3 GOP candidates’ plans would increase debt, study says
President Obama is roundly criticized by Republicans for running up the nation’s debt. But if a Republican takes the White House, the debt will keep climbing — and perhaps even faster than under Obama’s proposed policies, a budget watchdog group said.
GOP presidential hopefuls Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum are touting policies that would push the debt beyond current projections — largely because their proposed tax cuts would outweigh spending cuts. Only Ron Paul’s plans would begin to sharply decrease the debt, according to a report Thursday from the nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.
The analysis shows how difficult it will be for any president to change the trajectory of the debt. And it underscores the need for bipartisan efforts to increase revenue and curb spending, particularly as an aging population is about to drastically drive up Medicare costs, the group said.
“I don’t think cutting revenues further is the responsible thing to do — and they all do it,” said Alice Rivlin, referring to the Republican candidates. Rivlin, the founding director of the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, is a director of the budget watchdog group that released the analysis.
“We’re not going to be able to absorb this tsunami of seniors and their need for healthcare with the revenue we have,” she said.
Obama’s proposals also would push debt above what budget experts say is sustainable.
The nation’s debt load is typically measured as a portion of the economy, or gross domestic product — with 60% being an internationally accepted level of debt. The United States’ so-called public debt, which excludes transfers among government accounts, is about 70% of GDP.
Under Obama, the public debt is expected to rise over the decade, to 80% of GDP, according to an earlier analysis by the group. It based its projection on his proposals, including ending the George W. Bush-era tax breaks for those earning beyond $250,000 a year.
For its analysis of the GOP candidates, the group compared campaign proposals to existing policies, and those it assumes will occur, including the continuation of the Bush-era tax cuts. Under that baseline, the group said, the debt would reach 85% of GDP by 2021.
Gingrich has noted that the federal budget was balanced when he was House speaker. But the budget group said the policies he’s promoting now, including spending on space exploration, would increase the national debt by an additional $7 trillion over the baseline over the next decade to 114% of GDP. Santorum’s policies would drive up the debt by an additional $4.5 trillion, to 104%.
Romney’s proposals would increase public debt to between 85% and 96% of GDP, depending on the level of new revenue his proposals could generate in addition to the new tax policies he announced this week, the budget watchdogs said.
Only the proposals from Paul, the libertarian Texas congressman, would reduce the debt from current projected levels, by $2.2 trillion, to 76% of GDP.
The budget group didn’t take into consideration the Republicans’ proposals to slow Medicare costs, because the effect of those changes would be at least a decade away.
The group also dismissed GOP assertions that tax cuts would pay for themselves by spurring economic growth.
The deficit is projected to be $1.1 trillion this year.