It's a Rebuilding Year for Franchise

Times Staff Writers

Producer Elie Samaha's troubled Franchise Pictures has found someone to do its heavy lifting.

In the last few weeks, Southern California construction magnate Ronald Tutor and a business partner who specializes in salvaging "litigation-distressed" companies have quietly acquired just under 50% of the Warner Bros.-affiliated production firm, according to Tutor and others involved in the deal.

Tutor is president of Sylmar-based Tutor-Saliba Corp., the largest contractor on Metro Rail and other massive public works projects in California.

In an unusual arrangement, Tutor and co-investor David Bergstein, a Los Angeles businessman who scouts for companies with legal problems, are leading a five-investor group that ultimately will pay what they called a "substantial seven-figure" sum for their equity stake in Franchise. The investment, they said, will cover not only Franchise's overhead costs but also its heavy legal fees.

Franchise -- home to such costly megaflops as "Battlefield Earth" and "3000 Miles to Graceland" -- has been embroiled in a legal fight with its former partner, German financier Intertainment.

The German company accused Franchise of defrauding it of at least $100 million through false accounting and other transgressions. Franchise fired back with counter-claims in the federal court case, which is scheduled for trial Aug. 5.

Asked about the litigation and published reports that Samaha was the subject of an FBI investigation of possible fraud, Tutor said he had examined Franchise's finances for six months and concluded that the company faces only "minimal" liabilities.

"Elie did nothing wrong," said Tutor, who then quickly added: "Let me put that in the context of Hollywood. Elie did nothing wrong in terms of Hollywood, where everything goes."

According to Bergstein, the investors made a "fixed-fee deal" with powerhouse entertainment law firm Quinn Emanuel Urquhart Oliver & Hedges to defend Franchise. Bergstein declined to give the amount of the legal fee or of his group's investment.

Bergstein said he has previously invested with Tutor, whom he met in connection with earlier corporate salvage efforts. "He's had a lot of litigation. He's a specialist of sorts," Bergstein said of the construction executive.

In one high-profile civil action, Tutor-Saliba was found guilty of defrauding the Metropolitan Transportation Authority in connection with the giant Metro Rail project. The company was ordered to pay $29.5 million in damages and an additional $22 million in legal fees. Among other things, the construction firm was accused of using minority businesses as fronts, submitting false claims and more than 1,000 instances of unfair business practices. An appeal is pending.

In November, the San Francisco city attorney's office filed suit against Tutor-Saliba alleging a complex pattern of fraud and inflated billings in connection with the expansion of San Francisco International Airport. The firm, which posted $642 million in revenue for its fiscal year ended Sept. 30, has denied wrongdoing.

Tutor said he met Samaha through a mutual friend and has been discussing their arrangement for several months. The construction mogul added that he expected to find "synergies" between Franchise and, a troubled Internet disc distributor in which he and Bergstein are investors.

"We really see the opportunity for substantial success," Tutor said.

For Samaha, the bailout cuts the bleeding from legal fees, which already had exceeded $7.5 million, according to Bergstein. It also enables Samaha to continue taking advantage of a four-year movie distribution deal with AOL Time Warner Inc.'s Warner Bros. studio.

"I'm going to concentrate on what I do best, which is making movies," Samaha said in an interview Tuesday.

Of the reported FBI inquiry, Samaha added: "If there was anything there, they'd have done something by now."

The producer's new partners won't directly finance Franchise's movies. They said Samaha has about $300 million in production funding available from various sources, including his lead lender, Comerica Bank.

Los Angeles garment industry tycoon Gerard Guez is one of Samaha's longtime backers. Bergstein said Guez has 30 days under his deal with Franchise to exercise an option that would let him acquire as much as 25% of the company.

Guez didn't return calls.

Under the producer's arrangement with Warner Bros., the studio is obligated to release Franchise's movies in U.S. theaters as long as they have production budgets higher than $20 million and carry an R rating or less. Warner advances the cost of prints and advertising and receives a distribution fee of about 15% of revenue.

Warner Bros. executives, pained by the embarrassment of earlier Samaha releases such as "Get Carter" -- a Sylvester Stallone action film that took in $15 million at the U.S. box office in 2000 -- have been working with Franchise to improve the caliber of its films.

"What we're trying to do is help him creatively migrate over to the best quality movies possible," Warner Bros. President Alan Horn said of Samaha.

Horn helped steer his former business partner, director Rob Reiner, to Franchise last year. The producer is financing Reiner's romantic comedy, tentatively titled "Loosely Based on a True Love Story," starring Kate Hudson and Luke Wilson. The studio contributed more than 20% of the film's $30-million budget and will release it this fall.

William Morris Agency President Jim Wiatt, who represents Reiner and others who have worked on Samaha's movies, said the producer has proven reliable, notwithstanding the litigation. "We've done a lot of business with Elie and Franchise Pictures, and we've not had a problem.... He's lived up to his financial obligations," Wiatt said.

Samaha owned an L.A. dry cleaning chain before getting into the film business. He became known in the last few years for indulging stars such as Stallone, John Travolta and Kevin Costner by financing their pet projects, often in return for a price break on fees.

The producer frequently has hosted stars and entertainment industry players at his various nightclubs, including the popular Sunset Room on the Sunset Strip. Tutor and Bergstein denied Hollywood gossip that Samaha might help them enter the club or restaurant business.

Tutor said Bergstein would be the group's point person in dealing with Samaha: "For me, it's an arm's-length, passive form of investment. I have enough to do with the construction business."



Digging out of a hole?

With a weak track record, producer Elie Samaha is getting help from an unlikely source: Southern California construction magnate Ronald Tutor. Here is a look at film releases produced by Samaha's Franchise Pictures in the last three years, with their domestic grosses, and some projects in the works:



Title: "City by the Sea"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: $22.5 million

Title: "Half Past Dead"

U.S. distributor: Columbia

Domestic gross: 15.3 million

Title: "Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 14.3 million

Title: "feardotcom"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 13.2 million

Title: "Femme Fatale"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 6.6 million



Title: "driven"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: $32.7 million

Title: "Angel Eyes"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 24.2 million

Title: "The Pledge"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 19.7 million

Title: "3000 Miles to Graceland"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 15.7 million

Title: "The Caveman's Valentine"

U.S. distributor: Universal

Domestic gross: 687,081



Title: "The Whole Nine Yards"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: $57.3 million

Title: "The Art of War"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 30.2 million

Title: "Battlefield Earth"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 21.5 million

Title: "Get Carter"

U.S. distributor: Warner Bros.

Domestic gross: 15 million


Upcoming 2003 releases:

"The Foreigner" -- Jan. 28. An action-adventure starring Steven Segal. Direct-to-video release through Columbia TriStar Home Video.

"Hairy Tale" (tentative title) -- May 16. A family comedy-adventure directed by Gene Quintano and starring Matthew Modine about a boy genius who helps a martial arts whiz and his chimp outwit those running a devious animal laboratory in exchange for advice on how to play football and win the affections of his dream girl.

"The Wedding Party" -- May 23. A comedy directed by Andy Fleming and starring Michael Douglas, Albert Brooks, Candice Bergen, Robin Tunney and Ryan Reynolds about a daredevil secret agent and irreverent father of the groom who gives an uptight podiatrist father of the bride the jitters when they meet before the wedding.

"Loosely Based on a True Love Story" (tentative title) -- Sept. 12. A romantic comedy directed by Rob Reiner and starring Luke Wilson, Kate Hudson and Sophie Marceau about an author indebted to a loan shark who has 30 days to finish a novel or be killed.

"The Whole Ten Yards" -- Oct. 17. Sequel to the comedy hit "The Whole Nine Yards," starring Bruce Willis as a retired hit man who must rescue his former neighbor (Matthew Perry) and his wife from a jam with the Hungarian Mafia.


Sources: Warner Bros., Times research


Anita M. Busch contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2019, Los Angeles Times
EDITION: California | U.S. & World