Arizona teachers vote for statewide walkout

A parent of a Paseo Elementary student shouts at teacher Tammy Custis outside the school in Peoria, Ariz., on Wednesday.
(Matt York / Associated Press)

Arizona teachers have voted to walk off the job to demand increased school funding, marking a key step toward a first-ever statewide strike that builds on a movement for higher pay in other Republican-dominant states.

A grassroots group and the state’s largest teacher membership group said Thursday that teachers will walk out April 26.

Arizona jumped into a movement for higher teacher pay that started in West Virginia, where a strike garnered a raise, and spread to Oklahoma, Kentucky and most recently Colorado.


Thursday’s vote followed weeks of protests in Arizona and an offer from Republican Gov. Doug Ducey to give teachers a 20% raise by 2020. Many teachers kept up the pressure at schools and on social media, saying the plan failed to address much-needed funding for classrooms and support staff.

“The worst possible thing we could do is not take action right now,” said Noah Karvelis, an organizer for Arizona Educators United.

The historic vote was announced at a press conference at the Arizona Education Assn. headquarters. Around 78% of the 57,000 teachers voted in favor of the walkout, according to the group’s president, Joe Thomas.

“This is undeniably, clearly, a mandate for action,” Thomas said.

Arizona House Democratic Leader Rebecca Rios said in a statement that she supported the planned teacher walkout.

“The women and men who work so hard to educate our children at our neighborhood public schools have earned a meaningful and sustainable pay increase that’s based on a real revenue source, not smoke and mirrors,” Rios said. “We call on superintendents and school boards to support their teachers and support staff during this time.”

The governor said “no one wants to see teachers strike” and reiterated his proposal on Twitter after the vote was announced.


“We have worked side by side with the education community to develop a sustainable plan to give teachers a 20% raise by 2020,” Ducey wrote.

Thomas said the governor’s plan was “falling apart as we speak,” and added that two letters asking the governor to sit down with educators have gone unanswered.

Ducey’s proposal drew support from the business community and some school organizations, but others were concerned about finding the money. The plan would cost about $650 million when fully implemented.

The Arizona PTA pulled its support for the proposal, saying its analysis showed the finances were not realistic. An education advocacy group, Save Our Schools Arizona, said it’s worried the plan isn’t a “sustainable or comprehensive” way to reinvest in schools.

Legislative budget analysts this week predicted a $265 million deficit in 2020 if the governor’s plan is approved. Ducey’s office strongly disputes that analysis, saying much of the funding comes from revenue increases.


Teachers on both sides of the walkout vote have shared concerns. It could pose child care difficulties for thousands of families and leave teachers at risk of losing their credentials. How a strike could play out in more than 200 public school districts will vary but could leave hourly workers like custodians without their paychecks.

Beth Simek, president of the influential Arizona PTA, she feels the pain of teachers who are torn. Some are concerned about the effect on support staff and what kids might do without school, she said.

“I know they’re toiling with that,” Simek said. “I also know they need these raises.”

Parents and communities already have been making plans for child care, with some stay-at-home parents stepping up to watch children so other parents can work, she said. Local parent-teacher associations also are putting together food boxes for kids who rely on free breakfast and lunch at school.

“There’s been a lot of mobilization by the community to prepare,” Simek said.

Teachers themselves could face consequences in this right-to-work state, where unions do not collectively bargain with school districts and representation is not mandatory. The Arizona Education Assn. has warned its 20,000 members about a 1971 Arizona attorney general opinion saying a statewide strike would be illegal under common law and participants could lose their teaching credentials.

The logistics of a walkout will vary by district. The state’s largest, Mesa Public Schools in suburban Phoenix, would close and hourly staffers would not be paid, Supt. Michael Cowan has said.

The Dysart School District west of Phoenix would “make every effort” to avoid closing schools,” but they would have to shut down if too few staff members show up, Supt. Gail Pletnick has told parents.


Sara Bresnahan, a spokeswoman for the Phoenix Elementary School District, said a walkout is “uncharted territory” but its schools would try to stay open for as many students as possible.

“Some kids will be coming to school and really need a place to be,” she said.

Karvelis wouldn’t say how long the walkouts could last.

“I don’t want to put any limitations on it right now,” Karvelis said.

Nancy Maglio, a teacher at Magee Middle School in southern Arizona’s Tucson Unified School District, said teachers are motivated to walk out and demand funding because of what it means for their students.

“None of us went to school, none of us spent money on tuition, on books, none of us spend our time and our energy to not care,” she said. “We went into a field where caring is mandatory.”

While Maglio voted in support of the walkout, it wasn’t without conflicted feelings.

“I am eagerly anticipating the walkout, but I’m not eagerly anticipating leaving my students,” she said.