Jeb Bush increases attacks on Obamacare, pledges replacement

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush announces his plan to repeal and replace President Obama's healthcare law, Tuesday at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H.

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush announces his plan to repeal and replace President Obama’s healthcare law, Tuesday at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H.

(Jim Cole / Associated Press)

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, who is laboring to make inroads with potential Republican voters flocking to Donald Trump and Ben Carson, is intensifying attacks on the Affordable Care Act and making renewed pledges to repeal and replace the 2010 law.

“There’s no way to fix it,” Bush said Tuesday in a speech at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H., promising to “get rid of all of Obamacare.”

“You can’t fix something that is a failure from the start,” he said.

Bush’s 10-page replacement plan is now the most detailed alternative being offered by any of the top-tier GOP candidates.

It represents a stark contrast with Democratic front-runner Hillary Rodham Clinton, who has been campaigning on the health’s law historic expansion of health coverage while proposing new regulations to protect consumers from rising drug prices and runaway medical bills.


Bush’s strong repeal call also represents something of a change for the struggling presidential hopeful, who in the past has expressed skepticism about congressional Republicans’ repeated efforts to roll back the law.

Most Americans want to modify and improve the law, polls show. But repeal remains popular with the GOP base.

Bush’s blueprint, which he is calling “The Conservative Plan for 21st Century Health,” largely hews to mainstream conservative proposals for loosening federal oversight of healthcare.

The former governor promises to lower costs by deregulating the health-insurance industry and freeing health plans from mandates that they cover basic benefits, a key requirement of the health law that President Obama signed five years ago.

Bush’s plan would also create a new system for providing tax breaks to help Americans who don’t get coverage at work, replacing the current law’s subsidies for low- and middle-income Americans.

And he would redesign the 50-year-old Medicaid safety net that now covers some 70 million poor Americans by giving states block grants and letting them redesign their programs.

But the plan, like many alternatives offered by critics of the Affordable Care Act, does not include key details, including how it would be paid for.

Bush’s tax credits and other government assistance would likely cost hundreds of billions of dollars, yet Bush has proposed to scrap the taxes and other revenue that generate hundreds of billions of dollars in the current law.

The only revenue source in Bush’s plan -- a new cap on the tax break for employer-provided coverage -- is similar to a tax in the current law that is under attack by Democrats and Republicans.

Also unclear is the effect of the plan on tens of millions of Americans who depend on government assistance to get health coverage.

Capping Medicaid expenditures and tying assistance to a consumer’s age, as Bush would do, rather than to income, would almost certainly leave many low- and middle-income Americans with fewer protections.

Twitter: @noamlevey