2 alleged Boogaloo Boys members arrested amid heightened fears of election violence

Far-right activist armed and in fatigues outside the state Capitol in Lansing, Mich.
Timothy Teagan, an alleged member of the Boogaloo Boys far-right movement, stands with his rifle outside the Michigan Capitol in January 2021. He faces several federal charges.
(Paul Sancya / Associated Press)

The FBI has arrested two alleged members of the far-right anti-government group Boogaloo Boys, with authorities increasingly concerned about the potential for violence in the lead-up to next week’s midterm elections.

Timothy Teagan appeared Wednesday in federal court in Detroit on charges of being a drug user in possession of firearms and ammunition and giving a false statement in connection with the acquisition of a firearm, according to an unsealed federal complaint.

Meanwhile, the FBI said in a criminal complaint filed Monday that there was enough evidence to charge Aron McKillips, of Sandusky, Ohio, with illegal possession of a machine gun and the interstate communication of threats. It says McKillips is a member of the Boogaloo Boys and is believed to be in a paramilitary group called the Sons of Liberty.


The timing of the law enforcement action is notable in part because it comes just days before the midterm elections. After the FBI searched his home last month, Teagan told documentarian Ford Fischer that federal agents questioned him specifically about potential violence being planned ahead of the election.

“They were very, very particular about questions involving anything going on with the election,” he said. “They were asking if I knew of any violent plans or any violent tendencies that could come forth about the election. … They were asking if we had any plans to go to polls armed.”

Election workers have increasingly been targeted by threats and harassment since the 2020 election, and it’s gotten worse in recent weeks — five people have been charged with intimidation.

Friday’s attack on Democratic Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s husband, Paul, is the most recent example of the country’s increasing political violence.

Oct. 30, 2022

Nationally, election officials are concerned about conspiracy theorists signing up to work as poll watchers, with some groups that have trafficked in lies about the 2020 election recruiting and training watchers.

The arrest of the suspected Boogaloo Boys members was reminiscent of a similar move by police in Washington, who arrested the leader of the Proud Boys days before the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, where lawmakers were certifying President-elect Joe Biden’s win. Members of the far-right group, along with leaders of another extremist group, the Oath Keepers, were later charged with seditious conspiracy.

The risk of fragmented far-right movements that promote civil division and anti-authority violence tends to escalate around elections, said Brian Levin, director of the Center for the Study of Hate & Extremism at Cal State San Bernardino.


“Hate crime and extremist plotting that rose in 2008, 2016 and 2018 correlated to conflictual elections, and this year election-related invective appears to be rising,” Levin said. “Part of the timing of various arrests could be related to the escalated risk during this time as well as the authorities hitting a threshold of evidence where they could bring charges.”

Jeremy Joseph Bertino is the first member of the Proud Boys extremist group to plead guilty to seditious conspiracy in the Jan. 6 Capitol attack.

Oct. 6, 2022

McKillips’ lawyer, Neil McElroy, said via email Wednesday that McKillips was taken into custody and that he has asked for McKillips to be released pending a detention hearing next week in Toledo, Ohio.

In the criminal complaint against McKillips, the FBI alleges that he made multiple online threats, including one to kill a police officer and another to kill anyone he determined to be a federal informant.

The FBI contends that McKillips provided other members of the Boogaloo Boys with equipment to convert rifles into machine guns, as during a trip to Lansing, Mich., in April 2021. “I literally handed out machine guns in Michigan,” McKillips said in a recording, the complaint states.

In September 2021, he said in a private chat group, “Ain’t Got a federal badge off a corpse yet, so my time here ain’t near done yet lol,” according to the complaint.

People wearing body armor or weapons have been observed at ballot drop boxes in multiple states after Trump and his allies urged supporters to monitor them.

Nov. 1, 2022

In May, McKillips and another user of the Signal messaging system threatened to kill a different Signal user in the belief that the person was a federal informant who worked for the FBI or Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, the complaint says. And in July, McKillips threatened in a Signal chat group that he would “smoke a hog,” meaning kill a police officer, if conditions worsened following a fatal police shooting in Akron, Ohio, the complaint says.


McKillips frequently advocated violence against police, federal agents, government buildings and big-box stores like Walmart and Target, and threatened to blow up Facebook’s headquarters, the complaint says.

During Teagan’s hearing Wednesday, a federal magistrate ordered him held pending a Friday detention hearing.

Dressed in a colorful Hawaiian-style shirt — a uniform of sorts for adherents of the so-called Boogaloo movement, which predicts that a second U.S. civil war is coming — Teagan told the court that he might seek to retain his own attorney.

Police in the Detroit suburb of Plymouth arrested Teagan on Oct. 25 and charged him with assault and battery in an attack on his father. FBI agents searching his room at his father’s home four days later found body armor, Boogaloo movement flags and patches, and gas masks, according to the criminal complaint. They also seized a handgun from his brother’s vehicle.

According to the complaint, Teagan submitted an ATF form on July 17 for the purchase of a firearm and certified that he did not use controlled substances. But on Oct. 27, agents seized packages of what appeared to be marijuana, bongs and other drug paraphernalia from Teagan’s room.

His brother, Christopher Teagan, told an FBI agent on the Joint Terrorism Task Force that he brought Timothy Teagan “a ton of weed” following his brother’s release on the assault charge, the complaint states.

Teagan was among a dozen or so people who openly carried guns while demonstrating in January 2021 outside the Michigan Capitol in Lansing. Some promoted the Boogaloo movement. Teagan told reporters at the time that the demonstration’s purpose was “to urge a message of peace and unity to the left and right.”

Across the country, election clerks have spent the last two years waging an information and public relations battle to restore faith in elections. But as the 2022 primaries showed, some key personnel involved in elections — poll workers and poll challengers — still actively doubt the results of the 2020 presidential race, believing baseless allegations of fraud.

Sept. 27, 2022

Some Boogaloo promoters insist they aren’t genuinely advocating violence. But the movement has been linked to a string of domestic terrorism plots.

Christopher Teagan, 24, told the Associated Press after Wednesday’s hearing that his brother, through his association with the Boogaloo movement, has “never been involved in anything of any type of violent nature.”


“He’s just been to protests,” he said outside the courtroom. “I think [the FBI] will go after him unjustly or harsher because of his association with the group.”

The federal actions could reflect that different people in the Boogaloo movement are “getting closer to violence,” said Javed Ali, an associate professor at the University of Michigan and a former senior U.S. government counter-terrorism official.

Judge Thomas Wilson ordered all three men to jail while they await sentencing scheduled for Dec. 15.

Oct. 26, 2022

“Maybe this is part of a more nationwide effort to finally start arresting and disrupting people who’ve moved beyond the phase of being angry,” Ali said.

Teagan’s arrest came just days after three members of a paramilitary group were convicted of supplying “material support” for a terrorist act over a plot to kidnap Michigan’s Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer. Prosecutors argued that the defendants supported the Boogaloo movement.

In August, Steven Carrillo, an Air Force sergeant who officials say is associated with the Boogaloo movement, was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole in the killing of a Northern California sheriff’s sergeant. In June, Carrillo was sentenced to 41 years in prison for killing a federal security agent in Oakland.