READER POLL: ‘The Hobbit’ will triumph but ‘X-Men’ and ‘Pirates’ franchises should quit now


This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.


Talk about heroic: Four film franchises, one decade, more than $10 billion worth of theater tickets sold.


And more than that, in their very best moments, each of these franchises shown above delivered sparkling adventure and escapism for moviegoers. Now, though, with the decade winding down and all four franchises sitting a nice tidy trilogy, the question must be asked: Isn’t three the magic number? Do we really need a fourth movie from any of these aging popcorn enterprises? Clearly, all of them will be written up in the Hollywood history books but right now the indelicate must be asked: ‘How can we miss you if you won’t leave?’

Last week we gave you an in-depth report on this quartet of mega-franchises and their quests for a fourth visit to theaters. We told you how The Hobbit’ must escape the the towering shadow of ‘The Lord of the Rings,’ while Sam Raimi’s ‘Spider-Man’ series needs to get back to its roots to thrive. We also explained that the X-Men’ future looks especially uncertain while the Pirates of the Caribbean’ franchise might be facing a one-man mutiny with Johnny Depp’s distress over recent changes at Disney.

We also put the question to you: Which of these franchises is making a mistake by adding a fourth film?

You made it clear that ‘The Hobbit,’ with director Guillermo del Toro taking over with a new vision, is in a class by itself -- the other franchises may tack on new editions to cash in, but fans are expecting nothing but magic from Del Toro’s arrival in Middle-earth. The remaining three franchises got a frostier reception. For five days last week, more than half of our reader voters named ‘Pirates’ as the cinematic series that should walk the plank. Over the weekend that changed and (with a lot of late-arriving Depp fans?) the surging ‘X-Men’ became the top choice as a franchise hitting bottom.

It’s not too late, though, we’ll take votes for the next 48 hours before declaring our, uh, winning loser. In the meantime, thanks for reading, commenting and voting.

-- Geoff Boucher



Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man regrets: ‘I would have done everything differently’

Surprised author Tim Powers finds himself aboard ‘Pirates’ ship

Depp: ‘There’s a crack in my enthusiasm’ for ‘Pirates’ 4

Peter Jackson: Movie fans are ‘fed up with the lack of original ideas’

‘The Hobbit’ is just the beginning of the del Toro Decade

Daniel Radcliffe as Bilbo Baggins? ‘Potter’ stars says thanks but no

Hugh Jackman says there’s a lot of Mike Tyson in Wolverine

Photos at top, from left, Ian McKellen in ‘Lord of the Rings,’ Tobey Maguire in ‘Spider-Man,’ Halle Berry in ‘X-Men: The Last Stand’ and Johnny Depp in ‘Pirates of the Caribbean.’ Credits from left: New Line Cinema, Sony Pictures, 20th Century Fox, Walt Disney Studios. Bottom photo of Sam Raimi by Ken Hively / Los Angeles Times