Question of the day: Which city has the best baseball fans?

This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.

Reporters from around Tribune Co. tackle the question of the day, then you get a chance to chime in and tell them why they’re wrong. Check back throughout the day for updates.

Phil Rogers, Chicago Tribune

Listen to baseball on TV and every night you’ll hear a local broadcaster praise his audience for being ‘the best fans in baseball.’ From New York to both sides of Chicago, in Los Angeles, St. Louis and even places such as Detroit and Houston, the distinction is thrown around cheaply. But the fans who truly deserve the distinction are the ones who still show up at PNC Park in Pittsburgh, hands down.

The Pirates are on pace to 54-108, their 18th consecutive losing season and second-worst in franchise history, yet they still average a crowd of 20,070, more than the Marlins, Athletics and Indians.


That’s impressive. This is a small market that has had a challenging economic situation, but somehow the Pirates are on pace to have their attendance slip by only a little more than 200,000 from 1992, when Barry Bonds helped them win 96 games and finish a Francisco Cabrera single away from the World Series. Give it up for the Pittsburgh fans! They’re the best in baseball -– and, yes, they deserve a lot better.

Updated at 11:55 a.m.

Dom Amore, Hartford Courant

The question within this question is how does one define “best baseball fans’? Does it mean the greatest in number? The loudest? The most loyal? The most knowledgeable?

I’m going with Pittsburgh. . . . Crazy? The Pirates draw well below the MLB average each year to their beautiful new stadium, so how can Pittsburgh have the greatest fans? Easy. Because it isn’t easy being a baseball fan in Pittsburgh, not like it is in New York, Boston or even the north side of Chicago.
This is not about small markets and payroll. Over the last 15 years, there has been ample evidence that such teams can win — with good management. The Bucs have put their fans through 18 consecutive losing seasons. They have unloaded popular players and gotten little in return.

And yet, the fans there are in Pittsburgh, having faithfully supported their franchise since 1882, haven’t disappeared. The Pirates continue to draw about 1.5 million each year, and those folks come out in all kinds of weather, hoping against hope that this will be the year. The city may not have the most or the loudest, but if baseball fans could earn a medal for enduring hardship, I’d pin it on Pittsburghers.

Updated at 12:24 p.m.

Mike DiGiovanna, Los Angeles Times

I haven’t been in National League stadiums enough over the years to rank their fans, but in the American League I’d have to go with Minnesota. The fans there are enthusiastic, cheer at the right time and know the game without being pretentious about it, like fans in New York and Boston can sometimes be.

Twins fans are extremely supportive, but they appreciate good baseball, whether it’s played by the home or visiting team. It’s fairly standard in Minnesota to see a standing ovation for an opponent who makes an outstanding defensive play.

And now, after decades of playing indoor baseball in the Metrodome, the Twins and their fans have taken their act outdoors, to new Target Field, a beautiful facility where, not surprisingly, the Twins have sold out all but one game this season.