Carl Bernstein tweets list of GOP senators who he says are contemptuous of Trump

Journalist Carl Bernstein of Watergate investigation fame
Veteran journalist Carl Bernstein attends the 2018 PEN Literary Gala in New York in May 2018.
(Evan Agostini / Invision)

Former Watergate sleuth Carl Bernstein shared on Twitter the names of 21 Republican senators who he says have “repeatedly expressed contempt” for President Trump and his fitness for the nation’s highest office.

Bernstein’s post was quickly condemned Monday by some of those he named on Twitter — an eyebrow-raising move from the former Washington Post reporter who, with colleague Bob Woodward in the 1970s, penned scoops that led to the resignation of President Nixon.

Bernstein said he wasn’t violating any confidentiality pledges in listing the senators. He said he learned of the politicians’ purported private feelings through conversations with some of their colleagues, staff members, lobbyists and White House aides.


“With few exceptions, their craven public silence has helped enable Trump’s most grievous conduct — including undermining and discrediting the U.S. electoral system,” Bernstein tweeted late Sunday.

Bernstein, who serves as a political analyst for CNN, declined a request to talk about his posts.

Many Washington reporters have talked about lawmakers who have privately expressed reservations about Trump but rarely attached names to their stories. Bernstein said he believed several of the Republicans on his list were privately happy about President-elect Joe Biden’s victory.

It’s time to start preparing for the transfer of power to Biden

Nov. 11, 2020

Michael Zona, a spokesperson for Iowa Sen. Charles E. Grassley, who was on Bernstein’s list, said the characterization was untrue.

“Sen. Grassley has been a strong supporter of the president and at the same time has made it no secret when he disagrees with the president,” Zona said. “There is no difference between what Sen. Grassley says publicly and privately. Washington journalists might be wise to reconsider trafficking in baseless second- and third-hand rumor. It may restore some lost credibility.”

Ohio Sen. Rob Portman “has never talked to Mr. Bernstein, and we don’t know where he’s getting his false information,” said Emily Benavides, the senator’s spokesperson.


Portman, in a column written for the Cincinnati Enquirer on Monday, called on Trump to begin cooperating with Biden on a transition of power.

With no platform and no policies to run on, fearmongering is the only thing left at Trump’s presidential convention.

Aug. 25, 2020

There was no article on CNN’s website about Bernstein’s list on Monday. The veteran reporter appeared on CNN’s “New Day” on Friday and named 15 of the 21 senators he tweeted about two days later.

Roy Gutterman, a Syracuse University professor who specializes in journalism law and ethics, said Bernstein’s approach was unusual and noted the journalist’s frequent criticism of Trump.

“I don’t know if what he did today would fit the model of what he staked his reputation on, which was hard-core investigative reporting,” Gutterman said.

It was unsurprising to find Utah Sen. Mitt Romney on Bernstein’s list. Romney is one of the few senior GOP figures to publicly criticize Trump. Last week, speaking of Trump’s pressure to overturn the election results, Romney said it was “difficult to imagine a worse, more undemocratic action by a sitting American president.”

“The senator’s views about the president are well-known by the public,” spokeswoman Liz Johnson said.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Indiana Sen. Todd Young said that Bernstein’s “unsourced rumors” don’t deserve a response and that Young has a great working relationship with Trump.

Meanwhile, Sean Smith, communications director for South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott, said his boss “has never met, talked to or considered interacting with Mr. Bernstein, so no one should give any weight to the baseless accusations of someone who clearly has an ax to grind with the president.”