conceptual — a master plan for how buildings would be arranged on the site, not a final design.
But the way they have been presented doesn't make that entirely clear. The digital renderings for Parcel Q included in the latest report to the authority are highly detailed architecturally — more than is typically the case for a master plan.
Given the sleek, upscale and rather placeless look of those images, it's not too hard to understand why they bothered Molina. She has pushed from the start of negotiations with Related for the inclusion of affordable housing and other concessions.
But Bill Witte, president of Related California, said Monday that it was county officials who requested the more detailed renderings.
"We contined to reiterate to them that this is not architecture yet -- it's conceptual design," Witte said. "It needs work. We knew that going in. We had no idea they would react as they did."
Further muddying the waters is the news that Robert A.M. Stern Architects of New York, who designed the new
Peter Morris Dixon, a spokesman for Stern, also confirmed the firm's involvement. Gensler refused to comment.
From an aesthetic point of view, a Grand Avenue project based on a Gensler master plan and including buildings by both Gehry and Stern is very difficult to imagine. Gehry's work is formally exuberant, Stern's historically minded and conservative. Their personal relationship, though, is close; Gehry has been a regular visiting professor at the Yale School of Architecture, where Stern is dean.
Reached by phone Monday morning, Gehry, who has been busy in recent weeks with events marking the 10th anniversary of Disney Hall, sounded relatively upbeat about the prospects for his continued involvement. He said he has been in close touch recently with Stephen M. Ross, Related's chairman.
"We've been asked to work on the next phase" by Related, Gehry said. "We'll see what happens. If we do it, we'll take the lead on the design. They understand that."
Gehry added that the designs Related presented to the Grand Avenue Authority last week — the result of a rather hasty collaboration between Gensler and Stern to meet the latest deadline — reflect the nature of the project and its approval timeline.
"There is lots of angst and anxiety around the project," he said. "The pressure is on Related to deliver these plans. But the market isn't there. It's still soft."
Witte agreed. "You can't legislate the market," he said of the Grand Avenue Authority's reaction to the latest plans. "We are responding to and will continue to respond to the market. This is a commercial project, not a museum or a university one."
The recent turmoil, though it hardly reflects well on the way Related or the Grand Avenue Authority has overseen the project in recent months, is likely to shake up the design process in a helpful way. It will make an uninspired proposal less likely to win approval or move uninterrupted through the process. And it will clarify the fact that the proposal rejected last week was not meant as a complete design but a master plan.
It may also be the case that while Related executives in California favored a plan by Gensler and Stern, Ross and the New York headquarters have been planning to trump the West Coast office by deciding to let Gehry take the lead on the design. Several sources also said that Molina is unhappy that work on a city-owned parcel in the Grand Ave. redevelopment area, site of the forthcoming Broad museum and a Related Cos. apartment building, has moved ahead while Parcel Q, a county site, remains empty.
The relationship between the Grand Avenue Authority and Related has grown less smooth in the last couple of years with the departure of Martha Welborne, who had been helping manage the project, for a job with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Meanwhile City Councilmember Jose Huizar has replaced Jan Perry as the city's representative on the Grand Avenue body. Those changes have all had the effect of bolstering Molina's influence.
Compared with the original 2007 proposal for the site across from Disney Hall, the new Related plan shows the effects of the recession. It calls for fewer residential units (430 instead of 488), a slightly smaller number of hotel rooms (275 versus 250) and less retail space (171,000 square feet compared with 250,000). The residential units will be mostly rental apartments, while the original plan called for mostly condominiums.
Related had also sought permission to build out Parcel Q in two phases, starting along 2nd Street with an apartment tower and retail plaza and adding facilities near 1st Street later.