Kamala Harris promises teachers a raise if elected president

Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) addresses a campaign rally Sunday at Morehouse College in Atlanta.
(Curtis Compton / Associated Press)

In the first major policy proposal of her presidential campaign, Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) is focused on boosting the salaries of teachers.

Harris’ campaign says her plan is an unprecedented investment in teacher pay and toward programs dedicated to teacher recruitment, training and professional development. In new details released Tuesday, the Democrat’s campaign described the underpayment of teachers as a “national failure that’s holding America back” and said that “we’ve failed to give teachers the respect and resources they deserve.”

The issue is hardly new. For years, teachers have said they are underpaid and their schools are underfunded. Teachers in more than a half-dozen states have walked out of their classrooms in protest in recent months. But in wading into the education spending debate in her first policy rollout, Harris is set to capitalize on a debate that has been boiling in districts across the country and that is critical to the nation’s teachers unions, which have been key players in Democratic Party politics in many regions.

Harris previewed her plan in a Houston speech Saturday, saying that “you can judge a society by the way it treats its children, and one of the greatest expressions of love that a society can give to its children is educating those children with resources they need.”

Traditionally, elementary and secondary schools receive most of their budget dollars from state and local governments, with the federal government providing less than 10% of total funding. But Harris is calling for the federal government to immediately invest a base level of funding into each state with the goal of closing the teacher pay gap — the difference in compensation for teachers and similar professionals with college degrees. Then, Harris’ campaign says, for every dollar a state contributes to increasing the pay of teachers, the federal government will invest an additional four dollars.


Harris’ campaign says that under the plan, the average teacher in the U.S. will receive a $13,500 a year raise.

The campaign estimates this will cost $315 billion over a decade, paid for by strengthening the estate tax and closing tax loopholes that benefit the rich.

While it is early in the Democratic primary and the American Federation of Teachers has not backed any Democrat running for president, the head of the AFT praised Harris’ plan.

Randi Weingarten, the group’s president, said in an interview that there’s been a “woeful underinvestment in public schools throughout the country” and that Harris had proposed a “bold, smart, strategic and decisive proposal that will help solve the problem of how we recruit and retain great teachers.”

“What she’s doing is saying personnel is absolutely key in terms of teaching, and she is investing in our personnel, she’s investing in teaching,” she said.

Catherine Brown, a senior fellow at the liberal Center for American Progress, said that states have been systemically disinvesting in public education for a decade, particularly in more conservative parts of the country.

“I think it would be better if states would step up and pay teachers what they deserve. I think we can all agree it’s a very hard job, a foundational job to our democracy, and they are underpaid,” she said. “I think that states are not stepping up — in particular, conservative states. What we’ve seen are states led by GOP leaders have disinvested in education systematically in favor of giving tax cuts.”

The issue of teacher pay and education spending has been cause for strikes in a number of states. In Harris’ hometown of Oakland, striking teachers recently went back to their classrooms following a weeklong strike after union members voted to approve a contract agreement that provided pay raises.

In 2016-17, the average annual salary for a public school teacher nationally was $58,950, down slightly from the previous year, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

Overall, 78% of Americans said that’s not enough, according to an April 2018 poll from the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research. Just 15% think teachers are paid the right amount, while 6% think they’re paid too much.

Harris’ campaign emphasized that education funding was a national issue, affecting both urban centers and rural schools, but explicitly singled out the area along Interstate 95 in South Carolina known as the “Corridor of Shame” because of its underperforming schools. The region gained that nickname from a 2005 documentary that depicted decrepit conditions and deteriorating buildings.

U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos recently toured the region, and South Carolina lawmakers have said that improving the state’s education system is a priority this year. On her own South Carolina trip in February, Harris weighed in on the teacher pay issue.

“You know, right here in South Carolina, we need to pay our teachers what they are worth,” Harris said at a North Charleston town hall, adding later: “For most of us who ever have a microphone like this in our hands, we have never achieved this kind of success without the teachers and the public education system that made us who we are.”

Harris’ plan also includes investments in teacher recruitment, training, retention and professional development, her campaign says. It says there will be a multibillion-dollar investment in programs at historically black colleges and universities and other minority-serving institutions.