A new Chinese spying charge and sharpening rhetoric further poison U.S.-China relations - with no end in sight
An already tense relationship between the United States and China has grown increasingly poisonous this week amid a new spying charge, a rapid escalation of a trade war and an accusation by President Trump of election interference.
The sharpening rhetoric and actions, including an espionage arrest in Chicago and tough words at the United Nations Security Council in New York, are playing out as America’s unease about China’s global role grows and the Asian giant becomes increasingly confident about projecting its power overseas.
Although the U.S. and Chinese economies are deeply entwined, some fear that the Trump administration is intent on decoupling them, a strategy that would have a seismic effect on the global economy.
In his latest swipe at China, Trump accused Beijing of interfering in the November U.S. midterm election because it does not want him to win after his tough actions on trade.
“Regrettably, we found that China has been attempting to interfere in our upcoming 2018 election ... against my administration,” Trump said in a speech to world leaders at the U.N. on Wednesday. “They do not want me, or us, to win because I am the first president ever to challenge China on trade.”
Later, when asked what evidence he had, Trump said, “Plenty of evidence.” But he did not elaborate.
“We did not and will not interfere in any country’s domestic affairs,” China’s foreign minister, Wang Yi, said in reaction. “We refuse to accept any unwarranted accusations against China.”
Wang also warned against a Cold War mentality between the U.S. and China.
“China and the United States can have competition, but should not use a Cold War mentality to view each other, and nor should they slip into the trap of a zero-sum game,” he said. “Recently, certain U.S. forces domestically have been continually blackening China’s name, creating antagonistic feeling, which has caused serious harm to the atmosphere of Sino-U.S. ties.”
In recent days, talks to resolve conflicts have been canceled and tension has risen over China’s territorial claims in the South Chinese Sea and Taiwan. Recent U.S. sanctions on a Chinese military agency for purchasing Russian military aircraft and a missile system, and Chinese anger at the U.S. over its sales of parts for fighter jets to Taiwan, have deepened the antagonism.
The Trump administration imposed tariffs on $200 billion in Chinese goods Monday while China retaliated with tariffs on $60 billion in U.S. goods as the trade war escalated, with some predicting it could last until next year or even 2020.
A key U.S. complaint in the trade conflict is that China forces companies to hand over trade secrets and steals intellectual property. American officials have accused China of pervasive espionage, unequaled in scope by any other country.
On Tuesday, Chinese national Ji Chaoqun, 27, who joined the U.S. Army Reserve in 2016 after graduating with a master’s degree in electrical engineering in Illinois, was arrested in Chicago. He was charged with gathering background material on eight individuals working or recently retired as scientists or defense contractors and emailing it to a provincial Chinese intelligence officer.
Ji, according to a criminal complaint, arrived in the U.S. in 2013 to study at the Illinois Institute of Technology in Chicago. Although he denied contact with a foreign government while applying to the reserve program, he is charged with working at the direction of the Chinese officer to obtain the information. He could face up to 10 years in prison for allegedly acting as an illegal agent of China.
Others recently accused of Chinese spying or theft of intellectual property include a former Apple engineer, a former IBM software engineer, a General Electric engineer, a scientist who worked for pharmaceutical company GlaxoKlineSmith and several former U.S. intelligence officers. Those accused included Chinese nationals, naturalized Americans of Chinese descent and Americans not of Asian descent.
The alarms sounded about spying have come from Trump down. At a New Jersey dinner with chief executives last month, the president expressed concern that many foreign students were spies, comments made as part of a long attack on Chinese trade practices, according to media reports.
In February, FBI Director Christopher A. Wray said at a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing that espionage by Chinese students, academics and scientists posed a “whole-of-society threat” that required “a whole-of-society response.” In July he called Chinese espionage “the broadest, most challenging, most significant threat we face as a country.”
He said China’s ambition was to be the dominant economic superpower, adding that investigations of Chinese spying were underway in 50 states.
“It covers everything from corn seeds in Iowa to wind turbines in Massachusetts and everything in between,” he said. “The volume of it, the pervasiveness of it, the significance of it is something that this country cannot underestimate.”
Chinese American organizations have warned that the repeated claims of Chinese espionage are having a chilling effect on Chinese Americans, including people born in the United States or those who have lived and worked in the United States for decades.
“Disparaging and stereotyping an entire population is wrongheaded and un-American, and especially disturbing when the source is our national leaders, whether in the White House, the Congress or the FBI,” said a statement by United Chinese Americans, a federation of Chinese American organizations, last month.
Rep. Judy Chu (D-Monterey Park) called Wray’s comments reckless and complained of a growing “dangerous narrative” in America that Chinese students and scholars be subjected to sharper scrutiny than others.
A Chinese American federation, the Committee of 100, last year released a white paper that reported Chinese Americans were disproportionately targeted in investigations of espionage, with many charges found to be false.
It reported that 52% of defendants charged under the Economic Espionage Act since 2009 are Chinese, and that as many as 1 in 5 Asians charged with spying were found not guilty, a rate twice as high as that for non-Asian people. Those convicted who had Asian names tended to get harsher sentences, it reported.
U.S. agencies have been issuing warnings about Chinese espionage for years. “Chinese actors are the world’s most active and persistent perpetrators of economic espionage,” a Pentagon report to Congress said in 2012.
A June report by the White House Office of Trade and Manufacturing Policy said China deployed more than 40,000 intelligence agents overseas targeting strategic sectors such as electronics, telecommunications, robotics, data services, pharmaceuticals, cellphone services, satellite communications and imagery, and business application software.
There has been a steady stream of arrests and prosecutions, many involving corporate espionage.
Last month, biochemist Yu Xue, 48, a naturalized American citizen, pleaded guilty to theft of cancer research she developed while working for GlaxoSmithKline, to help a Chinese government-backed company she set up in that country. Yu, who said most of the information was open-source data available on the internet, faces sentencing in December.
A General Electric engineer, Xiaoqing Zheng, 55, a U.S. citizen, was arrested in August, accused of stealing GE power turbine technology, encrypting the data and hiding them in a digital image of a sunset.
In July, a former Apple engineer, Zhang Xiaolang, who had worked on the company’s self-driving car project, was charged with theft of trade secrets. He denies that he took information from the company to benefit his new employer, a motor company in southern China.
Massachusetts resident Shuren Qin, 41, was charged in June with shipping 78 hydrophones — underwater devices used to detect submarines — to a military research institute in Xian, China.
And in January a former IBM software engineer, Jiaqiang Xu, 32, was sentenced to five years in jail for economic espionage and theft of the IBM computer coding.
Several former intelligence officials have also been charged recently with spying.
A retired officer from the Defense Intelligence Agency, Ron Rockwell Hanson, appeared in court on spying charges in July, accused of planning to sell U.S. military secrets to China.
In June, former CIA officer Kevin Mallory was convicted of spying and selling classified documents on defense to the Chinese. Mallory was approached by a Chinese intelligence operative posing as a headhunter via LinkedIn.
Jerry Chun Shing Lee, 53, an American citizen and ex-CIA officer, pleaded not guilty to spying charges in May and faces trial next year.
Must-read stories from the L.A. Times
Get the day's top news with our Today's Headlines newsletter, sent every weekday morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.