Advertisement

Next Step : Toward a New Kind of Latin Revolution: Power to the Middle Class : The Bush plan aims to revive laggard economies with investment, trade and debt relief. The wealthy oligarchies would lose out in the process.

Share
TIMES STAFF WRITER

President Bush’s new program offering Latin American countries unprecedented opportunities to expand trade ties with the United States, win help in reducing their debts and attracting foreign investment is meant to foment nothing less than a new revolution in the region.

While he has not said so specifically, Bush wants to see power in Latin America wrested from the corrupt oligarchies that have dominated the region’s economies for the past four decades and transferred to the long-fettered middle class, according to knowledgeable analysts.

And the big question now is how aggressively the region’s new democratic governments will respond. Initial reactions have been positive but slow in coming. Chile was the first to express interest in such a trade pact.

Advertisement

The oligarchies, a legacy of the Spanish conquistadores, controlled their economies directly until the 1950s, when Argentine economist Raul Prebisch captured the region’s fancy with a call for protection from imports, which was accompanied by a move to state ownership of private industry.

When the region adopted Prebisch’s policies, the government-owned enterprises became the major drain on national economies and provided a steady channel of income for the top economic classes, which obtained ownership shares and provided management skills.

Today, state-run industries that in many cases benefit only a handful of wealthy families are subsidized by government borrowing and by taxes imposed on the relatively small populations of middle-class taxpayers. Latin economies are choking on the resulting debt.

Alan J. Stoga, analyst for Kissinger Associates, former Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger’s New York consulting firm, argues that restructuring the Latin economies so they can operate on free-market principles is as central to any recovery in the hemisphere as it is to Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union.

“There’s absolutely no doubt that absent any restructuring of the Latin economies, there is nothing even worth talking about,” Stoga said. “There will be no partnership at all.”

That is the rationale behind Bush’s trade-rather-than-aid approach. The new democratic governments are strapped by debt and crippling inflation. If Washington can encourage them to abandon “Prebischism,” it can weaken the oligarchies and boost the middle class.

Advertisement

That, in turn, would help democracy take root, bolster American economic ties with the region and strengthen American security interests throughout the Southern Hemisphere, according to government and private strategists who specialize in Latin America.

Although Bush’s new proposals have attracted little attention, analysts say they constitute the most sweeping set of incentives since the “Alliance for Progress” program that John F. Kennedy proposed to help counter Fidel Castro’s appeal in the 1960s. Here are the major points:

* The United States will negotiate a bilateral free-trade agreement--designed to cut tariffs and increase the flow of trade--with any Latin country that is willing to undertake the kinds of reforms needed to shift to a market-oriented economic system. U.S. and Mexico already have begun preliminary work aimed at launching more formal trade talks later this year.

* Washington will help set up a $300-million international lending pool to finance the infrastructure and technical aid needed to convert state-owned industries into private corporations and attract more foreign investment to the region.

* Reversing its previous opposition, Washington would consider forgiving portions of the billions of dollars in debts that Latin countries owe the U.S. government--a first step toward matching the writedowns that commercial banks have taken on their Latin loans.

* And last week, Bush asked the annual seven-nation economic summit in Houston to launch a multibillion-dollar international effort to provide aid and technical help to Latin countries just as the Western nations have done for Eastern Europe.

Advertisement

The series of rapid-fire proposals has come as a result of a rare personal involvement by the President, reflecting both his own longtime interest in the region and his belief that helping to bolster democracy there is important to U.S. national interests.

Though born in Connecticut, Bush spent much of his early career in Texas, where--as Commerce Secretary (and fellow Texan) Robert A. Mosbacher says--”you learn a lot about the Mexican economy almost by osmosis.” One of Bush’s sons, Jeb, married a Mexican national.

More important, Bush acquired a professional interest in Latin American during his years as director of the CIA and, later, as vice president--an interest that continues today.

Besides rushing out his new initiatives, Bush is scheduled to visit Brazil, Argentina and other Latin American countries in September. U.S. strategists say he has tentatively decided to take three more trips to the region over the next 12 months.

To be sure, there is no guarantee that Bush’s new proposals will have a major impact. As Washington’s cynics have pointed out, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have been pressuring the Latins for years to make needed reforms, without success.

Just the same, by accident or not, Bush’s new proposals come at a time when many of the region’s new democratic governments are moving precisely in that direction--and may be receptive to the promise of expanded markets abroad.

Advertisement

Mexico, under President Carlos Salinas de Gortari, has begun a sweeping reform of its economic and trade policies that virtually reverses four decades of corporate statism. Brazil just announced an even more dramatic overhaul.

Venezuela has made some modest but important reforms. Argentina is just beginning. Costa Rica and many of the smaller Latin American countries are moving rapidly toward free-market economies.

Moreover, the shift is being accelerated by a growing fear among Latin American governments that the increasing preoccupation of the Western powers with the emerging East European democracies will leave little or nothing in the aid pot for Latin America.

It is just for that reason that Bush’s own new program--offering opportunities for expanded trade benefits and for an international aid effort--virtually parallels the one that the allies have set up for the former Eastern Bloc.

Many of the region’s new governments are actively pondering the President’s proposal, and it is hoped more will be ready to respond by the time Bush visits the area in mid-September.

But the real test will come after that, when--if the Latins take Bush up on his plan--the United States must make good on the President’s offer.

Advertisement

The Latins have made some progress before, noted Kissinger Associates’ Stoga, but Washington has not always provided the rewards.

If both sides come through and Washington forges a genuine partnership with the region, Stoga says, that could be a real revolution. If not, both sides will be disappointed--again.

Advertisement