Turn-of-the-century honor lost : MARTHE, A WOMAN AND A FAMILY: A <i> FIN-DE-SIECLE </i> CORRESPONDENCE, translated by Donald M. Frame (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: $15.95; 361 pp.)
- Share via
How sharper than a serpent’s tooth it is to have a thankless child. --Shakespeare’s “King Lear”
The wayward, and thankless, child has been with us as long as parenthood has, even though society’s concept of “wrong” and “right” changes almost by the year: Yesterday’s hippie movement is today’s self-expression.
But, somehow, being sexually promiscuous at age 14, and pregnant by a farmhand at 18, is, even today, a pretty sure way for a daughter to bend her mother out of shape. At the turn of the 20th Century (fin-de-siecle), it was an unmitigated disaster if you were a member of the landed gentry in France and painfully conscious of your role in “proper” society and of the damage that wagging tongues can do to a proud reputation.
“Marthe, a Woman and a Family,” is a remarkable collection of correspondence between distraught members of the De Montbourg and De Cerilley families in the period 1892-1902, as they wrestle with, “what are we going to do about. . . ?” (in this case, Marthe, but almost any family could easily substitute for another). The letters were unearthed in the attic of a French chateau about 10 years ago.
Wealthy, even by today’s standards (with an estate estimated between $600,000 and $3 million), the De Montbourgs, nevertheless, have a status problem that money, alone, doesn’t entirely solve: Who can they find to make an honest woman of madcap Marthe, a man who isn’t either a certifiable basket case or bounty hunter?
While Emile, Marthe’s perennially semi-hysteric mother, sneaks the girl off to the anonymity of a Parisian home for unwed mothers, most of the actual recruiting is left to poor old, Job-patient uncle Charles de Cerilley. And it is Uncle Charles who garners most of our sympathy as he tries to maintain some sort of family stability as Emile’s self-pitying letters inundate him. (“Affectionately, your unhappy sister. . . . Affectionately, your ever-afflicted sister. . . . Affectionately, your sad sister.”)
Despite a handsome dowry (how else?), the talent search takes nearly two years as priest, relatives and even personal ads are enlisted in lining up someone suitable to salve the family honor. A pharmacist, a postal worker and two stationmasters make it to the semi-finals, but the final role of retroactive cuckold finally falls to a “pleasant” 33-year-old whose background suggests that, by now, hard-pressed Uncle Charles and still-distraught Emile have lowered their standards appreciably.
Robert d’Aillot, the possessor of a “good” name (there’s that, at least), is hardly the 19th-Century equivalent of a Harvard MBA in the good-catch department. His main claim to professional fame is managing his father’s estate, and, since his father is a retired customs official on a small pension, Robert’s responsibilities begin and end with taking a few vegetables and milk to market occasionally.
Instinctively, the reader knows only too well that this combination of Marthe’s, shall we say, giving ways, combined with Robert’s new-found, and heady, move onto the lower rungs of the petite noblesse , spell nothing but trouble.
Trouble indeed as Marthe’s lusty appetite for bedroom romping (“I’m sorry, I didn’t catch the name”), and Robert’s latent instincts for family blackmail come to a predictable head.
These fascinating letters have a universal timelessness about them--the close-knit family under siege--even as they chronicle a rigid French social structure beginning to topple. Our heroine, Marthe, emerges only peripherally, most of her own contribution to the correspondence beginning only after her--horrors--divorce.
Slowly, inevitably, we watch the family crumble and fall apart . . . old, dark secrets surfacing that help explain Emile’s near-paranoia over her wayward daughter . . . legal wrangles erupting . . . sickness and death taking their toll. And yet, somehow, that turn-of-the-century dignity still remaining largely intact.
More to Read
Sign up for our Book Club newsletter
Get the latest news, events and more from the Los Angeles Times Book Club, and help us get L.A. reading and talking.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.