Historic ‘Remnant of Israel’ Celebrates Legacy

Storm-tossed in the Caribbean and captured by pirates, 23 Jews fleeing oppression in Brazil eventually landed in 1654 in what is now New York and formed America’s first Jewish congregation.

Descended from survivors of the Spanish Inquisition, these pioneer American Jews called themselves the “remnant of Israel”--in Hebrew, Shearith Israel.

“It’s a wonder there was a remnant at all,” said Rabbi Marc Angel, spiritual head of the synagogue on Central Park West that has been the congregation’s home since 1897.

To mark the temple’s centennial this year, Shearith Israel has been searching for descendants of 1897 member families for a reunion.

Meanwhile, the congregation--whose members have included a U.S. Supreme Court justice, three founders of the New York Stock Exchange and poet Emma Lazarus--continues to welcome and succor survivors of persecution.

“We lost 80 members of our family, everyone except me and my mother’s cousin, who is here,” said Mirella Axelrad, whose family fled Europe during the Holocaust.

She now lives in Bolivia and visited the synagogue for her infant grandson’s recent circumcision. Her eyes teared up, then she smiled and said “he’s safe here,” in her native Italian.

The congregation of 600 families traces its roots to Jews exiled from Catholic Spain and Portugal in the 1500s. Some eventually wound up in Brazil, under more tolerant Dutch colonizers.

A century later, the Portuguese ousted the Dutch, and Brazil’s Jews again fled in search of a haven. The 23 who got lost in the Caribbean and fell into the hands of buccaneers were rescued by a French vessel and finally made it to the Dutch colony of New Amsterdam on the Hudson River.

There, they and their descendants worshiped in rented space in lower Manhattan until 1730, when they turned an old grist mill into a synagogue, the first in the American colonies.

Three more sites followed before the congregation built its present home, facing Central Park, on a former duck farm.

The original “23 souls, big and little,” as a Dutch document called them, grew into a religious community that has served some prominent New Yorkers.

One, Judith Kaye, chief judge of the Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, has worshiped at Shearith Israel for 30 years.

“My moment of greatest joy came in the temple when the Torah was placed in my arms for the first time,” the judge said, referring to the sacred scrolls. “Women don’t usually carry the Torah.”

Benjamin Cardozo, who served on the U.S. Supreme Court, also was a member of the congregation. So was Lazarus, who penned the lines on the base of the Statue of Liberty: “Give me your tired, your poor. . . .”

New York now has the largest Jewish population of any city in the world, at more than 1 million. But when the first 23 Jews docked here, they were hardly met with open arms. The Dutch governor, Peter Stuyvesant, described them as “very repugnant” to the magistrates and people of his colony.

“He finally told them they could stay,” Angel said, “but they had to be unobtrusive, and the governor said that if they got sick or were in need, they had to take care of their own.”

One of them, Asser Levy, chafed at the idea that he paid taxes to the Dutch but was allowed none of a resident’s privileges or duties, such as guarding the city gates. In one of America’s earliest civil rights cases, Levy demanded--and won--the right to do guard duty.

The small religious community survived, however, largely because members got along with non-Jews and with later-arriving Jews of different backgrounds, Angel said. In colonial times, he noted, Ashkenazi Jews from Central Europe were embraced by Shearith Israel’s Sephardic Jews, whose roots are Mediterranean.

To this day, the congregation follows Sephardic tradition during services, but welcomes worshipers of varied backgrounds, including Reform Jews.

“We follow basic tradition, but we’re not rigid,” said Angel’s son, Hayyim, 27, also a rabbi.

“About 50 years ago, if a man walked into the synagogue without a hat, he’d be sent to the back row. We don’t do that now. We train them instead.”