Diet and exercise alone are no cure for obesity, experts say

Telling patients with sustained obesity to eat less and move more is a modest start, says a group of weight-loss experts. But it falls far short of what most need.
(Mel Melcon / Los Angeles Times )

At long last, a group of respected physicians and obesity researchers has stepped forward to challenge the facile bromide that America’s weight issues can be easily fixed by diet and exercise.

Take note, glib-talking doctors and legislators, rail-thin commentators, and fat-haters of all stripes: For most of the nation’s 79 million adults and 13 million kids who are obese, the “eat less, move more” treatment, as currently practiced, is a prescription for failure, these experts say.

In a commentary published Thursday in the journal Lancet Diabetes and Endocrinology, four weight-loss specialists set out to correct what they view as the widespread misimpression that people who have become and stayed obese for more than a couple of years can, by diet and exercise alone, return to a normal, healthy weight and stay that way.


“Once obesity is established, however, body weight seems to become biologically ‘stamped in’ and defended,” wrote Mt. Sinai Hospital weight management expert Christopher N. Ochner and colleagues from the medical faculties of the University of Colorado, Northwestern University and the University of Pennsylvania.



Feb. 17, 1:23 p.m.: An earlier version of this story referred to Christopher N. Ochner as a weight management physician. He is trained as a clinical psychologist, not a physician. His research focuses on obesity prevention and treatment for adolescents.


The human body, evolved to endure through periods of food scarcity, has adapted a host of methods to ensure that lost weight will be restored, the authors say. It will respond to weight loss by powering down its use of calories as fuel, pumping out hormones to increase hunger, boosting fat storage capacity, and tricking the brain to demand overconsumption.

“Few individuals ever truly recover from obesity,” the authors wrote. Those that do, they add, “still have ‘obesity in remission,’ and are biologically very different from individuals of the same age, sex and body weight who never had obesity.” They are constantly at war with their bodies’ efforts to return to their highest sustained weight.

The depressing fact, said Ochner in an interview, is that “the average adult with sustained obesity has less than a 1% chance of reattaining and maintaining a healthy body weight without surgery.”


These discouraging facts about the body’s response to weight loss are well known to obesity researchers: Drug developers wrestle with the fact that even when their treatments induce weight loss by one means, other mechanisms spring up to limit or reverse that weight loss. So why would an influential foursome see the value in recapitulating these ideas in a respected medical journal?

“It’s not just that most people still stigmatize obesity--as they say, it’s the last acceptable form of stigma,” said Ochner. “What really bothers me working around and with clinicians, is that some of them--a disturbing percentage--still believe it’s all about personal choice: that if the patient just tries hard enough, and if we can just figure out how to get them a little more motivated, then we’d be successful. And that’s just not right.”

Lifestyle changes are undoubtedly a necessary condition for enduring weight loss, Ochner said. But they’re far from sufficient, and when physicians believe they are--when they say “you already know what to do, I told you what to do,” he said--”that’s certainly cruel, and it’s harmful: It prevents them getting the care they need.”

Physicians, he said, should be doing more than exhort patients to eat less and move more. They should intervene more quickly to encourage weight loss in overweight patients before they become obese. They should discuss with obese patients the range of medications, surgery and device-based treatments approved by the FDA to supplement diet and exercise in promoting weight loss. And they should make weight-loss maintenance--an aspect of obesity treatment that is neglected--a part of their treatment plan.

Meanwhile, public health officials and researchers, Ochner added, should do more to encourage the development of more effective aids to weight loss. And everyone should understand that “it may be 20, 30, 40 years before we see a turnaround.”

“We all want a fix for obesity, a cure for it,” Ochner said. But “eat less, move more” is not it, he said.


Follow me on Twitter @LATMelissaHealy and “like” Los Angeles Times Science & Health on Facebook.