A Milestone Year, for a Decidedly Dubious Reason
The major networks began to look a little like ratings dinosaurs during the just-concluded 1996-97 TV season, while NBC--despite losing some of its grandeur--remained the industry’s Tyrannosaurus rex.
NBC not only lumbered off with the season’s ratings crown but also this week wrapped up its 10th consecutive win during a sweeps period--the key months local stations use to negotiate advertising rates.
CBS finished second in overall viewing during May, as every network but NBC equaled or improved its results versus a year ago.
Even so, ABC capped a historically low season with a disappointing sweeps performance, failing to make a splash with its big-budget miniseries, “The Shining” and “20,000 Leagues Under the Sea.” The network did eke out second place in the key demographics that dictate ad rates, while CBS remained last by that standard.
"[Viewers] came back for the big events,” said CBS Entertainment President Leslie Moonves, referring to the sweeps. “We feel like if you put on quality shows, they will come.”
The networks obviously weren’t so compelling, however, for the duration of the broadcast year, which began in September and concluded Wednesday.
During that period, cable and other alternatives continued to take a sizable bite out of the broadcast audience, as ABC, CBS and NBC for the first time dipped below half of prime-time viewing on an average night, combining for 49% of the audience.
The network decline has been severe. Fifteen years ago, the Big Three networks totaled more than 80% of the audience. A decade ago, 46 prime-time series averaged a 15 rating or higher, while this season only eight did.
To say all those viewers left network television would be misleading, since Fox adds to the pie and two baby networks, UPN and WB, have joined the fray; moreover, the four networks still attract roughly 60% of nightly viewing despite the proliferation of options, with nearly 70% of homes receiving several dozen channels thanks to cable.
“Part of it is that there are more and more entertainment options out there, and not just on the television dial,” said Giles Lundberg, Fox’s head of research and marketing.
Nevertheless, there’s no arguing that ABC, CBS and NBC continue to erode dramatically, losing 8% of their combined audience this season (the percentage drops to 4% with Fox included). At the same time, cable maintained the steady and inexorable growth it’s enjoyed in recent years, up 9% in prime time, due in part to more channels as well as to greater emphasis on original programming.
“It’s growth both from the newer guys and the more mature networks,” said Bob Sieber, head of research for the Turner cable networks.
Despite their ratings slide, the networks find some solace in the fact that they stemmed the tide of viewer defections during May, as audiences showed up for some of the big miniseries like “The Odyssey” and “The Last Don,” as well as events such as “Ellen’s” coming out and the birth on “Mad About You.”
In the current environment, however, gains for one network come largely at the expense of another, rather than from cable. And except for certain events, like the Super Bowl or Olympics, viewers who don’t watch network television seem harder than ever to woo back.
Within the network universe, NBC--the network with the Peacock logo--can again crow about victories in prime time, late night (where “The Tonight Show With Jay Leno” maintains a substantial lead over “Late Show With David Letterman”), early morning (“Today” widened the gap versus “Good Morning America”) and a first-place tie with ABC in nightly news. Even the third-place daytime lineup is in its most competitive position in years.
Still, NBC’s prime-time ratings dropped significantly from last season. The network was watched by 15.2 million people during an average hour, compared to 17 million the year before. By contrast, CBS (13.8 million) and Fox (11.6 million) were both up slightly.
The big loser was clearly ABC, which lost 13% of its audience, dropping behind CBS to an average of 13.5 million viewers.
ABC finished second among adults 18-49, the most crucial age group to most advertisers, barely edging Fox, which wound up with its best relative finish in its 10-year history.
ABC’s problems are numerous but stem principally from the decline of key programs like “Roseanne,” “Home Improvement” and “Grace Under Fire” while failing to generate new hits to replace them. NBC hastened that demise by scheduling some of its most popular shows, including “Frasier,” against ABC’s once (but no longer) dominant Tuesday lineup.
Thursday’s “Must See TV” roster, meanwhile, continues to separate NBC from the pack, with “ER” edging “Seinfeld” as the most-watched program for the second straight year.
Those shows, each attracting more than 30 million viewers a week, are largely responsible for NBC winning the last two seasons. ABC, in fact, actually won more nights, underscoring the importance of that lineup in NBC’s margin of victory.
NBC has found it difficult expanding the “Must See” franchise beyond Thursday, though not for lack of trying. Despite mediocre results with sitcoms Monday and Wednesday this season, the network will schedule a record 18 comedies across five nights in the fall.
NBC Entertainment President Warren Littlefield explained that the network is “trying to spread out our offense” to new nights. Despite losing viewers, NBC ruled the demographic race by the widest margin in a decade--when Bill Cosby was on its schedule--and scored the first back-to-back prime-time wins since CBS won three consecutive years, ending in 1993-94.
As for Cosby, his new CBS program was far from a runaway hit but did become the highest-rated comedy to open a night at 8 p.m. since his last show a dozen years ago.
Fox not only improved compared to last season but launched one of the few new-series hits in “King of the Hill,” which successfully bridged the gap between “The Simpsons” and “The X-Files” Sunday nights. Moving “X-Files” also bore ratings dividends that more than offset the decline experienced Fridays by replacing it with a new show, “Millennium.”
Fox’s overall results were aided in part by televising two of the year’s top sporting events, the Super Bowl and the World Series. In a case of the rich possibly getting richer, NBC will broadcast both next season.
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Top 20 Series of ’96-'97 Season
Avg Viewers Network in Millions 1. “ER” NBC 30.79 2. “Seinfeld” NBC 30.56 3. “Friends” NBC 24.88 4. “Suddenly Susan” NBC 24.61 5. “The Naked Truth” NBC 24.48 6. “Fired Up” NBC 23.48 “Monday Night Football” ABC 22.38 8. “Home Improvement” ABC 21.68 9. “The Single Guy” NBC 20.89 10. “Touched by an Angel” CBS 20.25 11. “60 Minutes” CBS 18.84 12. “20/20" ABC 18.31 13. “The X-Files” FOX 17.87 14. “NBC Sunday Night Movie” NBC 17.54 15. “CBS Sunday Movie” CBS 17.49 16. “NYPD Blue” ABC 17.43 17. “Spin City” ABC 17.33 18. “The Drew Carey Show” ABC 17.03 19. “3rd Rock From the Sun” NBC 17.01 20. “Walker, Texas Ranger” CBS 16.98
Source: Nielsen Media Research
* MORE TV NEWS
CBS aims to attract younger viewers with its schedule. F2
Rosie O’Donnell captures an Emmy on her first try. F26
Oprah Winfrey easily beats O’Donnell in local ratings. F29