Review: ‘Still Alice’ powerfully presents a mind falling to Alzheimer’s
Kenneth Turan reviews ‘Still Alice’ Starring: Julianne Moore, Kate Bosworth, Alec Baldwin, and Kristen Stewart. Video by Jason H. Neubert.
Losing your mind is a terrible thing to watch, but the splendid acting in “Still Alice” makes it worth the pain. Scarier than any Elm Street nightmare, a horror film for the rest of us, it succeeds despite itself not because of one strong performance but two.
The accomplished Julianne Moore stars as respected academic Alice Howland, shocked by her diagnosis of early onset Alzheimer’s disease, and the actress’ work as someone coping with the ravages of the unthinkable deserves all the plaudits it’s going to get.
But if it wasn’t for costar Kristen Stewart, who plays Alice’s daughter Lydia, “Still Alice” wouldn’t be nearly as emotionally effective as it is. Moore and Stewart have been off-screen friends for more than a decade, and that bond only enhances the work they do here.
As scripted by the writer-director team of Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland from a novel by Lisa Genova, “Still Alice” does have obstacles to overcome. Elements of its plot have the standard quality of a Hallmark production, and the work of some of the film’s costars is a bit too on the nose. But, with Moore and Stewart on the case, we feel the presence of something real here, something that can’t be shrugged off or ignored.
Alice is introduced at the usual cinematic happy event where no one realizes it’s going to be all downhill from here. It is the 50th birthday celebration for this celebrated Columbia University professor of linguistics, with her loving if a trifle overbearing husband, John (Alec Baldwin), and two of her three adult children (Kate Bosworth, Hunter Parrish) present at a Manhattan restaurant to raise a glass.
Not attending is third daughter Lydia (Stewart), an aspiring actress who lives out in Los Angeles. Alice uses the opportunity of a speaking engagement at UCLA to look in on Lydia and to express, clearly not for the first time, her frustration that this daughter has chosen not to go to college in favor of following her passion.
One pleasure of “Still Alice” at this early stage is the chance it gives us to see Moore playing a happy, well-adjusted woman. The actress is so good at aberrational characters — her unhinged Havana Segrand in David Cronenberg’s forthcoming “Maps to the Stars” is the latest example — that we don’t get enough chances to see her playing normal yet still involving, which is nowhere near as easy as it may sound.
But “Still Alice” is not about staying normal to the last frame. Like viewers of “Titanic” who know that the ship is destined to sink without a trace, we wait for that first indication — it turns out to be a memory lapse at that UCLA talk — of the decline we know is inevitable.
Alice shrugs that one off, but back home in New York things get worse, and when she finds herself disoriented jogging near her home, a visit to a neurologist is unavoidable.
The eventual diagnosis is as shocking as it is incontrovertible, with this being a hereditary condition Alice might have passed on to her children making things only worse. The heart of “Still Alice” is the wrenching business of watching as all the things that define this woman to herself and her family gradually drain away, one by one by one.
Moore is especially good at the wordless elements of this transformation, allowing us to see through the changing contours of her face what it is like when your mind empties out. When Alice says at one point “I feel like I can’t find myself,” it is all the more upsetting because we’ve already watched it happen.
“Still Alice” does have situations that feel contrived and overly familiar, like an all-but-preordained heart-to-heart talk by the ocean, which is why the film is especially fortunate to have not only Moore but Stewart to keep things honest.
As she demonstrated working with Juliette Binoche in Olivier Assayas’ Cannes favorite “Clouds of Sils Maria,” Stewart is especially good at going toe to toe and holding her own with veteran actresses, and the intensity she brings to the part of a daughter determined to do things her own way is essential here.
Finally, though it doesn’t say so in so many words, “Still Alice” wants you to remember that its title is only one letter off from “Still Alive.” Alice is struggling to be who she once was, and that is a battle we have to respect no matter what.
MPAA rating: PG-13 for mature thematic material and brief language, including a sexual reference.
Running time: 1 hour, 39 minutes
Playing: At Landmark, West Los Angeles, Sundance Sunset, West Hollywood
From the Emmys to the Oscars.
Get our revamped Envelope newsletter, sent twice a week, for exclusive awards season coverage, behind-the-scenes insights and columnist Glenn Whipp’s commentary.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.