As many renowned thespians have observed, no matter what you have done before, those who stay in the acting business long enough will inevitably play a television detective.
Even, as it turns out, Jennifer Lopez.
Last seen as hosting “The American Music Awards” and a judge on “American Idol,” Lopez now stars as the morally compromised yet essentially likable Det. Harlee Santos in “Shades of Blue,” NBC’s new police drama that too often hopes narrative complication will pass for psychological complexity.
Created by Adi Hasak, the series also features Ray Liotta as Harlee’s even more corrupt and compelling boss, Lt. “Woz” Wozniak, as well as a strong ensemble that includes Drea de Matteo (“The Sopranos”) and Vincent Laresca (“Graceland”).
Jennifer Lopez stars as a detective in the new NBC show “Shades of Blue.”(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez, Ray Liotta, second from left, Santino Fontana and Hampton Fluker on the set in Harlem on Aug. 12, 2015.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
“Shades of Blue” bypassed the traditional pilot process and was ordered directly to series by NBC in February 2014.
(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
“I wanted to change my look completely and be like the antithesis of what people are used to seeing me as,” Jennifer Lopez says.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez, with Ray Liotta in Harlem, originally was involved only as a producer. It took some coaxing to get her to take on the role of Harlee Santos.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez, center, speaks to director Dan Lerner and costar Drea DeMatteo on the set of the new NBC show “Shades of Blue,” being filmed in Harlem on Aug. 12, 2015.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Before joining the cast, Ray Liotta, with Lopez, made sure his role was substantive.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Director Dan Lerner, center, watches as a scene of the new NBC show “Shades of Blue” is filmed in Harlem.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Director Dan Lerner on set in Harlem.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Ray Liotta, left, Jennifer Lopez and Hampton Fluker.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Ray Liotta gets makeup.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Residents of Harlem watch as the new NBC show “Shades of Blue” is filmed in their neighborhood.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez stars in the new NBC show “Shades of Blue,” playing a detective.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Drea de Matteo also plays a cop in "Shades of Blue.”(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez and Ray Liotta wait for action cue.(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Jennifer Lopez says “Shades of Blue” on NBC is “a character piece about human nature.”(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)
Not that it matters much. The show’s title may be a play on that groundbreaking ensemble drama “Hill Street Blues,” but “Shades of Blue” is first and foremost a star vehicle. Though Liotta does great work and plays the more multifaceted character, all eyes will be on Lopez, who is in virtually every scene.
A tale of devolution rather than transcendence, “Shades” opens with Harlee explaining, via a video on her laptop, how everything went wrong. “I always told myself the end would justify the means. But now that I’m at the end, I can’t justify anything.”
She’s obviously a mess and, because she is JLo, much will be made of this. Also of how good she looks, for a cop, what with those cheekbones and that luminescent skin, in addition to how the show immediately goes out of the way to show us how tough she is by barking orders and taking to the boxing ring within the first few minutes.
This may be true, but so is the fact that the TV screen is littered with pretty-boy detectives and their cheekbones (aloha “Hawaii Five-Oh,” cheerio “Sherlock”), so let’s try to resist the beauty angle. Plenty of good-looking men play remarkably good-looking cops, and it often takes a few episodes for them to look natural chasing down tough-talking perps or firing off a few rounds.
In fact, with its insistence on that boxing bout followed by some raunchy sex, “Shades of Blue” dispenses with familiar tropes so quickly and efficiently that it almost seems satiric.
It isn’t, of course. As the first minutes make all too clear, “Shades of Blue” takes itself very seriously: Immediately after Harlee’s teary monologue, we see her expertly “fix” a crime scene to cover for a rookie cop who accidentally kills a drug dealer.
The fact that the dead man is a drug dealer is supposed to mitigate the wrongful shooting for the viewer just as it does for Harlee. A show of the new millennium, this “Blue” comes in shades dark and stained with corruption, more influenced by the twisted morality of “The Shield” than the colorful heroism of Hill Street precinct.
Harlee isn’t just criminally loyal to the badge; she’s a cop on the take, part of a team assembled by Woz for this exact purpose. Woz believes that by providing protection, at a price, to the more reasonable criminal elements, he can control crime in his precinct. No drug dealing near schools, no rough stuff on the streets, no back-talk; Woz runs his precinct with the familial loyalty and constant OCD paranoia of every cinematic mobster.
He is particularly devoted to Harlee and her daughter, Cristina (Sarah Jeffery), whose bright future — cello lessons! private school! — Harlee will go to any length to ensure. So when she is caught mid-shakedown by the feds, she has no choice but to turn informant — what would become of Cristina should Harlee go to the slammer?
Real moral ambiguity is tougher to maintain than most TV writers seem to realize. Viewers may be interested in exploring the line between good and bad, but more often than not they are simply looking for characters and/or a story compelling enough to allow them to overlook the inevitable contradictions and sloppy cheats.
Lopez does a decent enough job — on top of the single-mom angle, Harlee also has a traumatic back story — but it’s Liotta who will make or break “Shades of Blue.” He’s been in the business for a while now; it’s about time he played a TV cop, good, bad or otherwise.