The Ryan Reserve Sale

I would like to correct the impression conveyed in a recent article (“Places in the Heart,” Nov. 11) that the University of California acted without the approval of Frances Ryan in selling the 15-acre Ryan Glen Oak Reserve in Escondido. The reserve had been donated to the university’s Natural Reserve System by Mrs. Ryan and her late husband in 1972.

In 1987, a faculty committee concluded that the site was receiving little use due to its small size, the impact of surrounding development, the absence of support facilities and other factors. The committee recommended that we negotiate a long-term agreement with another agency that could more beneficially use the site.

On Oct. 29, 1987, I met with Mrs. Ryan and her second cousin, Ethel Norman (whom she had invited), and explained the situation, including alternative courses of action. I emphasized that, in keeping with the terms of the gift, any disposition would require her explicit approval.

Over the ensuing months, there were numerous discussions with Mrs. Ryan and her advisers. The city of Escondido, school districts, the local historical society and others were approached but, for a variety of reasons, they were unable to take on management of the property.

Ultimately, the arrangement that emerged as the most palatable to all concerned, including Mrs. Ryan, was to sell the property to Mr. and Mrs. Norman. The Normans agreed to a restricted covenant, which effectively placed 13 of the site’s 15 acres permanently in “open space” (consistent with the Ryans’ original intent).

On June 22, 1988, Mrs. Ryan agreed in writing to the sale. Some have asked why we did not maintain the “status quo” until after her death. In view of the committee’s report, I felt strongly that Mrs. Ryan deserved to be involved in the disposition and to have the assurance and satisfaction of knowing how the property was to be utilized during her remaining years and thereafter.

Proceeds from the $80,000 sale have been placed in an endowment to fund grants for student research conducted on our 26 natural reserves. The first competition attracted 27 applicants. Seven students were awarded from $750 to $1,000 each.

J. ROGER SAMUELSEN

Director, Natural Reserve System

University of California