Northern California rains another roadblock as area tries to recover from deadly Camp fire

Recovery teams sift through the ashes looking for remains in the debris of a home in Paradise, Calif., during last week's rain.
(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Times)

Forty miles from Paradise, where dozens of people displaced by the Camp fire in Northern California have found refuge in a Corning hotel, 54-year-old Bill Krulder sat in the lobby Tuesday with his back to the window.

Outside, a steady, light rain pelted the ground.

“It’s a little too late,” he said.

“Way too late,” Joe Sievers, 67, added.

Residents in this Central Valley community have come to expect rainstorms in October, just as the leaves of the bountiful trees explode in deep burgundy, yellow and orange. They wondered out loud whether the rain showers, if they had arrived on time, would have prevented the deadliest fire in modern California history from ripping through Paradise.

Now that the damage is done, they said, the rain is adding another roadblock in their quest to return to some sense of normality.


The first of three storm systems expected in the area dropped a smattering of rain Tuesday. Forecasters predicted about an inch of precipitation, saying the relatively weak system would sputter out by early Wednesday.

But a stronger storm will roll in late Wednesday, bringing with it the potential for debris flows and up to 3 inches of rain through Thursday night.

The Butte County Emergency Operations Center has prepared for the rain by clearing drainage culverts of debris, said Matt Gates, public information officer for the Paradise Police Department.

The California Conservation Corps also has been working on erosion-control measures for mountain slopes filled with fire-damaged pine and chaparral.

“Ash doesn’t absorb water, which complicates things,” Gates said.

A third storm could bring 2½ to 4 inches of rain to the charred region from Friday through Sunday.

“It’s the intensity that can cause debris flows,” said Eric Kurth, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service. “If the rain comes over time, there’s some opportunity for it to absorb or gradually run off. When we have rapid runoff, that’s when it can bring down entire hillsides.”

The soil in recently burned areas cannot absorb significant amounts of rainwater, so excessive precipitation can lead to fast-moving flows containing mud, debris and even trees and boulders. The devastation can be deadly and often comes without warning.

The rain is also expected to complicate the already challenging search for human remains among the rubble of the Camp fire.

Typically, crews scoop fire debris into a screen and sift it, looking for bone or bone fragments, but the ash and rain have mixed to form a clay-like substance, making the task nearly impossible. Officials have had to bring in water and gently wash away the clay to expose potential human remains in the charred mess.

Authorities are slowly narrowing the list of the missing, which on Monday stood at 203, down from nearly 1,000 last week. Officials have found the remains of 88 people.

Amid a backdrop of charred pine trees, search and rescue teams from Butte County sift through the burned Ridgewood mobile home park in Paradise, Calif., on Nov. 25/
(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Times)

Rain is also expected to affect the burn areas in Southern California. Chilly and wet conditions are forecast beginning late Wednesday and continuing through Thursday night.

The system will bring half an inch to 2 inches of rain to Los Angeles and Ventura counties, with temperatures dropping into the low 60s during the day and into the 50s at night. Light showers could linger around the Grapevine into Friday, said Bonnie Bartling, a weather specialist with the National Weather Service in Oxnard.

Debris flows in areas charred by the Woolsey and Hill fires are unlikely based on the current rainfall forecast. Predicted rates look to be below the U.S. Geological Survey’s threshold of half an inch of rain per hour that could trigger mudslide danger, Bartling said.

“They’d have to get a half-inch or more in a very short period of time,” she said. “We’ll continue to monitor it to see if anything materializes.”

But the city of Malibu was still cautioning residents to prepare for weather problems, including potential flooding. Free sandbags are being offered at fire stations on Carbon Canyon Road, Malibu Road, Decker Road and the Pacific Coast Highway.

The storm is also bringing a high surf advisory from Wednesday through at least Thursday night: Waves in Los Angeles, Santa Barbara and Ventura counties will range from 6 to 12 feet. Surf in Orange County will be 5 to 8 feet, and San Diego County is expected to see waves up to 12 feet by Thursday.

The charred hills of Calabasas are seen through a burned-out structure after the Woolsey fire.
(Carolyn Cole / Los Angeles Times)

In Corning, Krulder said the rain, which helped in last week’s containment of the wildfire, is now keeping him from returning to what’s left of his home.

He had a hazy picture of his mobile home, with smoke rising from nearby debris. The house is still standing — most in his mobile community aren’t — but it looks damaged. He’s worried rainwater will turn the ash into sludge and make it difficult to comb through the wreckage.

“It’s stopping us from going up there,” Krulder said. “It’s delaying … FEMA going up there. Right now, it’s a waiting game for everybody.”

Over the last few weeks, Krulder and Sievers have made the Best Western hotel home. The two men didn’t know each other before the fire, though they lived in the same small town for years and frequented the same haunts.

They didn’t know 53-year-old Valarie Susnow of Magalia or 56-year-old Brian Boyd of Paradise, who joined them in a lobby Tuesday.

But since the Camp fire, they have formed a little community around the waffle maker during breakfast, passing one another in the elevator and lounging in the lobby, where Krulder and Sievers said in unison that they sit to “worry.”

Around the table, they trade escape stories of dodging embers and feelings of guilt. Together, they try to make sense of the tragedy that unites them.

Sievers said in the 41 years he lived in Paradise, he had turned his home into an oasis in the mountains. He created a mechanic’s shop where he fixed Subarus and sold them at cost to people living on little.

“They call me ‘Subaru Joe,’ ” he said with a chuckle.

He had rows of crops and fruit trees in his backyard.

Two years ago, plentiful rains helped him yield 300 pounds of cherries, most of which he donated. This year, dry conditions and a late rain washed away the blossoms and he grew only 50 pounds.

The fire took it all: his house, the cars he was fixing up, his harvest.

“Every square inch of that place had my fingerprints on it,” he said.

Sitting in the plush lobby chair, Sievers choked back emotion while describing his former life. He said he hasn’t allowed himself to break down.

He’s thankful for the rain, finally coming to purify the air. And he’s grateful for the respite it will give him in trying to sift through the life he lost.

Times staff writers Rong-Gong Lin II, Cindy Chang and Matt Hamilton contributed to this report.

Twitter: @AngelJennings

Twitter: @Hannahnfry


3:19 p.m.: This article was updated with comments from Camp fire evacuees and rain preparations in Northern and Southern California.

This article was originally published at 11:20 a.m.