Review: ‘The Oath’ makes an unpleasant stew out of Thanksgiving and politics
Not feeling stressed enough about politics these days? Ike Barinholtz’s “The Oath” is here to remedy that. The comedic actor makes his feature directorial debut, which he also wrote, with a politically charged comedy that’s sort of a satire, designed to wring wry laughs from our deeply divided political state. In the current climate, however, it’s just frustrating and unpleasant to watch.
The premise plays on the well-known notion that discussing politics with family at Thanksgiving is fraught and awkward, with a twist. The government has required every citizen sign a “loyalty oath” pledging their patriotism, with a deadline of Black Friday. Barinholtz plays the uber-liberal Chris, married to Kai (Tiffany Haddish), and in protest he steadfastly refuses to sign.
Things come to a head when Chris’ family descends on their home for Thanksgiving. His clueless parents (Nora Dunn and Chris Ellis) aren’t a problem, but his brother Pat (real-life sibling Jon Barinholtz), and Pat’s conservative girlfriend, Abbie (Meredith Hagner), are, despite Kai’s attempts to keep things copacetic. Chris’ and Pat’s sister Alice (Carrie Brownstein), and her family also attempt to keep the peace.
For the majority of the film, it’s sharing space with people whom you have to spend time with even if you’d rather not, and the small spats that erupt over negligible issues — all heightened by the “did you/didn’t you” questions about signing the oath. But the film enters horror movie territory when two government agents (John Cho and Billy Magnussen) show up to question Chris about a report that he’s been pressuring someone not to sign.
Suddenly, the barbed family comedy turns into a bloody awful affair, and this is where “The Oath” goes south. It positions the victim of an overly zealous police state as a wealthy white man, which is, frankly, tone deaf.
The film’s messaging is all over the place. Suddenly our moral compass, Kai, becomes unreliable. You start to question what the film is trying to say: Should citizens sign a loyalty oath to keep themselves safe from the government? While the first two-thirds of the film vehemently argue against that, the last third seems to flip-flop on the idea.
“The Oath” backs itself into an impossible corner, and then relies on a deus ex machina to escape the bind it’s in, backing away from saying anything interesting or provocative. “The Oath” wants to have its pie and eat it too — lobbing political hand grenades and then running away, refusing to engage in the consequences the scenarios set up.
Magnussen is magnetic as the mustachioed and psychopathic government agent Mason. Similarly, it’s a testament to Hagner’s performance that Abbie is completely unbearable. So why do the villains walk away with this movie? Because the “heroes” are inconsistent, which might be an unintentional comment on the way things are today in the political realm.
The neat ending is out of place with the violence that precedes it, and this satire about power dynamics ultimately argues that perhaps what’s right and moral is to avoid mixing family with politics, though that’s exactly what we should be doing in this moment.
Walsh is a Tribune News Service film critic.
Rated: R for language throughout, violence and some drug use
Running time: 1 hour, 33 minutes
Playing: Starts Friday, Arclight Hollywood; AMC Century City
From the Emmys to the Oscars.
Get our revamped Envelope newsletter, sent twice a week, for exclusive awards season coverage, behind-the-scenes insights and columnist Glenn Whipp’s commentary.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.