Jury awards former South Pasadena police officer $4.8 million in disability discrimination case

A former South Pasadena police officer whose firing was endorsed by Chief Arthur Miller, above, was awarded $4.8 million by a jury this week in a civil trial where he alleged he was wrongfully dismissed because of a disability.
(Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)

A Los Angeles jury has awarded $4.8 million to a former South Pasadena police officer who alleged he was fired by the city because of a disability.

After a two-week trial, the jury on Thursday found unanimously in favor of Timothy Patrick Green, an 18-year veteran who was dismissed from the Police Department in 2013.

Green’s lawsuit said the reason given for his dismissal, dishonesty, was untrue and that the real reason was discrimination based on his attention-deficit/hyper-active disorder.


South Pasadena City Atty. Teresa L. Highsmith did not return a call from The Times.

Former Police Chief Joseph Payne, who retired before Green’s dismissal, testified on his behalf, saying he was “a good officer, a good man, perhaps the best cop in the department at community policing,” said Green’s attorney, Vincent Miller.

According to Miller, Payne testified that the city failed Green by not providing accommodations to help overcome his difficulty writing reports. Instead, the lawsuit alleged, Payne’s replacement, Chief Arthur Miller, endorsed the recommendation of a captain who had long been trying to have Green fired.

Green’s termination revolved around a 2012 pre-dawn incident when he failed to cite a motorist he had stopped for speeding.

Green said he let the motorist go when he saw what he thought were silhouettes at the middle school across the street and went to investigate.

The next day, the driver went to the police station to report that he may have fled a police officer. Later investigation established that he had been involved in a hit-and-run accident before he was stopped by Green.

Green said he had not seen the damage on the front of the car. Green’s attorney said his client gave slightly different statements in two interviews. In one, he said he had not gone past the rear bumper of the car. In the other, he said he hadn’t gone past the rear quarter panel.

According to the lawyer, Chief Miller claimed Green was lying about being more concerned about suspicious silhouettes at the school than the driver he pulled over.

“The jury clearly felt it was obvious disability discrimination,” the lawyer said.

The award, he said, was to compensate Green for lost wages and “the fact that they destroyed his career permanently.”

“They fired him on charges of dishonesty,” the attorney said. “It’s known as the death penalty in law enforcement.”

Twitter: @LATDoug