Texas Jury Awards $454.5 Million in CompUSA Case
A jury ordered Mexican billionaire Carlos Slim Helu and four co-defendants to pay $454.5 million in damages to a Dallas company Thursday, saying they conspired to derail the company’s plans to open CompUSA Inc. stores in Mexico.
The company, COC Services Ltd., said its exclusive agreement to open the stores hinged on finding an investor.
Slim expressed interest in helping them finance the deal. But, COC’s owners testified that Slim and his associates halted talks after gaining insider information about CompUSA, which Slim bought a few months later for $800 million.
COC sued Slim, CompUSA, former CompUSA Chief Executive Jim Halpin and two companies controlled by Slim.
The state jury awarded $90 million in actual damages for lost profit and $364.5 million in punitive damages.
Halpin bore the brunt of the jury’s decision. The jury said he should pay $234 million, CompUSA should pay $94.5 million and Slim should pay $90 million. The remaining $36 million will be paid by Slim’s two companies.
“The message sent by the verdict is that in this global economy, companies need to abide by United States rules if they come here,” said Mark Werbner, attorney for COC. “You are not allowed to interfere with contractual rights of others.”
Neither Slim nor Halpin was in the courtroom for the verdict, which was reached on the third day of deliberations after a three-week trial. A spokesman in Mexico City for Slim, whose family-run financial empire includes control over Telmex, the Mexican phone company, said he had no comment on the verdict.
Defense lawyers said they were considering asking for a new trial.
The defendants said COC never had a final deal to operate CompUSA stores in Mexico, only unsigned letters of intent to negotiate if COC ever found a partner.
Slim, one of his sons and a son-in-law all testified that the COC proposal didn’t make business sense. Slim testified it was a “risky business” because of the lack of a large, affluent middle class that could afford computers.
Last year, Forbes magazine ranked Slim the wealthiest man in Latin America, pegging his personal fortune at $7.9 billion.
