World & Nation

NATO disputes claim of 11 civilian deaths in Afghan strike

Suicide attack in Wardak
U.S. troops, part of the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force, investigate the site of a suicide attack in Wardak province, east of Kabul, Afghanistan, on Sunday.
(Ahmad Jamshid / Associated Press)

KABUL, Afghanistan -- Afghan officials said Sunday that a NATO air strike in the eastern part of the country killed 16 people, including 11 civilians, a version countered by the international coalition, which said in a statement its attack killed 10 militants with no reported civilian casualties.

Civilian deaths and injuries at the hands of foreign troops remain a highly sensitive political issue in Afghanistan. President Hamid Karzai in February banned Afghan security forces from calling in air strikes in residential areas after 10 civilians were allegedly killed in a NATO night attack in Kunar.

Shujaul Mulk Jalala, the governor for eastern Kunar province, said the strike late Saturday night in Kunar’s Wattapu district killed four women, four children and three men who were riding with five militants in a pickup truck between villages, killing 16 in total. Pickup trucks often serve as public transportation in remote mountainous areas of Afghanistan.

The five militants are believed to be affiliated with Al Qaeda, Jalala said.


Some reports suggested the deaths may have resulted from a drone attack, but this was not confirmed. Conflicting accounts of who, by what means and how many died are not uncommon given remote conditions and a lack of independent observers, especially in the Kunar region bordering Pakistan.

Security analysts say the U.S.-led air strikes are a double-edged sword. On the one hand, they are often effective, especially in remote border and tribal areas, killing many Al Qaeda leaders. But they also kill many ordinary Afghan people, in part because the militants hide among the civilian population and in part because targeting, even as it improves, is never perfect.

Foreign combat troops are scheduled to withdraw from Afghanistan by the end of 2014, placing growing responsibility for national security in the hands of local forces, who often suffer from poor morale, training, equipment and high desertion rates.

Ideally, Afghan ground forces with the help of an indigenous Afghan air force could defend the country without U.S. air support, said Ahmad Sayedi, a Kabul-based military analyst, although that’s unlikely to happen anytime soon.


“We need our own air force,” Sayedi said. “The ground forces are not capable of operating without air support.”

Kunar province has seen intense fighting between the Taliban and American-led NATO and Afghan forces for much of the last 10 years. According to a recent United Nations report, some 1,300 Afghan civilians were killed and more than 2,500 wounded in the first half of 2013, most from insurgent attacks, a 23% increase over the same period of 2012.

In a statement, NATO said it took all allegations of civilian deaths and injuries seriously and would continue to look into reports that civilian casualties resulted from its “precision strike.”

In a separate incident in eastern Wardak province Sunday afternoon, suicide bombers stormed the provincial headquarters of the National Directorate of Security spy agency, killing four intelligence officers and wounding more than 30 others, including women and children, officials said.

The Wardak attack started when a suicide car bomber detonated his explosives-packed vehicle at the gate of the National Directorate of Security offices in Maidan Shahr, the provincial capital, at which point five attackers with suicide vests tried to enter the premises, said Attaullah Khogyani, the governor’s spokesman. He said they faced strong resistance from Afghan security forces.

A gun battle raged between the militants and security forces for more than two hours before the attackers were killed, Khogyani said.

In a statement sent to journalists, the Taliban claimed responsibility for the Wardak attack and said it had killed 10 “enemy forces” and destroyed more than 30 tanks. It isn’t unusual for the Taliban to exaggerate its claims or even take credit for incidents it didn’t plan.

The Taliban has often targeted the National Directorate of Security. In late 2012, a Taliban suicide bomber seriously injured the then-NDS chief, Asadullah Khalid, during a meeting arranged on the pretext of providing intelligence. Khalid remains hospitalized after undergoing surgery several times. The directorate reportedly has some 30 departments employing 15,000 to 30,000 people nationwide, many trained by the U.S. and NATO.



Israeli leader skeptical about Iranian Twitter greetings

Excitement rocks Tokyo upon selection as 2020 Olympics site

EU: Strong evidence Syria used chemical weapons, says U.N. should act

Special correspondent Baktash reported from Kabul and Magnier reported from New Delhi.