U.S. charges 4 members of Chinese military in Equifax breach

Atty. Gen. William Barr with FBI Deputy Director David Bowdich
Atty. Gen. William Barr speaks to reporters Monday at the Justice Department in Washington. FBI Deputy Director David Bowdich stands behind him.
(Michael Reynolds / EPA / Shutterstock)
Share via

Four members of the Chinese military have been charged with breaking into the computer networks of the credit reporting firm Equifax Inc. and stealing the personal information of roughly 145 million Americans, the Justice Department said Monday, blaming Beijing for one of the largest hacks in history to target consumer data.

The hackers in the 2017 breach collected names, addresses, Social Security and driver’s license numbers and other information stored in Equifax’s databases. The intrusion damaged the company’s reputation and underscored China’s increasingly aggressive and sophisticated intelligence-gathering methods.

“The scale of the theft was staggering,” Atty. Gen. William Barr said Monday in announcing the indictment. “This theft not only caused significant financial damage to Equifax, but invaded the privacy of many millions of Americans, and imposed substantial costs and burdens on them as they have had to take measures to protect against identity theft.”


The case is the latest U.S. accusation against Chinese hackers suspected of breaching networks of American corporations, including steel manufacturers, a hotel chain and a health insurer. It comes as the Trump administration has warned against what it sees as the growing political and economic influence of China, and efforts by Beijing to collect data for financial and intelligence purposes and to steal research and innovation.

Equifax, like most large U.S. companies, failed to encrypt the databases that store some of the most sensitive details of people’s lives.

The indictment arrives at a delicate time in relations between Washington and Beijing. Even as President Trump points to a preliminary trade pact with China as evidence of his ability to work with the Communist government, other members of his administration have been warning against cybersecurity and surveillance risks posed by China, especially as the tech giant Huawei seeks to become part of new high-speed 5G wireless networks around the globe.

Experts and U.S. officials say the Equifax theft is consistent with the Chinese government’s interest in accumulating as much information about Americans as possible.

China could use the data to target U.S. government officials and ordinary citizens, including possible spies, and to find weaknesses and vulnerabilities that can be exploited — such as for purposes of blackmail. The FBI has not seen that happen yet in this case, Deputy Director David Bowdich said, although he added it “doesn’t mean it will or will not happen in the future.”

“We have to be able to recognize that as a counterintelligence issue, not a cyber issue,” said Bill Evanina, the U.S. government’s top counterintelligence official.

The four accused hackers are suspected members of the People’s Liberation Army, an arm of the Chinese military that was blamed in 2014 for a series of intrusions into American corporations.


Prosecutors say the suspects exploited a software vulnerability to gain access to Equifax’s computers, obtaining login credentials that they used to navigate databases and review records. They also took steps to cover their tracks, the indictment says, wiping log files on a daily basis and routing traffic through dozens of servers in nearly 20 countries.

In addition to stealing personal information, the hackers also made off with some of the company’s sensitive trade secrets, including database designs, law enforcement officials said.

Atty. Gen. William Barr shows photos of the suspects
Atty. Gen. William Barr shows photos of the people indicted in the Equifax hack.
(Sarah Silbiger / Getty Images)

Atlanta-based Equifax maintains a massive repository of consumer information that it sells to businesses looking to verify people’s identities or assess their creditworthiness. All told, the indictment says, the company holds information on hundreds of millions of people in America and abroad.

The accused hackers are based in China, and none is in custody. But U.S. officials hope criminal charges can be a deterrent to foreign hackers and a warning to other countries that American law enforcement has the capability to pinpoint individual culprits. Still, China and the U.S. committed in 2015 to halt acts of cyber espionage against each other, but the Equifax intrusion and others like it make clear that Beijing has continued its operations.

A representative for the Chinese Embassy in Washington did not return an email seeking comment Monday.


The case resembles a 2014 indictment by the Obama administration Justice Department that accused five members of the PLA of hacking into American corporations to steal trade secrets. U.S. authorities also suspect China in the massive 2015 breach of the federal Office of Personnel Management and of intrusions into the Marriott hotel chain and health insurer Anthem Inc.

Such hacks “seem to deliberately cast a wide net” so that Chinese intelligence analysts can get deep insight into the lives of many Americans, said Ben Buchanan, a Georgetown University scholar and author of the upcoming book “The Hacker and the State.”

“This could be especially useful for counterintelligence purposes, like tracking American spies posted to Beijing,” Buchanan said.

Barr, who at an event last week warned of Beijing’s aspirations of economic dominance, said Monday that the U.S. has for years “witnessed China’s voracious appetite for the personal data of Americans.”

“This kind of attack on American industry is of a piece with other Chinese illegal acquisitions of sensitive personal data,” Barr said.

The criminal charges announced Monday, which include conspiracy to commit computer fraud and conspiracy to commit economic espionage, were filed in federal court in Atlanta.


Equifax last year reached a $700-million settlement over the data breach, with the bulk of the funds intended for affected consumers.

Equifax officials told the Government Accountability Office that the company made many mistakes, including having an outdated list of computer systems administrators. The company didn’t notice the intruders targeting its databases for more than six weeks. Hackers exploited a known security vulnerability that Equifax hadn’t fixed.

Although Equifax’s stock price has recovered, its reputation has not fully. The company was dragged in front of Congress no fewer than four times to publicly explain what happened.

The company is about to start paying out claims on its $700-million settlement, of which more claimants have opted in to getting a cash settlement than accept credit counseling. So many claims have been made for the cash, that the Federal Trade Commission and the lawyers suing Equifax have warned claimants that the chances of getting the full cash value of the settlement was unlikely.