Op-Ed: Germanwings crash: No algorithm can stop a pilot bent on killing himself
French emergency rescue services work among debris of the Germanwings passenger jet at the crash site near Seyne-les-Alpes, France.
(Yves Malenfer / Associated Press)French emergency rescue services work among debris of the Germanwings passenger jet at the crash site near Seyne-les-Alpes, France.
(Yves Malenfer / Associated Press)A photo from the French Aviation Authority BEA shows a box containing the flight data recorder from the Germanwings A320 airplane that crashed in the French Alps on March 24.
(BEA / EPA)French gendarmes get ready to go to the crash site of the German Airbus A320 of carrier Germanwings as part of the search operations in Seyne-les-Alpes.
(Pascal Guyot / AFP/Getty Images)French emergency rescue services work among debris of the Germanwings passenger jet at the crash site near Seyne-les-Alpes, France. The co-pilot of the doomed Germanwings flight repeatedly sped up the plane as he used the automatic pilot to descend the A320 into the Alps, the French air accident investigation agency said Friday.
(Yves Malenfer / Associated Press)The family of Australian victim Carol Friday, Malcolm Coram and his daughters Philippa, left, and Georgina, visit the memorial of the plane crash in Le Vernet, France.
(Yoan Valat / EPA)Gendarme Bruno Hermignies stands by a bulldozer clearing a path to the crash site near Seyne-les-Alpes, France, on Monday.
(Claude Paris / Associated Press)Firefighters stand in front of candles and flowers on the steps to the Joseph-Koenig high school in Haltern, Germany, before a memorial service.
(Martin Meissner / Associated Press)Police stand in front of the home of the parents of Andreas Lubitz, copilot on Germanwings flight 9525, in Montabaur, Germany. Lubitz divided his time between his parents’ home and an apartment in Duesseldorf.
(Thomas Lohnes / Getty Images)Authorities carry a computer and other items from the home of the parents of Andreas Lubitz, copilot in a flight that crashed in southern France this week.
(Thomas Lohnes / Getty Images)Relatives of the Germanwings Airbus A320 crash victims gather during a remembrance ceremony as rescuers hold flags of the passengers’ nationalities near the village of Le Vernet, France, on March 26.
(Pascal Guyot / AFP/Getty Images)Relatives of victims of the Germanwings Airbus A320 crash arrive in Seyne-des-Alpes, France, near where the aircraft went down, on March 26.
(Jeff Pachoud / AFP/Getty Images)An investigator is lifted by helicopter on March 26 as officials work at the crash site of the Germanwings Airbus A320 that went down in the French Alps.
(Anne-Christine Poujoulat / AFP/Getty Images)Investigators work on March 26 amid the debris of the Germanwings Airbus A320 that crashed in the French Alps.
(Anne-Christine Poujoulat / AFP/Getty Images)A photo appearing on multiple Facebook pages is said to show Andreas Lubitz, the co-pilot of Germanwings Flight 9525.
()A photo shows the cockpit of the crashed Germanwings Airbus A320 at the airport in Duesseldorf, Germany, prior to plane’s crash in the French Alps.
(Marius Palmen / European Pressphoto Agency)German national team players observe a minute of silence for victims of the Germanwings Flight 9525 crash before a game against Australia in Kaiserslautern.
(Fredrik von Erichsen / European Pressphoto Agency)Flags fly at half-staff at a castle in Schwerin in eastern Germany on March 25 in memory of the victims of the Germanwings crash.
(Jens Buttner / AFP/Getty Images)A youth center in Seyne-les-Alpes, France, was established as a funeral chapel after the Germanwings crash.
(Daniel Karmann / European Pressphoto Agency)One of the subtler ironies of the Germanwings accident — though the word “accident” may no longer be appropriate — is that the airplane involved used so-called fly-by-wire technology. The flight crew’s control inputs go not to the ailerons and elevators, but instead to a computer that decides how to execute the pilots’ commands. One of the functions of this technology, which is present in all new airliners, is to guard against faulty or ill-advised pilot actions.
But the pilot still has the last word. If he chooses, he can override the computers. It is one of the axioms of aviation, handed down over generations, that the pilot’s authority — presumably for the safety of the flight and its passengers — is absolute. He is a monarch, and the airplane is his kingdom.
And so, while computers can protect us against pilot error, they cannot defend us against pilot malice. No algorithm, no existing technology, can stop a pilot bent on killing himself, with a plane full of people as collateral damage — as appears to have happened in the Alps.
We have now learned something about the complex locks and overrides in the armored doors that are supposed to separate a flight crew from a terrorist passenger. Some committee must have labored long and hard over the imagined action-movie scenarios that would result in their destruction. But the task of designing those doors, after 9/11, was not a riddle about a chicken, a fox, a river and a raft, to which a sufficiently patient and logical person could arrive at a correct answer. When passengers, flight attendants and pilots are all potential enemies, what combination of locks and protocols can possibly work?
Suicide by airplane is very rare. In most cases — all cases, that I know of, in private planes, which are the majority — the pilot is alone. In the last couple of decades, however, there have been five or six instances in which a flight crew member deliberately crashed a plane full of passengers.
The strange stew of malice, despair and grandiosity that leads people to unite suicide with slaughter is hardly a specialty of airline pilots, however; we encounter it regularly in the news, in instances as disparate as the suicide bomber in the mosque and the distraught father who kills his children and then himself.
As airline engines, avionics and airframes become more and more reliable, pilots continue to be the cause of most accidents — although human error finds fewer opportunities in the increasingly automated skies. From shortly after takeoff to shortly before touchdown, airplanes fly themselves while pilots talk with controllers and one another and punch data into flight management systems. In dense fog, with suitably equipped airports and airplanes, completely blind landings are made. Oddly, it is the takeoff, arguably the simplest part of flying an airplane, that has so far eluded automation — more because of the resistance of pilots than the difficulty of the task. Eventually even that may change. If cars can be made self-driving — as supposedly they can — then airplanes too could perhaps be freed of the last layer of unreliability: the crew.
But how would you feel, boarding a plane, if there were no one up front to fly it? Would you not rather see a human crew? Most people would. We cannot help feeling that the agility and resourcefulness of the human mind may some day be needed to save us from some unforeseeable mischance of flight. It’s happened before, and will surely happen again.
We overlook even egregious pilot errors — Colgan Air, Air France 447 and TransAsia are recent examples — in our faith that human beings are ultimately more reliable than machines. What makes the Germanwings accident so terrible to contemplate is that, if it turns out to be true that the first officer deliberately crashed the plane, it offends our sense of common humanity. We may forget mistakes, but we cannot forgive a betrayal.
Peter Garrison is a pilot and writes an accident-analysis column for Flying Magazine.
Follow the Opinion section on Twitter @latimesopinion and Facebook
Must-read stories from the L.A. Times
Get all the day's most vital news with our Today's Headlines newsletter, sent every weekday morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
More From the Los Angeles Times
-
Biden’s speech will come just before his 100th day in office, and will provide him an opportunity to update the American public on his progress toward fulfilling his promises.
-
Reports of blood clots among those who got Johnson & Johnson’s COVID-19 vaccine may make some recipients anxious. Here’s how to handle those feelings.
-
The head of the IRS calculated that tax evasion in the U.S. may be much more than previous estimates from the federal government.
-
A white police officer from Wisconsin who was investigated and cleared for shooting and injuring a Black man during a domestic dispute has returned from administrative leave.