California | Local
National
World
Business
Sports
Washington
Science
Environment
Opinion
Entertainment The Hot List Company Town Arts & Culture Calendar The Envelope TV Listings Movie Showtimes
Travel Health Autos Home & Garden Food Image Books Brand X Magazine
Data Desk
Photography
Obituaries
Crosswords/Sudoku
Your Scene
Blogs
Columnists
Print Edition
Readers Rep
Corrections
All Sections
Buy, Sell & More Jobs Cars latcars Real Estate Foreclosure Sale Rentals Personals Local Values Coupons Newspaper Ads
Place an Ad In the Newspaper Online
Settings/Services Sign In Register E-Mail Newsletters
RSS Feeds
Help
Contact Us
L.A. Times Archives
Reprint Requests
Work for Us
Home Delivery Customer Support Subscribe
Entertainment The Hot List Company Town Arts & Culture Calendar The Envelope TV Listings Movie Showtimes
Travel Health Autos Home & Garden Food Image Books Brand X Magazine
Buy, Sell & More Jobs Cars latcars Real Estate Foreclosure Sale Rentals Personals Local Values Coupons Newspaper Ads
Place an Ad In the Newspaper Online
Settings/Services Sign In Register E-Mail Newsletters
RSS Feeds
Help
Contact Us
L.A. Times Archives
Reprint Requests
Work for Us
Home Delivery Customer Support Subscribe
Strong dose of belief helps, too
Many people swear by old and new products, but health experts say there are better ways to fend off or cut short colds or the flu.
» Discuss Article
(46 Comments)
WHEN Nick Rous feels a cold coming on, he starts taking vitamin C and lots of garlic. When people around him come down with the flu, he reaches for echinacea and a homeopathic remedy, Oscillococcinum.
As a last resort, Rous, 30, says he turns to Tylenol and the nasal spray Afrin. "But I try to avoid that stuff as much as possible," says the saxophone player, who lives in San Francisco. "They just treat symptoms, but I feel like it's more productive to do things that boost your immune system and your strength."
As a last resort, Rous, 30, says he turns to Tylenol and the nasal spray Afrin. "But I try to avoid that stuff as much as possible," says the saxophone player, who lives in San Francisco. "They just treat symptoms, but I feel like it's more productive to do things that boost your immune system and your strength."
Like Rous, many Americans are putting their faith in old standbys, such as vitamin C and zinc, and in relative newcomers.
Homeopathic remedies such as Oscillococcinum and combination products such as Airborne are apparently especially appealing.
In 2006, sales of homeopathic immune boosters grew 13%, according to data collected by the Nutrition Business Journal; Airborne's sales jumped nearly 50%, according to company figures. Although sales of formerly popular alternatives such as zinc and echinacea are lagging somewhat (sales dropped more than 6% and 16%, respectively, in 2006, according to the Nutrition Business Journal), they're still among the top sellers for cold and flu - and both, along with vitamin C, are common ingredients in many patented blends.
Homeopathic remedies such as Oscillococcinum and combination products such as Airborne are apparently especially appealing.
In 2006, sales of homeopathic immune boosters grew 13%, according to data collected by the Nutrition Business Journal; Airborne's sales jumped nearly 50%, according to company figures. Although sales of formerly popular alternatives such as zinc and echinacea are lagging somewhat (sales dropped more than 6% and 16%, respectively, in 2006, according to the Nutrition Business Journal), they're still among the top sellers for cold and flu - and both, along with vitamin C, are common ingredients in many patented blends.
"People will go out and spend a whole lot of money on these different products, and unfortunately there's not that much that's been shown to be effective," said Dr. Ian Paul, a pediatrician at Penn State College of Medicine who has studied alternative remedies for coughs in particular (his research has so far shown that honey works better than cough syrup for kids).
In the absence of a cure for the common cold or flu, what most people are seeking is a little relief.
With alternative remedies, as with over-the-counter remedies, said Paul, that relief often comes from the belief that the treatment is working. "There's such a large placebo effect with a lot of these things," he said.
Andrew Shao, vice president of scientific and regulatory affairs for the Council for Responsible Nutrition, a trade association, agreed. "To say that things like vitamin C and zinc don't work wouldn't be totally accurate, because clearly for some people they do."
The research may be equivocal, Shao added, "but you hear people all the time saying, 'Well, I swear by it, it works for me.' "
There are, of course, better ways to treat or prevent a cold or the flu. A healthy diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables helps keep the immune system strong. Getting enough rest is critical for prevention and recovery. Exercise has been shown to reduce cold and flu infections, and so, of course, has frequent hand-washing.
And nothing is more effective at preventing the flu, Paul pointed out, than getting the flu vaccine.
In the absence of a cure for the common cold or flu, what most people are seeking is a little relief.
With alternative remedies, as with over-the-counter remedies, said Paul, that relief often comes from the belief that the treatment is working. "There's such a large placebo effect with a lot of these things," he said.
Andrew Shao, vice president of scientific and regulatory affairs for the Council for Responsible Nutrition, a trade association, agreed. "To say that things like vitamin C and zinc don't work wouldn't be totally accurate, because clearly for some people they do."
The research may be equivocal, Shao added, "but you hear people all the time saying, 'Well, I swear by it, it works for me.' "
There are, of course, better ways to treat or prevent a cold or the flu. A healthy diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables helps keep the immune system strong. Getting enough rest is critical for prevention and recovery. Exercise has been shown to reduce cold and flu infections, and so, of course, has frequent hand-washing.
And nothing is more effective at preventing the flu, Paul pointed out, than getting the flu vaccine.
|
Post Comment |
Discussion What's your favorite cold remedy? Does it always work for you?
This discussion board is archived. Comments will no longer be posted.
1. We drink Greek Mountain tea whenever a family member gets a cold. I'm not sure of the medicinal contents, but the tea helps alot with a stuffy nose and seems to shorten the duration of a cold.
Its a light herbal tea that you can get from most Greek stores. It has no caffeine that I know of, so my wife also prepares it for our daughter when she gets the sniffles.
Submitted by: Mike M 8:15 AM PDT, Mar 24, 2008 Submitted by: Neil 12:43 PM PDT, Mar 18, 2008 Submitted by: Peter 9:22 AM PDT, Mar 15, 2008 |
LM Pagano's house has a timeworn elegance that feels more like New Orleans than Los Angeles. Photos
He is America's premier authority on travel. Now 80, he still can't slow down.
The L.A. Police Chief's four bedroom home is on the market at $1,875,000. Photos
"Bruno" takes the lead, but "Ice Age" and "Transformers" don't fall off much. Photos
- Box office news
- Box office news
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Food Headlines
