Justice Sotomayor laments perception of judges as political

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, center, answers questions from the audience during a speech at UC Berkeley.
(Associated Press)

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor said Thursday that she was saddened to see many people have lost confidence in judges and believe they are political.

Sotomayor made the comments while taking questions from law students at UC Berkeley. The school’s interim law school dean, Melissa Murray, served as Sotomayor’s clerk when the justice was a federal appellate court judge.

Judges try to be fair and impartial and don’t have rigid beliefs they apply to every case, Sotomayor said. She encouraged people to view judges as “human beings who care deeply about what we’re doing.”

“So don’t give up hope on us, OK?” she asked the audience.


Sotomayor did not mention President Trump’s nominee to the court, Neil Gorsuch, whose confirmation hearing is scheduled to start later this month. And her comments lamenting the perception of judges made no reference to the president’s attacks on the judiciary.

Sotomayor, who walked around the auditorium shaking hands and hugging students as she spoke, was nominated by President Obama in 2009 and became the court’s first Latino justice when the U.S. Senate confirmed her later that year.

She was asked what it was like to have only eight justices on the court since Justice Antonin Scalia’s death last year. Gorsuch would fill Scalia’s seat.

“We are talking more,” she said of the remaining justices. “We are trying to reach consensus more.”


She also said she initially found herself asking more questions when attorneys were making their arguments, though she has since pulled back.

“I was filling the dead space during the arguments,” she said. “With [Scalia] around, he usually was the first one to jump in and ask a question.”