Advertisement

5 Candidates Debate, Focus on Economy : Democrats: Rancorous clash is attempt to get presidential campaigns on track after the Clinton scandal stole spotlight.

Share
TIMES POLITICAL WRITER

The five Democratic presidential contenders thrashed out their differences over the economy, health care and education Friday night in a sometimes rancorous televised debate, trying to get their candidacies back on track after the most turbulent week of the 1992 campaign.

Arkansas Gov. Bill Clinton sought to use the two-hour confrontation, which focused mainly on economic policy, to return to the issues that made him the presumed front-runner in the race before he was forced to defend himself against unsubstantiated allegations of marital infidelity.

He stressed his experience as a governor, a post in which he said he had served on “the cutting edge of change,” and his moderate approach to reviving the economy.

Advertisement

“The thing that bothers me is not that people make money,” he said at one point. “I’d like to create more millionaires than (Presidents Ronald) Reagan or Bush did. . . . What you want is more income equality, and you want people to make money the old-fashioned way, by investing in our goods, our products and our services. And that’s what the Democrats ought to be about.”

His rivals--former California Gov. Edmund G. (Jerry) Brown, Jr., Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin, Nebraska Sen. Bob Kerrey and former Massachusetts Sen. Paul E. Tsongas--sought to use the debate to draw attention to their own remedies for the nation’s economic woes.

“I decided to run to rescue the nation’s economy,” Tsongas said. “You cannot do that with giveaways and tax breaks. I’m not running to be Santa Claus. I’m running to be President. My job is to rescue this country so people can have a job . . . so they can provide for their families.”

While Tsongas contended the Democratic Party needed to shift away from its tradition of liberal activism in economic policy, Harkin sought to reaffirm and renew that legacy.

“What I’m calling for is a new New Deal,” Harkin said. “I want to say let’s start focusing on people, let’s put them to work, start educating our kids and let’s have a national health insurance program. That’s bottom-up, percolate-up economics, not trickle-down economics.”

Brown, who has cast himself as the anti-Establishment candidate and the champion of voter resentment, said: “I think people are frustrated. They’re angry. They look out at America and they know we’re strong; we’re the richest country in the world and yet . . . our automobile industry is declining, our ports are not competing . . . our cities are deteriorating.

Advertisement

“We need real reform. We have to reform the politics, the tax code, the industrial policy, our health system. And as we do that, we will be . . . in the beginning of a golden age.”

Kerrey urged adoption of an “industrial policy that focuses on the training and skills of our people.”

He added: “Our gasoline tank is empty because we haven’t invested in plants and equipment. Business people are clipping coupons instead of investing in things that create jobs. And we’ve let the foundation--our transportation and communication system--deteriorate.”

The charges of infidelity against Clinton surfaced only at the very end of the debate, during a discussion of character as a campaign issue. “What is the biggest character issue out there right now?” asked Brown. “It’s the stories on Bill Clinton, isn’t it, and whether there’s an issue there or whether there isn’t and whether or not it betokens a respect for women.”

Kerrey responded that the focus on the adultery issue--sparked by an Arkansas woman’s claim, published in a supermarket tabloid, that she and Clinton had been involved in an affair for 12 years--is “not legitimate. What’s legitimate is our issues, our ideas, our agenda. That’s what’s legitimate in this campaign.”

Brown then said: “Every time a woman makes a claim, she’s always viewed as lying or a bimbo.”

Advertisement

Clinton, who has strongly denied the woman’s allegations and who has appeared on CBS-TV’s “60 Minutes” Sunday with his wife to discuss his personal life, was asked if he wanted to reply. He said: “I think I’ve said all I need to say about that. And I think the American people have got more of me and my wife and our life together than they ever thought they’d get in this primary process.”

The two-hour debate was staged at a public television station studio in suburban Virginia and moderated by PBS newsmen Jim Lehrer and Robert MacNeil. While the candidates spent much of their time castigating Bush--especially his State of the Union address earlier this week--they also engaged in several critical sharp exchanges among themselves.

One of the sharpest of these erupted during a discussion of the health care issue. It came after Clinton declared: “If one of us gets elected President, we’ll have national health care for everybody. Any one of these (programs) will save $100 billion over the way we’re going.”

That angered Kerrey, who has made a national health insurance plan the centerpiece of his campaign and claims more expertise on the issue than any of his rivals.

Kerrey said: “I have a very specific program,” and he disputed whether Clinton had offered one.

“On health care (Clinton) doesn’t answer the question,” Kerrey charged. “And I’m telling you, Gov. Clinton, you’re trying to have it both ways. At least tell the American people what you’re for.

Advertisement

“Read my program,” replied Clinton, who then criticized Kerrey’s health care proposal because it calls for a tax increase as a substitute for premiums.

“If you lead with a tax increase in a system where costs are out of control, you’ll never get control of the costs,” Clinton said.

Tsongas directed some of the harshest criticism at Bush. At one point he said: “There is no principle that George Bush is not willing to sabotage for his own benefit.”

Advertisement