Where’s the great American pay raise? New numbers cast doubt
U.S. weekly wages fell in 2022, according to new Bureau of Labor Statistics figures, revealing widespread softness that wasn’t previously evident in other data.
Average weekly wages were $1,385 in the fourth quarter of last year, a rare 2.3% decline from the same period in 2021, the latest results from the Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, published Wednesday, showed. The drop in 2022 followed a 5.9% increase the year before.
The QCEW figures differ from other government measures of wages in that they include things such as bonuses, stock options and severance pay. They’re also used to revise more timely, high-frequency measures such as those included in the monthly jobs report published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Last year’s drop probably reflects smaller incentive pay amid a softening in hiring trends, said Ron Hetrick, an economist at Lightcast. In 2021, companies in all kinds of industries were offering unusual perks to attract workers as they scrambled to staff up again when the economy reopened after COVID lockdowns.
“Employers have pulled back on the bonuses that they’re offering as the labor market has cooled,” Hetrick said. “That includes everything from hiring bonuses to retention bonuses to inflation bonuses.”
California workers from fast food to school staff are demanding better wages and benefits through legislation backed by unions.
The QCEW measure provides a different perspective on the state of the labor market than the average weekly earnings figures published in the monthly jobs report, which showed a 4.2% increase in 2022. The differences in the types of compensation included in each mean the two are not directly comparable.
The QCEW data also played a role in the weak figures on gross domestic income published Thursday, with wages and salaries “now estimated to have increased $53.0 billion in the fourth quarter, a downward revision of $135.4 billion,” the Bureau of Economic Analysis said.
Wage decreases were relatively widespread across the U.S., according to the QCEW data, with 240 of the largest 355 counties seeing declines.
The report also contained several clues that a shift in the composition of the workforce — with higher-paying industries shedding jobs while hiring in lower-paying industries remained robust — helped put downward pressure on overall wages.
San Francisco, for example, registered a 22.6% drop in average weekly wages, the biggest decline among the 355 largest counties, as professional and business services wages fell 24.9%. New York County saw wages fall 9.4%, with a 14.9% pay decline in finance. Weekly wages in Los Angeles dropped 3.5%.
Proposed legislation would require employers who lay off more than 50 workers at a time to provide employees with 90 days notice. It would also prohibit employers from pressuring workers to sign away their rights in exchange for severance pay.
“We are seeing that demand for workers is slowing down in tech and in other white-collar sectors, while it still remains a hot labor market for some of these other industries like food services and healthcare,” said Daniel Zhao, an economist at Glassdoor.
One bright spot was Midland, Texas, which saw average weekly wages rise 6.1%, the biggest increase among the 355 largest counties. The natural resources and mining sector in Midland registered a 3.3% wage increase.
A surge in oil prices in 2022 spurred increased drilling activity in and around Midland, which sits atop the country’s largest oil basin. Energy companies have scrambled to find workers, boosting pay and helping drive down the area’s unemployment rate.
The QCEW data also included new information on employment. It showed a 2.6% increase in head count across the country in 2022, about half a percentage point lower than the employment growth registered in monthly jobs reports.
Gains were concentrated in the South, with Midland seeing the biggest rise in head count, up 7.9%. Other counties in Texas and in Florida rounded out the top five.
Elkhart, Ind. — known as the world’s recreational vehicle manufacturing capital — and Hendricks, Ind., saw the largest decreases in employment, with head count down 1.7% in each county.
Bloomberg writer Catarina Saraiva contributed to this report.
