Opinion: Most commented: Our readers’ Weiner obsession

This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.

The Anthony Weiner scandal has some people asking: Is this actually news? Even our editorial on the subject of Weinergate began with an admission:

We really, really don’t want to be writing about Weinergate. Seriously. The travails of Rep. Anthony Weiner seem so much like a piece of here-today, gone-tomorrow political theater, a manufactured controversy just titillating enough to keep the Twittersphere thrumming, that we’d rather not add to the national embarrassment by throwing more ink at it. And yet…

And yet: Our editorial board chimed in, weighing in on how the congressman might best handle his situation. ‘Coming clean might be less embarrassing than continuing to feed the media beast,’ they advise.

And yet: That’s what readers are commenting on as well, with a range of reactions from why Weiner’s story matters and that the congressman should resign, to why we shouldn’t care and move on. Here’s a sampling.


He’s totally hiding something

This would have been a story that lasted 15 minutes if he said ‘that’s not me, someone hacked my account, and I’ve asked the FBI to look into it’. Seriously, he brought this on himself. What person cannot answer the question ‘is that your crotch?’ What elected official with a security clearance would not call the FBI and ask them to deal with a potential breech? --smom42

The guy has bad judgment

Regardless of his merits as a legislator, clearly you have to admit this is a case of egregious personal behavior and even worse judgment in terms of his response. --EfrainRojas

He doesn’t deserve to represent the people of this country

He is so obviously lying yet the news media continue to give him the benefit of the doubt...why? He doesn’t know how many pictures of him are out there? Has he posed for so many pictures in is underwear he’s lost count? He doesn’t know what his underwear looks like? A member of Congress has had his electronic account hacked and he hasn’t filed a complaint under the guise that he doesn’t want to waste taxpayer money. Since when has Rep Weiner cared about wasting our money. He’s done nothing about it because he knows he sent the picture. He can’t even land on one version of his story as to how the picture got out. It is past time for him to leave. He doesn’t deserve to represent the people of this country. --Snotlaw

Weiner should resign

Wasn’t there a Republican who emailed his bare chest to one woman he met on Craigslist and then he RESIGNED not too long ago? This Democrat sent a picture of his CROTCH to several people on Twitter and he still hasn’t resigned? Weiner why don’t you resign like Congressman Chris Lee? Oh the hypocrisy of liberals. --JimmyJam

Meh… Who cares?

The congressman isn’t obligated to reveal his naughty secrets unless they’re political. This is personal--lying is excusable out of embarrassment and protecting his career. Media’s job is exposing personal and professional dirt on prominent people...journalists notate these trivialities for historical records. If newsworthy, ferret it out--Question is, is it news? And is tweeting one lewd photo to someone over eighteen harassment under the law? Hardly qualifies as lewdness if he wore briefs in the pic. Is giving too much attention to this story absurd? Who cares if Rep. Anthony Weiner tweeted a mildly indecent picture. Holding a distinguished position doesn’t make him virtuous, and ascetics don’t populate the U.S., not at all. If people act affronted over this trifle they’re faking it. --Mia303

No, but really: It’s time to move on

Another petty distraction. Let’s get real people. --dandestripes

*Spelling errors in the above comments were corrected.


College shouldn’t be a big waste of time and money

Accusations of reverse discrimination

Obama’s so smart, he sounds dumb?

The best solution for the Mississippi River

Drilling for oil on our turf

--Alexandra Le Tellier