Skip to content
More Tumult Besets Guard Unit in Iraq
Three California Army National Guard sergeants have been imprisoned and four other soldiers sentenced to hard labor for their role in abusing Iraqi nationals who were taken into custody near Baghdad and apparently mistaken for insurgents.
The sentences mark the latest development in a tumultuous period for the 1st Battalion of the National Guard's 184th Infantry Regiment.
The battalion has been the subject of a wide-ranging investigation into allegations of misconduct over the last year. In the last month, it has been involved in a spate of violent encounters with insurgents and suicide bombers, leaving four soldiers dead. Overall this year the battalion has had 71 combat-related injuries and seven soldiers killed in action, meaning that about 10% of its soldiers have been wounded or killed.
Lt. Col. Robert L. Whetstone, spokesman for the 3rd Infantry Division in Iraq, said Friday that three sergeants from a Fullerton-based company of the battalion have been confined to military prisons for their role in the abuse of detainees.
All pleaded guilty at special courts-martial and were sentenced by a military judge to terms of up to 12 months of confinement, as well as reduction in rank and forfeiture of pay.
The military has declined to discuss the allegations against the soldiers in detail. But the accusations appear to focus largely on abuse that took place in March at a power plant near Baghdad.
An unknown number of Iraqis were taken into custody there, military officials have said, and were tortured or otherwise mistreated by soldiers.
The Iraqis were believed to be insurgents at the time they were taken into custody, but one member of the battalion, speaking on condition of anonymity because he is not authorized to talk about the incident, said none were insurgents, though several appear to have been common thieves. All but one of the detainees were soon released.
The abuse involved the use of a stun gun on men who were handcuffed. The stun gun was used on at least one man's testicles, the member of the battalion said.
A portion of the abuse was captured on video. A soldier who was not involved in the mistreatment later discovered the footage on a laptop computer and gave it to his commanders.
Other members of the battalion have sought in recent months to downplay the incidents, saying the abuse was led by Iraqi soldiers and was merely witnessed by U.S. soldiers who were patrolling with them.
But Whetstone placed the blame on the American soldiers, saying that although some of them were accused of "failing to stop the abuse of others," none of the abuse "coincided with abuse by Iraqi soldiers."
"Iraqi police were present for one incident of abuse, but there is no evidence that their actions were inappropriate or abusive," Whetstone wrote in an e-mail from Iraq.
The stun-gun incidents are one focus of a broad investigation into possible wrongdoing in the battalion.
Among the accusations that investigators have examined are complaints that soldiers from the battalion charged unauthorized "rent" to Iraqi-owned businesses operating on an Army base.
A first sergeant was also relieved of duty after he was accused of feigning an Iraqi's execution by firing his pistol next to the detainee's temple.
The battalion's commander, Lt. Col. Patrick Frey of Salinas, was suspended from duty. Military officials say he has since been replaced by an active-duty Army officer and reassigned. His current location and assignment are unknown.
Last year, soldiers in the battalion caused a stir by going public with concerns that their training for Iraq was so poor that they would suffer needlessly heavy casualties.
Today, with seven combat deaths, the battalion, headquartered in Modesto, has recorded the most soldiers killed in action of any California unit in Iraq.
"The 1-184 Infantry is operating on the front lines of this fight. The recent casualties they've suffered reflect that reality," said Maj. Jon Siepmann, spokesman for the California Guard.
Most recently, Sgt. Jerry Lee Bonifacio, 28, of Vacaville was killed in a Baghdad car bomb attack Monday. He was manning a checkpoint outside the Green Zone, the international area housing the U.S. Embassy and military headquarters, when a vehicle approaching the gate detonated. Military officials said the vehicle was trying to follow a U.S. military convoy into the compound when the sergeant ordered it to halt.
Bonifacio, who was posthumously promoted to staff sergeant, was a squad leader and mortar man. The military described him as a "quiet professional who always put his soldiers first."
Others killed in action have been identified as Sgt. Arnold Duplantier II, 26, of Sacramento; Spc. Mike Takeshi Sonoda Jr., 34, of Fallbrook; Sgt. Paul C. Neubauer, 40, of Oceanside; Staff Sgt. Daniel R. Scheile, 37, of Antioch; Sgt. Alfredo B. Silva, 35, of Calexico; and Cpl. Glenn Watkins, age unknown, of Washington state.
According to Whetstone, the sergeants who were most recently convicted of charges relating to the abuse of detainees were Louie David, 25, of Carson and Luis Gomez, 28, of La Habra. Both were convicted of dereliction of duty and maltreatment of detainees and sentenced to a reduction in rank and forfeiture of pay and confinement for five and six months in jail, respectively. Gomez will receive a bad-conduct discharge, Whetstone said.
Last month, military officials confirmed the conviction of Sgt. David Fimon, 26 of Poway, who was charged with conspiracy to commit maltreatment of detainees, dereliction of duty, maltreatment of detainees and obstruction of justice. He was sentenced to a reduction in rank, forfeiture of pay and 12 months of confinement, followed by a bad-conduct discharge from the military.
In all, 12 soldiers from the Fullerton-based A Company were charged with misconduct "relating to abuse and maltreatment of detainees," Whetstone said.
Five others pleaded guilty at courts-martial that are considered lower-level proceedings; those soldiers received a reduction in rank, and four were sentenced to periods of hard labor, Whetstone said.
He declined to provide further details about the guilty pleas or identify those soldiers.
Two soldiers were disciplined by their superiors and punished but did not go through courts-martial.
One other soldier is scheduled to plead guilty before a court-martial by the end of the month, and a final case is pending, Whetstone said.
The battalion is scheduled to return to the United States in February.