‘We are the shame of Europe,’ angry medics tell French President Emmanuel Macron

French President Emmanuel Macron at a school outside Paris
French President Emmanuel Macron, wearing a protective face mask, speaks with schoolchildren in earlier this month during a class in Poissy, outside Paris.
(Ian Langsdon / Pool via AP)

Angry doctors and nurses faced off with French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday, demanding better pay and reform of a once-renowned public health system that found itself quickly overwhelmed by tens of thousands of coronavirus patients.

“We are desperate. We no longer believe in you,” said a nurse who confronted Macron at the leading Pitie-Salpetriere Hospital in Paris, adding that she was using a long-expired surgical mask. “We are the shame of Europe.”

“That’s not true,” the president countered — but he could barely get a word in as medics peppered him with their grievances.

Apparently anticipating such tensions and fearing that they could further hurt Macron’s image, the president’s office did not allow a single video, photo or radio reporter on the visit.


Macron acknowledged mistakes in reforming the national hospital system, which has faced decades of cost cuts, leaving medical facilities in one of the world’s richest countries short of staff, masks and breathing machines needed to fight the COVID-19 crisis.

“For months I was asking for equipment, and we had only three days to fight against the virus,” Martin Hirsch, head of the Paris hospital network, told Macron. France’s infections abruptly multiplied over a short period in March.

French scientists say they may have identified a possible case of the coronavirus in France dating back to December.

As the virus raced across France in March and saturated several hospitals, Macron had to deploy the armed forces to build the country’s first-ever peacetime field hospital and move patients and doctors around in military transport jets and specially fitted high-speed trains.

France’s hospital problems long predate the coronavirus crisis. Emergency-room workers held strikes and protests for months last year demanding more hiring and funding after years of job losses.

Macron’s government announced a plan last year to address the growing concerns, and pledged bonuses for medical staff when the virus hit. But “we undoubtedly made a mistake in the strategy,” the president acknowledged Friday.

“It was a great strategy, but we should have done it 10 years ago,” he told frustrated hospital staff.

Macron promised to launch a new investment plan while the virus crisis is still raging, without offering details. “Trust will only come if we move fast,” he said.

As the coronavirus scythed through French nursing homes, one took drastic action to save its residents — and succeeded.

An angry reception met Macron on a visit to the same hospital in February, as the president sought to show he was successfully managing the virus. Leading neurologist Dr. Francois Salachas confronted Macron to describe how the crisis — which then was just beginning — had already revealed weaknesses in French hospitals caused by years of budget cuts.

The damaging exchange aggravated public frustration with Macron and is likely why his office tightly restricted media access to Friday’s hospital visit. The Elysee Palace didn’t give a reason for the unusual decision.

As Macron sat around a table with top doctors, the reception was forthright.

“We cannot go back like before,” said Thomas Similowski, head of the hospitals’ medical commission, calling for a rethink of medical training and more flexibility to deal with new threats.

Macron then met with unions, who demanded wage hikes to keep nurses from quitting the profession and further worsening staff shortages.

The iconic loaf and the French daily ritual of buying it have become loaded with moral, civic and public health considerations that could never have been imagined.

And then, as the president headed for the exit, irate nurses blocked his way.

“That’s nice, the bonus ... but what we want is a raise,” declared the nurse who had said she was using an expired mask. She did not give her name.

“For a major European country, this is not normal,” said another.

French authorities say more than 27,000 people with the virus have died in hospitals and nursing homes, compared with about 7,000 in neighboring Germany, which tested much more widely than France and entered the crisis with six times as many intensive care beds.