Republicans block meningitis, chickenpox vaccine mandates in Wisconsin


Wisconsin Republicans blocked Gov. Tony Evers’ plan Thursday to require student vaccinations against meningitis and tighten student chickenpox vaccination requirements.

The Legislature’s GOP-controlled rules committee voted 6-4 to block the proposal. All six of the panel’s Republican members voted to stop the policy. The vote comes two days after a lengthy public hearing on the policy changes that saw parents complain that the new requirements trample their liberties. The committee blocked the proposal during the last legislative session as well.

“[The rules committee], once again, met its oversight duty relating to the improper actions taken by [the Department of Health Services] to enact binding administrative code provisions that were arbitrary and capricious, as well as, placing undue hardships on the families of this state,” Sen. Steve Nass, a committee co-chair, said in a statement. He said the committee’s action “restores the reasonable right of parents to make immunization decisions for their children.”


Officials with the health department announced in February that beginning this fall students entering seventh grade must be vaccinated against meningitis and high school seniors must get a booster shot. Students currently don’t have to get vaccinated against meningitis.

The department also announced that beginning this fall parents must provide schools with evidence from a healthcare provider that their child had had chickenpox to avoid a chickenpox vaccination requirement.

The department currently requires students to get vaccinated against chickenpox to enter every grade from kindergarten through sixth grade. Parents can receive an exemption from the requirement if they tell the school that their child had been infected with the illness and therefore had natural immunity.

Abortion pills: A Trump-appointed conservative judge’s upcoming ruling could have the biggest effect in blue states like California. What to know.

March 7, 2023

The department also updated its definition of an outbreak to include at least five cases of chickenpox and at least three cases of meningitis. Under current regulations if an outbreak occurs in a school or child care center, students can be prohibited from entering the building until they’re immunized.

The changes sent Republicans, still stinging from COVID-19 mandates and shutdowns, into an outrage.

Nass began the public hearing Tuesday by referring to state epidemiologist Dr. Ryan Westergaard as “Wisconsin’s Dr. Fauci” and accusing the health department of assuming that parents lie about their children’s chickenpox infections so they can go to school without being vaccinated.


Parents lined up at the hearing to complain about the policy revisions. They argued that the health department was overreaching and they know how to best take care of their children.

Westergaard and Dr. Stephanie Schauer, the state immunization program manager, told the committee that meningitis is a potentially lethal disease and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has recommended students get vaccinated against it since 2005.

Westergaard added that chickenpox has become so rare that parents may not recognize the disease and unknowingly send their infected children to school.

Republicans would have none of it. Nass said he doesn’t trust anything Westergaard says after he recommended the state shutdown during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic.