Growing list of Trump GOP challengers revives fears of 2016 repeat

Nikki Haley smiles and points her fingers skyward onstage
Former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley speaks at an annual leadership meeting of the Republican Jewish Coalition in Las Vegas on Nov. 19.
(John Locher / Associated Press)

Memories of the tumultuous 2016 Republican primary hung over the Las Vegas ballroom last weekend during the first major gathering of the party’s potential contenders for the 2024 presidential nomination.

No fewer than 10 White House prospects stepped onto the stage to pitch their plans to fix the nation — and their party. The details varied, but most speeches had
a sense of defiance rarely seen since former President Trump seized control of the party six years ago.

Their central message: Trump can and should be beaten.

Nikki Haley, the former U.S. ambassador to the United Nations under Trump, pledged in April that she wouldn’t challenge the former president if he ran again. But Saturday night, facing hundreds of cheering Republicans, she vowed to give “1,000%” to a White House bid if she decided to get in.


“I’ve never lost an election, and I’m not going to start now,” she said as the crowd roared.

But as the donors and activists who gathered for the Republican Jewish Coalition’s two-day leadership conference applauded, perhaps no one was cheering louder than Trump himself from his Florida estate.

Trump’s team and a growing number of anxious donors and Republican operatives believe that the GOP’s emboldened 2024 class may already be unintentionally re-creating the conditions that enabled Trump’s success in 2016. That year, a crowded Republican field splintered the primary electorate and allowed Trump to become the party’s presidential nominee despite failing to win more than 35% of the vote in any of the first three primary contests.

In the earliest days of the 2024 season, the 2016 parallels are striking.

As then, Trump is viewed with suspicion within his party, his standing weakened considerably after several loyalists lost what were believed to be winnable races in this month’s midterm election. And most of all, a parade of ambitious Republicans is lining up to take him on.

A small but growing group of Republican operatives is warning Trump’s critics that the only way to defeat him is to rally behind a much smaller group of alternatives.

Eric Levine, a New York-based donor who attended the weekend gathering, called on his party to embrace no more than two or three candidates — and to move with real urgency.


“I don’t think we have the luxury of waiting,” said Levine, who has raised millions of dollars for Republicans in recent years and began speaking out against Trump only after the midterms. “If he becomes the Republican brand, the party is going to be destroyed.”

For now, at least, Trump’s rivals don’t appear to be heeding his warning.

The most popular alternative to Trump, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, isn’t likely to enter the race until the late spring, his allies say. But in his keynote address to the gathering Saturday night, he left little doubt that 2024 was on his mind.

“In times like these, there is no substitute for victory,” DeSantis said, repeatedly citing his overwhelming reelection earlier this month. “We’ve got a lot more to do, and I have only begun to fight.”

In interviews, several other would-be Republican candidates and their aides indicated they would probably wait until spring or summer to enter the race, should they decide to run. That’s even after Trump formally launched his 2024 campaign last week.

How a team of cyber experts and lawyers came together in the days after the 2020 election to try to find information suggesting fraud, in an attempt to keep Trump in office despite his defeat.

June 17, 2022

New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu, who isn’t ruling out a 2024 run, said Trump’s early announcement had created no sense of urgency; it simply highlighted his weakened political standing.

“I think all of us understand how little of a factor he’s going to be,” Sununu said in an interview. “He’s not scaring anybody out. Anyone who wants to run is going to run. It’ll be fun. It’ll be a wide-open race.”

Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan said it’s much too early to worry about winnowing the field.

“I think more voices, more potential choices,” said Hogan, who is openly weighing a 2024 bid. “Trump needs to be tested. People need to go out there and be willing to stand up to him.”

Hogan continued: “I don’t think anyone’s going to listen to narrowing the field. Everybody’s going to say, ‘I should be the guy,’ ‘I should be the guy,’ ‘We should all be the guy.’”

Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, a failed 2016 presidential contender who led Trump’s White House transition efforts during the campaign, said he expected seven or eight major candidates to ultimately enter the 2024 race, “which is manageable” compared with the 16 who ran against Trump in 2016.

“A lot of those people are fishing out of the Trump pond,” Christie said, suggesting that prospects such as DeSantis and Michael R. Pompeo are “MAGA guys” who would steal support from Trump’s base in a way that creates opportunities for others — like himself.

Christie dismissed any talk of winnowing the field so soon. “We should all rally behind someone? OK, who? I don’t think there’s any obvious choice,” he said.

Trump advisors initially hoped that he might clear the field with his early announcement. They now believe a crowded field will help him by splitting the anti-Trump vote, like in 2016. Trump won the New Hampshire and South Carolina primaries that year with just 35% and 32% of the vote, respectively. Seven others divided the overwhelming majority of the vote.

Trump’s team notes that his loyalists in key 2022 primary elections from Arizona to New Hampshire to Pennsylvania won their GOP nominations with between 30% and 40% of the vote — a base of support the team believes will continue to be his floor in the 2024 primary.

Former New Hampshire GOP Chair Jennifer Horn, who led the state party in 2016, said the growing number of likely 2024 candidates “should know better” this time around.

“They are feeding exactly the kind of environment that Trump needs to win,” Horn warned. “If past is prologue, we’ve all got reason to be concerned.”

And while there was evidence of Trump fatigue at the weekend conference, he received a warm reception when he appeared via teleconference on Saturday. The crowd cheered loudly when he noted his success in moving the U.S. Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem.

But there was notable silence when he repeated his baseless claims about his 2020 election loss. “The election was rigged. And it’s too bad it was, and Israel lost a lot,” Trump told the packed ballroom. “You better hope that a certain person wins the election in 2024.”

And with Trump already a declared candidate, some operatives worry it’s much later than his challengers think.

The first presidential primary debate could be just nine months away, using the 2016 presidential primary calendar as a guide. By the summer of 2015, there were already 17 candidates in the race.

One of them was Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, who is considering another run in 2024.

Speaking to reporters in Las Vegas, Cruz said Trump and his loyalists deserved some of the blame for the weaker-than-expected results in the midterms.

“I’m frustrated when my party fields candidates with no realistic chance of success,” he said.

But when asked about the 2024 presidential contest, Cruz said only that there were several candidates “clearly positioning to run” against Trump, and that he believed “voters can and should sort that out.”

Pompeo, Trump’s former secretary of State, is among those positioning themselves to run, and implicitly criticized the former president repeatedly onstage over the weekend without mentioning his name. Instead, Pompeo said conservatives deserve leaders “who fight for them, not ourselves or our own egos.”

And he acknowledged the looming 2024 primary.

“Who knows — the next time we’re together we could be onstage, multiple podiums,” Pompeo said. “Who knows who else might be there and what nicknames we’ll have?”

AP writer Jill Colvin in New York contributed to this report.