High heels are the worst, and women are ditching them

British Prime Minister Theresa May wears flat shoes as she delivers a speech in February.
(Christopher Furlong / AFP / Getty Images)

Amanda Powers hasn’t worn high heels in years — not to work, not to parties, not even to her own wedding.

“They’re not comfortable,” she said. “They’re not fun to wear. Not to mention, I walk fast and they slow me down.”

Around the country, women are trading in their high-heeled stilettos for sneakers and ballet flats. Workplaces are becoming more casual, and it is increasingly acceptable to wear sneakers to dinner. But analysts say there are other changes afoot too: More Americans are working from home, and even among those who do go into the office, fitness trackers such as Fitbit have made people more aware of how much they are — or should be — moving.


“Even after we get to work, we’re trying not to sit at our desks all day,” said Katie Smith, director of retail analysis at Edited. “We stand. We take the stairs. We walk to lunch. We’re constantly counting our steps, so it makes sense to wear comfortable footwear and clothing.”

Sales of high heels dropped 12% last year, while sales of women’s sneakers rose 37% to $2.3 billion, according to the NPD Group’s retail tracking service.

The sales decline wasn’t for lack of options: High heel inventory rose 28% from the year before, according to Edited, a New York-based market research firm. And the sagging sales didn’t have much to do with price: About one-third of high heels had been discounted by an average of 47%.

“This is not a burn-your-heels moment — the majority of women still have heels in their wardrobes,” Smith said. “But there isn’t an expectation anymore that if I go to a party, I have to put on my spiky heels, stand for two hours and then want to die. Social mores are changing.”

It doesn’t hurt that flats — which are popping up on runways and the red carpet — are having a pop culture moment, either. Marc Jacobs’ latest fashion show featured models in silk lace-up brogues and crystal-embellished ballet flats, while actress Gal Gadot wore gladiator sandals to the “Wonder Woman” premiere. Even First Lady Melania Trump, known for her love of high-end high heels by Christian Louboutin and Manolo Blahnik, traded in her stilettos for a pair of white sneakers last year for a trip to Texas after Hurricane Harvey.

Tech giants are also taking note: A ballet-flat emoji is slated to make its debut this year.


“Across the board, there’s an increasing casualization of every occasion, including at work,” Smith said. “We’re dressing in jeans and sneakers. We’re dressing for comfort and function.”

Recent surveys show that women are buying more athletic shoes and sandals than they are dress shoes or fashion boots, according to market research firm Mintel. Nearly half of those surveyed said they are willing to pay more for shoes that are comfortable.

High heel makers, many of which had their heyday in the “Sex and the City” era of the early 2000s, have weathered a wave of consolidation in recent years. Michael Kors last year paid $1.2 billion to buy Jimmy Choo, the upscale shoe company. Two years earlier, Coach bought Stuart Weitzman for $574 million.

“People are multitasking more these days — they’re going from yoga class to work, then from happy hour to pick up their kids, and they don’t want to change into four different outfits,” said Alexis DeSalva, retail and apparel analyst at Mintel. “Flat shoes have become a staple in multipurpose dressing.”

Nike last week announced a new retail concept, called Unlaced, that will specialize exclusively in women’s sneakers. The company also is expanding its lineup of women’s sizes, and earlier this year released its first collection of sneakers designed entirely by a team of 14 women. There are also signs that Crocs, Tevas, Uggs and Birkenstocks — all known for being comfortable, if less than attractive — are making a comeback.

As for Powers, the marketing director in Los Angeles, she now has just one pair of heels — “very modest” black pumps — left in her closet. She’s given away the rest and stocked up on the shoes she actually likes to wear: a dozen pairs of sneakers and at least 25 pairs of flats.

“I am never going back,” she said. “As soon as I stopped wearing high heels, it was a taste of sweet freedom.”