23 governors join California in opposing Trump gas mileage standards

Vehicles travel west on Interstate 80 across the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge in 2015.
(Ben Margot / Associated Press)
Share via

Citing climate-damaging tailpipe emissions, 23 U.S. governors signed a pledge Tuesday backing California leaders in their showdown with the Trump administration over its plans to relax vehicle mileage standards.

The pledge by leaders of states and Puerto Rico, most of them Democrats, comes as the administration moves to block tougher mileage standards laid out by then-President Obama as part of his efforts against climate change. Legal challenges to Trump’s policy proposal threaten to disrupt the auto industry for years, and an influential auto industry trade group is renewing its appeal for a compromise.

The Trump administration says American consumers increasingly want bigger, less-efficient SUVs and pickup trucks. It also argues that demanding ever more fuel-efficient vehicles will drive up automobile costs and keep less-safe, older vehicles on the road longer; opponents challenge that claim.


The administration is expected to release its final rules on the mileage changes in late summer or early fall. California and other states have promised litigation to block them.

The governors’ pledge commits to sticking broadly to the pre-Trump mileage goals, a program of annual tightening in mileage standards that reduce climate-changing carbon emissions. Transportation and the power sector are the biggest sources of heat-trapping fossil fuel pollution in the United States.

Environmental Protection Agency spokesman Michael Abboud said the administration was “pursuing one national standard to provide safe, affordable vehicles for consumers while also improving environmental outcomes.”

At stake is California’s ability to set its own emissions and fuel economy standards, a power granted by Congress in the Clean Air Act to fight the state’s smog problems in the 1970s. California once had more stringent standards than federal ones, but the two sides voluntarily synced their standards under Obama.

The Trump administration has threatened to challenge California’s authority to set its own mileage standards, which are followed by about a dozen states.

The pledge says governors “will not compromise on our responsibility to protect the health of our communities, our climate, and the savings consumers stand to gain at the pump.” It promises “additional concrete actions to fulfill this duty and defend against any threats.”


Besides California and Puerto Rico, the pledge was signed by the leaders of Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.

The commitment from the states — representing a sizable share of the U.S. car market — underscores prospects for years of legal challenges and regulatory uncertainty for automakers if the Trump administration moves ahead on the mileage freeze.

Sen. Tom Carper of Delaware, the top Democrat on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, urged automakers to get behind the states in the interests of cutting carbon emissions and advancing cleaner-burning vehicles.

“Since the Trump administration seems determined to put all environmental progress into reverse, automakers should make clear that they will not support this rollback by working directly with California and these 23 states to drive automobile technology into the future,” Carper said in a statement.

But an auto industry group made clear it had worries about both sides’ positions in the dispute.

“It is untenable to face a marketplace with different standards in different states, but it also untenable to face standards that rise so high that only a handful of electric vehicles can achieve them,” said Gloria Bergquist, spokeswoman for the Washington-based Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers. “That is why automakers keep urging the federal government and states to find a middle ground that raises standards year over year while aligning with market demand.”


President Trump has pushed automakers to support him in his bid to relax mileage standards. Last month, major automakers instead appealed for the administration to return to talks with California.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom indicated he wasn’t optimistic about any breakthroughs with the administration.

“I don’t sense they’re sincere in their commitment to sit down and negotiate,” he said, and cited the administration’s overall backing for the country’s oil and gas industry.