Movie reviews: ‘The Oscar-Nominated Short Films 2011’
Shorts programs are by their nature mixed bags of ambition, art and quality. One that packages the 10 live-action and animated nominees for the Oscar, however, carries a greater sense of anticipation.
That said, modest charms are what distinguish this year’s academy-tapped batch. The animated five in particular help dispel our often fatigued prejudices about that format as a haven for all things digital, 3-D, snarky and kid-marketed.
Bastien Dubois’ style mash-up “Madagascar, Carnet de Voyage,” in particular, is a vibrantly impressionistic travelogue of the French filmmaker’s trip to the African island nation, rendered as a scrapbook come alive. “The Lost Thing,” meanwhile, from Andrew Ruhemann and Shaun Tan, takes the story of a boy’s affinity for a misshapen creature he finds on a beach but includes an adult’s ruminative perspective.
Animation giant Pixar is in the mix with Teddy Newton’s frisky, yin-yang celebration of friendship, “Day & Night,” while Geefwee Boedoe’s hand-drawn educational film spoof “Let’s Pollute” takes aim — if a little too easily — at our wasteful environmental ways.
Too draggy, however, is Jakob Schuh’s and Max Lang’s painstaking adaptation of the beloved children’s book “The Gruffalo,” about the crafty survival instincts of a mouse in the woods. Though visually lovely and spotted with big-name voices — Helena Bonham Carter, John Hurt, Robbie Coltrane — its bedtime-reading pace seems ill-suited for the dynamic potential of film.
The live-action shorts, like last year, seem heavily weighted toward the plight of youngsters. Tanel Toom’s “The Confession” brings the specter of tragic guilt to a 9-year-old British lad awaiting his first priestly unburdening, but the film is so obvious and grim its impact is blunted. Even more one-note (and creepy) is “The Crush,” from Ireland, Michael Creagh’s ill-timed bad joke about an obsessed boy, the teacher he wants to marry, her fiancé and a gun.
Faring better is Ivan Goldschmidt’s tense and darkly comic “Na Wewe,” set amid genocidal terror in Burundi in 1994 and which dramatizes a rebel African militia’s absurd difficulty in sorting out ethnic Tutsis from a halted vanload of passengers.
On a lighter note, writer-director-star Luke Matheny’s roughly winning “God of Love” uses Woody Allen-esque comedy to tell a modern-day Cupid story of jazz, darts, unrequited love and destiny.
The standout, however, is Ian Barnes’ “Wish 143,” a sterlingly acted piece of wry melancholia about the scheming surrounding a cancer-ridden teenage boy’s libidinous response to a charity’s wish-granting gesture. Unexpectedly funny and effortlessly touching, it’s a story of rapidly diminished time conveyed with fittingly economic artistry, the hallmark of any truly memorable short film.
‘The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2011’
No MPAA rating
Running time: 1 hour, 46 minutes (live action); 1 hour, 25 minutes (animated)
Playing: At the Nuart, West Los Angeles; Regency Theaters South Coast Village Plaza, Santa Ana
The biggest entertainment stories
Get our big stories about Hollywood, film, television, music, arts, culture and more right in your inbox as soon as they publish.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
