For these senators, immigration is a personal story
WASHINGTON — Behind the desk at his office in the Capitol, the Senate’s assistant majority leader, Richard J. Durbin of Illinois, keeps a framed copy of his mother’s naturalization certificate.
She was a toddler when she arrived from Lithuania and was 26 when she became a citizen. She had grown old by the time her son asked what had happened to her citizenship papers.
“She wasn’t in the best of shape then, but she pops up off the couch, and she’s gone three minutes — tops — and comes in with this old, beat-up brown envelope, hands it to me,” Durbin recalled in an interview this year. A slip of paper fluttered out, the filing fee receipt she had kept all those years.
“That was my mom. When we talk about immigration, I kind of have a personal side to the story.”
As the immigration debate unfolds, senators have begun telling their own stories of immigration and the immigrants they’ve known, a treasure trove of American history spilling forward on the Senate floor.
The narratives, some recited with fervor, others more tentatively, show how the deeply personal experiences of senators and their families inform the political debate — on both sides.
Two Republican sons of immigrants, Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida and Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas, both 42, share similar family histories as children of Cuban exiles. But they take radically different approaches to changing the nation’s immigration laws.
Rubio, an architect and leader of the immigration overhaul effort, speaks of his parents landing in the U.S. before he was born, after leaving Cuba a couple of years before Fidel Castro’s revolution. His mom clerked at a Kmart while his dad tended bar in ballrooms like those where Rubio now gives soaring political speeches.
Cruz, who was born an American citizen in Canada, has become one of the most prominent opponents of the bill Rubio champions, which would provide current unauthorized immigrants a path to citizenship. He tells his father’s story of having fled Cuba, washed dishes to pay his way through college, married an American woman and started a business.
Those who are familiar with immigrants and the experiences of newcomers are likely to empathize with the problems inherent in the nation’s complex system of immigration laws, even if they do not always agree on what policy conclusions to draw, experts say.
“If they don’t know undocumented immigrants, they’re afraid of them,” said Gabriel Sanchez, an associate professor at the University of New Mexico and director of research at Latino Decisions, a polling firm. “It really just comes down to basic psychology: You remove the fear factor and it allows people to think about it from a different perspective.”
Before he was elected to public office, Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) was executive director at the Goldwater Institute. He was a fiscally conservative budget hawk in a state that has taken a hard line against illegal immigration.
But in his youth, Flake, a fifth-generation Arizonan, grew up alongside migrant farmworkers from Mexico — many of them without legal immigration status — on his family’s cattle ranch and farm in the northern part of the state.
“I could never look at the population we have here in Arizona — it’s a big population of those who are here illegally — and put them all in one criminal class,” said Flake, who is a member of the bipartisan group that crafted the immigration overhaul proposal. “It’s never rung true for me.”
Newly elected Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii), the only immigrant serving in the Senate, arrived as a young girl when her mother fled what the senator has described as an abusive husband in Japan.
The 7-year-old did not know English when she made the ocean voyage on the passenger ship President Cleveland.
Landing in Honolulu, she worked as a student cashier in elementary school to pay for her lunches. A few years later, in 1959, when Hawaii became a state, she became a naturalized citizen.
“The amazing thing about this country is millions of families have stories like mine,” Hirono said in the Senate, where she is working to extend certain immigration rights to women and families. “If I had not been able to come to this country, who knows where I’d be today. But I can tell you that I would not have had anything close to the opportunities this great country has given to me.”
Some senators acknowledge that their immigrant tales may not be the most original, but the stories help guide their thinking.
Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) has shrugged that part of her story is a cliche — Swiss grandparents on her mother’s side who came to the U.S. and opened a cheese shop in Wisconsin. Her father’s father, from Slovenia, mined iron ore.
But their granddaughter became Minnesota’s first woman elected to the Senate.
“I stand here today on the shoulders of immigrants,” she said in the Senate last week. “It could not have been possible in a country that didn’t open its arms to the risk-takers, pilgrims and pioneers of the world.”
And other senators have not made their stories fully public, even as they are near to the heart.
Sen. Rob Portman (R-Ohio) was so charmed after paddling “every inch” of the Rio Grande during a college kayak trip that he returned to work summers on a cattle ranch along the Texas border with Mexico.
“It influenced my thinking a lot,” Portman said in a recent interview.
“It’s not practical to have a mass deportation,” he said. “People who are coming here illegally are not coming to take advantage of our system; they’re coming to find a job to take care of their families.”
As the immigration debate opened in the Senate, Durbin retold his family’s story on the Senate floor. The wonder in his voice was almost audible.
“I am sure my grandmother never imagined that one of her grandchildren would be standing here today representing the state of Illinois in the Senate of the United States,” Durbin said. “That is my story, that is my family’s story, and it is America’s story.”
Must-read stories from the L.A. Times
Get all the day's most vital news with our Today's Headlines newsletter, sent every weekday morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.