‘Condoblue’ explains: Why I’m walking away

This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.

An update this morning from Condoblue. For those of you just joining us, Condoblue is the poster who plans to walk away from a mortage and move into a new home -- even if it means foreclosure. Reaction here was split on whether Blue’s decision was a smart business move, or a sign of poor personal character. Condoblue read your comments and responds this morning:

‘As the original poster, I’d like to add some facts to the story since there have been so many assumptions made about my situation. Apparently, it hit quite a nerve, judging from the torrent of postings.

‘I did not get House #1 with a liar loan; it was fully documented. I could have put money down but chose to hold on to my cash. As it turns out, the value has dropped so much, it would have just been money down the drain anyway. I never planned to flip the place or make a quick buck (although I don’t see anything wrong with making money). I just figured I’d sell or refinance it before the ARM readjusted. At the time I was looking, it was one of the cheapest condos I could find in a decent area.

‘I don’t have a grudge against big companies (hell, I work for one) or feel like I’m ‘sticking it to the man.’ Like many posters have said, it’s just business.

I have a good income, credit, and savings, so am qualified to buy House #2 using my savings as a down payment. I have adequate income to meet the lenders’ debt ratios to cover both homes, and then some. Servicing the debt is not an issue. Ironically, House #2 is a short sale.

When I applied for the loan on House #2, I expected the lender to question the upside-down status of House #1 (they can Zillow as well as I can), but they approved the loan with no questions or issues. I was surprised that they didn’t even ask how much the new ARM payment on House #1 would be, but was told that they don’t take that into consideration. Huh?

As for Big Lender on House #1, I called their loan department to see if I could refinance the mortgages and was told they don’t refi homes with negative equity. I asked the loan officer if they have any programs available for people in my situation. He said he didn’t know of anything, but that they did have loan counseling people available, but you have to fill out a questionnaire first before they’ll talk to you. So I called another 800 number to get the questionnaire and requested it via their automated voice system. That was 2 weeks ago; no questionnaire (not that I have a hardship anyway). Later, buried on Big Lender’s website, I saw where they supposedly contact borrowers 4 months before their loan reset, which would be early February. We’ll see.

In terms of selling House #1, this is a cookie cutter condo in a town full of them, so it’s easy to figure out its market value (zilch) and average days on market (eternity). There are plenty of short sales right here in the neighborhood, and they are not moving.

Finally, I realize my credit score will take a hit, but remember that I don’t need to rent since I own House #2. I have stable long-term employment, decent car, and no debt so speak of. So what if my car insurance goes up a bit. Incidentally, the Federal tax-exempt status on mortgage debt forgiveness is only temporary, so if you are considering walking away from your equity-less home, better call your CPA and lawyer to find out the rules and start making plans...’

Thanks, Blue. Your thoughts? Comments? Be respectful, and please don’t expect Condoblue to explain every intricate financial detail of these transactions. There’s a lot of information here.
Read below for Condoblue’s first post.
I am one of these people. My condo has dropped in value from $520K in 5/06 when I bought it to $350K now. My ARM payment will probably go up $900 per month in June.

‘Despite all this, I would be willing to stay if the bank would refi the loans to a 30 year fixed, but since I’m not a ‘hardship’ case they’d apparently rather foreclose. I guess the only way I could qualify for loan mitigation is to get my boss to fire me, stop making payments, and wreck my credit. In fact, my bank won’t even talk to me until I miss a couple of payments.

‘I have purchased a cheaper place in a nearby area now, while my credit is good, and will stop making payments on house #1 after house #2 closes. I know the foreclosure will be on my credit for 7 years, but I will have saved a lot of money.

‘I realize I agreed to the deal when I signed the mortgage papers, but I am within my rights to walk away from a bad deal and suffer the consequences, just as many corporations write down billions of dollars of debt, lose money for their shareholders, and lay off people as a result of their bad decisions.

‘I don’t really understand why people view a business decision by a homeowner as a terrible moral lapse. However, when large lending institutions, with access to more sophisticated information than any consumer could imagine, make mistakes affecting thousands of people worldwide, they are not excoriated and vilified with the same righteous zeal.’